retroSoC/docs/ip/tiny-soc-verification.md

Tiny MCU Verification Record

TINY-R2-P8/P9/P10 human acceptance (2026-10-25)

The maintainer explicitly confirmed human acceptance of TINY-R2-P8, TINY-R2-P9 and TINY-R2-P10 in the development session. The accepted checkpoint is 4466ad0e97b0bce4b9174dfd88dd199fca344ad5 on dev, which raises the ICS55 TINY_P9_NETLIST_WALL_TIMEOUT default to 14400 seconds. All seven CI workflows for that commit completed successfully (quality run 40098377127, development-environment 40098377121, smoke 40098377168, gf180 40098377223, sky130 40098377238, ics55 40098377215, ihp130 40098377145).

The refreshed P8 campaign passed on both profiles (evidence roots build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-23-19-00-f5281272385f/meta/tiny-r2-p8/ and build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-23-19-01-63130ad79b73/meta/tiny-r2-p8/): the 28-test focused suite, full firmware with P8_RESULT code=0 (2534635 cycles on ICS55, 2283118 on IHP130), synthesis, netlist boot (36449/36069 cycles), observational STA and capture/report.

P9 has all six source-bound full-frame workloads workload_passed (RECOVERY 3097113, QVGA_RGB565 18601599, VGA_YUV422 73938934 cycles, identical on both PDKs) and complete refreshed backend chains on both profiles (IHP130 build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-23-18-59-6879efac2bd8/meta/tiny-r2-p9/backend/ with DVP 175649 cycles; ICS55 build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-24-15-03-8d025610711f/meta/tiny-r2-p9/backend/ with SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny cycles=177541 in 12886.6 seconds).

P10 acceptance rests on two complete reports plus the P7 lifecycle legs. IHP130: build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-23-18-51-6879efac2bd8/meta/tiny-r2-p10/report/report.json is selected_gates_complete with zero gaps. ICS55: the single-timestamp campaign 2026-10-24-21-30 passed matched, software, audio, camera and backend on the clean accepted commit; build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-24-21-30-8d025610711f/meta/tiny-r2-p10/report/report.json is selected_gates_complete with zero gaps, and all five stage records share execution source digest 13bdfaaaa90d6ec4dbc8d8d6bb541c9221ee2fd529ecdcfeaed28974eea4b6f3. Its netlist-dvp passed with SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny cycles=177541 in 8383.8 seconds on a quiet host; the earlier loaded-host pass needed 13317.1 seconds, motivating the 14400-second budget. P7 lifecycle acceptance passed on both profiles (P7_LIFECYCLE_PASS, 3859487/3863255 cycles).

The retained ICS55 netlist-dvp host timeouts (exit 124) are budget/host runtime evidence, not DUT failures; no verdict rule, forbidden-marker set or TEST_STATUS requirement was weakened and no historical record was relabeled. Full long-running Icarus firmware, complete PR/nightly regression, fresh VGA, physical/PVT/board qualification and final complete-product timing closure remain deferred or unrun as recorded below; observational negative STA, warning deltas and observe-mode metrics are not reclassified. Historical pending-human-review statements below describe their original checkpoints. Generated collector records keep phase_accepted=false; human acceptance is recorded here. This acceptance does not imply final complete-product qualification.

Tiny Icarus behavioral repair (2026-10-22)

The Tiny Icarus behavioral flow failed elaboration with 29 errors on both profiles since the committed R2-P7..P10 observer changes (evidence: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-21-16-31-a257f7b03bdb/sim/iverilog/ and build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-21-16-36-76f15177ba7a/sim/iverilog/; CI runs 39719773195 and 39719773217 failed at the same step). Root cause: the Icarus flow compiles only the sv2v-lowered converted_soc.v, where packed structs become plain vectors and interface ports dissolve, while the dv observers read struct fields hierarchically and tiny_p9_recovery.svh used a string case that crashes Icarus code generation (eval_vec4 assertion).

The repair keeps every observer semantically identical: rtl/tiny/dv/tiny_p8_observers.svh moves a time declaration above its first use; rtl/tiny/dv/tiny_p9_observers.svh reads the identical packed bit ranges through named slice constants (valid in both the Verilator struct view and the sv2v vector view) and reads the XPI APB wires through the top-level interface instance u_xpi_apb4_if (the same nets); tiny_p9_recovery.svh rewrites the string case as an exact-match if/else chain; rtl/tiny/dv/retrosoc_tiny_tb.sv uses the same slice constants. No DUT, Mini, baseline, or verdict-rule change.

Evidence: Icarus compile is clean on both profiles; the R2-P7 Icarus behavioral acceptance now passes with SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny cycles=3859487, flow passed, check passed, no forbidden markers (build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-22-12-16-aae2707c2aa5/sim/iverilog/), matching the Verilator cycle count exactly. Verilator results are unchanged after the rework: SPI-P3 acceptance cycles=1030088 on both profiles (build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-22-12-17-a257f7b03bdb/, build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-22-12-17-76f15177ba7a/), R2-P7 Verilator cycles=3859487 (build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-22-12-17-3f1b609b0b86/), and the +tiny_p9_progress observer output is byte-identical to the pre-repair format. Full Pytest after the rework: 2097 passed, 0 failed, 1 skipped (optional pypdf) in 4042.64 s. Formatting gates pass.

TINY-R2-P10 quality-gate repair (2026-10-18)

The approved repair starts from dev@5b81dea4fe0a68aabb51f42f01422068280192b2 plus the retained P10/P7 worktree. It corrects publication metadata and tests, normalizes exactly one final LF in each of four Make files, and appends these two P10 documents. The maintainer explicitly extended the original eight-file scope to ten files for the DVP circuit catalog and its tests. Production RTL, HAL, public interfaces, profiles, dependencies, warning/metric policy and the reviewed P7 capability correction remain unchanged. No new MISRA deviation is introduced.

The stale PSRAM source reference predates this repair: P8 commit f6190f91 moved the model to rtl/model/ESP_PSRAM64H.sv. The publication's bulk-channel binding also still expected the pre-P9 direct RS_DMA_CHANNEL_BULK call. It now binds both the real RS_DVP_DMA_CHANNEL call and its Tiny/Mini conditional definition; Mini retains bulk channel 3. Negative tests reject a wrong call target or Mini selector without changing the HAL.

After those corrections, the first focused run reaches a further stale DVP diagram binding. The configuration CDC now transports 128 configuration bits plus an epoch and feeds an applied-configuration register. The approved diagram correction records packet assembly, the 129-bit CDC path, payload extraction and the 128-bit applied register before the core. The 42-bit payload FIFO path remains unchanged. Directed tests reject changed CDC width, payload slicing and bypass of the applied register. The isolated diagram fixture now copies dependencies from the additional circuit catalog as well as the embedded circuits; validators are not relaxed.

The execution retains each attempt rather than overwriting failed results:

Check	Recorded result
Initial publication selection	100 passed / 1 skipped / 60 errors; exposed the old DVP diagram binding
Diagram correction before fixture completion	156 passed / 1 skipped / 7 failed; isolated trees lacked the register declaration source
Final publication selection	163 passed / 1 skipped
Build-tool and Tiny configuration selections	2 passed and 6 passed
Format, embedded-C policy/host tests, Ruff, final diff	PASS
One full Pytest execution	2031 passed / 1 skipped, zero failures/errors, 4854.44 s

The sole skip remains the optional pypdf import. Source hashes are unchanged during the full Pytest run. The earlier full-run 10 failures/60 errors remain historical failures; the new run closes the current local publication/Make quality gaps. This is not a new remote CI result.

Before/after configuration and firmware dry-run output is byte-identical for all five build cases; the Mini Verilator lint dry-run also matches. Tiny ICS55/IHP130 and Mini IHP130 each pass PR/nightly definition dry-runs. These are definition checks, not executed complete hardware regressions.

Firmware case	New variant	Build duration	Retained image comparison
Tiny ICS55 P7	ics55-tiny-2026-10-18-17-28-bea5da759fbb	4.462 s	HEX byte-identical
Tiny ICS55 VGA	ics55-tiny-2026-10-18-17-28-7be4ff496b65	4.398 s	HEX byte-identical
Tiny IHP130 P7	ihp130-tiny-2026-10-18-17-28-3f1b609b0b86	4.451 s	HEX byte-identical
Tiny IHP130 VGA	ihp130-tiny-2026-10-18-17-28-28a0c226bed5	4.523 s	HEX byte-identical
Mini IHP130 compatibility	ihp130-2026-10-18-17-28-a2f660e37f72	6.772 s	Compilation only

Each build succeeds without self-owned C compiler warnings and retains its own ELF/HEX/configuration identity. No P7/VGA full-system simulation is repeated. Directed RTL fixtures remain part of the full Pytest execution. The separate reuse audit checks original reports, model/runtime inputs, command equivalence, exact final-LF changes and matching loadable images. Original simulation source digests stay attached to their original runs; no old report or collector allowance is rewritten.

The aggregate evidence root is build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-18-17-28-bea5da759fbb/meta/tiny-r2-p10/quality-repair/. It retains pre-edit.json, approved-extension.json, source archives, command-equivalence.json, firmware-summary.json, pytest-execution-source.json, retained-evidence-audit.json, report.json and validation/ logs/results/JUnit. Each variant above also retains meta/tiny-r2-p10/quality-repair/firmware-record.json. The runbook records the command matrix and ownership boundary.

The report is quality_repair_complete with phase_accepted=false. Full long Icarus/complete supported regression and final physical/PVT/board/ sensor/frequency qualification remain open. Synthesis, netlist and STA are not rerun for these metadata/final-LF changes. Publication identity remains c3de7c602a7ca0f0f9ade9d3ffb59339bc34fb8b; PDF generation, source-baseline refresh and visual qualification are NOT_RUN. The strict source-drift check is preserved. .editorconfig still requests a final newline while the locked mbake default removes it; this repair follows the executable gate and does not approve a formatting-policy change. No commit, push or phase advancement is performed.

TINY-R2-P10 P7 capability correction (2026-10-18)

The approved follow-up repairs the stale P7 acceptance-image capability check on dev@5b81dea4fe0a68aabb51f42f01422068280192b2 plus the retained P10 worktree. tiny_r2_p7.c now requires the exact DVP-inclusive 0x00007FFF through an application-private constant. Production TargetMask, HAL, register ABI, profiles, dependencies and quality policy are unchanged. The architecture's 0x0003FFFF allowed mask is not an implemented-target expectation. No new MISRA deviation is introduced.

The added cross-source checks read the real u_sysctrl parameter and firmware startup guard. They reject the old capability, unimplemented target bits, removed/masked comparisons, and missing or ambiguous source definitions. The focused selection passes 14 tests (including existing register parity). Software format/policy/host tests, Ruff and the final diff check pass.

One complete Pytest execution reports 1956 passed, 10 failed, 60 errors and 1 skipped in 4841.86 seconds. Its 70 failure/error nodes exactly match the previous full run and all reference the existing publication dependency on rtl/mini/dv/model/ESP_PSRAM64H.sv. They remain failures; the optional pypdf skip and existing Make-format issues are not repaired here. Shared validation, JUnit results and pytest-baseline-comparison.json are retained under the ICS55 evidence directory's validation/ below.

Both PDKs pass PR/nightly dry-runs; the expansions remain identical per PDK. Each P7 Verilator image is rebuilt in the fresh 2026-10-18-14-51 variant and executed exactly once, without automatic retries:

PDK	Verdict / cycles	Flow duration	Profiles	CPU gated cycles / DMA responses while gated / warm resets
ICS55	PASS / 3803591	1162.871 s	2, 3, 0	71627 / 64 / 1
IHP130	PASS / 3799823	561.606 s	1, 0	71634 / 64 / 1

Both commands and standard checkers succeed, with exactly one SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny, one P7_LIFECYCLE_PASS, required profile coverage and no forbidden error marker. There are no self-owned C compiler warnings. Source, runtime/filelist and pre-launch ELF/HEX/model identities match after execution. The normal +p7_monitor cold-reset assertions execute; the diagnostic-only P7_COLD_RESET_PASS marker is not required. These are logical clock/lifecycle checks, not physical frequency qualification. CPU/main-SRAM SYS and divided XPI MEM retain their existing distinct meanings.

New evidence directories are:

• build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-18-14-51-bea5da759fbb/meta/tiny-r2-p10/p7-capability-fix/.
• build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-18-14-51-3f1b609b0b86/meta/tiny-r2-p10/p7-capability-fix/.

Each retains p7-record.json, source-before.json, runtime-before.json, launch-identity.json, command logs/results, vga-reuse-audit.json and report.json. The shared pre-edit.json verifies both original VGA executions against the actual source before this correction and records the original compiler commands, binaries, logs, source archives and tool identities. The new audit proves the subsequent P7 C edit is not consumed by the VGA build and that its runtime/generated inputs are unchanged. Test/documentation changes are recorded separately. Original VGA execution digests and measurements remain attached to their original binaries; no simulation is repeated and no collector whitelist or old report is rewritten.

This closes the selected P7 Verilator gap and retains the two passed VGA executions. Reports use selected_followup_complete with phase_accepted=false. The failed 09:20 P7 attempts below remain real failures on their original source. Full long Icarus/complete supported regression, separate publication/Make-format repairs and final physical/PVT/board/sensor qualification remain open. No synthesis, netlist, STA or physical flow is rerun for this acceptance-image correction; earlier evidence retains its original attribution. No commit, push or phase advancement is performed.

TINY-R2-P10 P7 and VGA follow-up (2026-10-18)

The maintainer approved one P7 Verilator lifecycle execution and one full VGA/YUV422 execution per PDK, preserving the existing P10 candidate based on 5b81dea4fe0a68aabb51f42f01422068280192b2. Only this ledger and the P10 runbook are edited; no RTL, firmware, HAL, profile, dependency or quality-policy input is changed. New evidence uses timestamp 2026-10-18-09-20; the 2026-10-17 reports below keep their original identities and scope.

Both Tiny PR/nightly dry-runs pass and expand to identical commands per PDK. This is matrix-definition evidence, not an executed complete regression. The original P7/P9 producer phase IDs remain in their records; P10 consumes these follow-up results without accepting another phase.

PDK	P7 lifecycle image	Full VGA/YUV422 image
ICS55	FAIL, firmware code 1, simulator exit 1, 361.667 s	PASS, 13598.239 s, 73938869 cycles
IHP130	FAIL, firmware code 1, simulator exit 1, 268.512 s	PASS, 9269.826 s, 73938869 cycles

The P7 failure is a stale acceptance-image expectation. The firmware at app/apps/ci_smoke/tiny_r2_p7.c:133 requires target_capability == 0x3fff. The DVP-inclusive integration sets TargetMask=0x7fff in rtl/tiny/top/retrosoc_tiny.sv; tiny_sysctrl.sv returns that mask at TARGET_CAP and crt/src/hal/rcu.c copies it into the snapshot. The retained firmware disassembly still compares against 0x3fff. Both simulations report SIM_TEST_FAIL code=1 before any P7_CLOCK_COMMIT, so current-revision clock transition, WFI/DMA gating and warm-reset coverage remain unclosed. This mismatch is the first established blocker; the later lifecycle checks were not reached and need a fresh approved run after the fixture repair.

Git attribution identifies the old expectation in bc48cec74a8f3cec731c4853ac0380f9ae32c35b and the DVP-inclusive mask in 8f5630fb41257098b30153eeb50248bb63ebfb94. Both predate this P10 follow-up. The RTL capability must not be reduced to satisfy the stale test. Fixing the acceptance image and adding a hardware/firmware capability-consistency check requires the next approved implementation scope; no such fix or retry is performed here. Historical P7 acceptance remains attributed to its old source.

P7 source and pre-launch binary identities were checked again after failure. Its raw build/simulation logs, command results and causal source/commit chain are bound by p7-failure-evidence.json under each follow-up directory:

• build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-18-09-20-bea5da759fbb/meta/tiny-r2-p10/follow-up/.
• build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-18-09-20-3f1b609b0b86/meta/tiny-r2-p10/follow-up/.

Fresh VGA evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-18-09-20-7be4ff496b65/meta/tiny-r2-p9/full-frame/ and build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-18-09-20-28a0c226bed5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/full-frame/. Both profiles verify the 640x480 YUV422 frame, all 614400 payload bytes, 153600 DMA words, 307200 pixels and guards, followed by the 7x3 RGB565 PIO crop with 42 valid/48 stored bytes. Total accepted/delivered FIFO words are 153612, including the twelve PIO words. FIFO high-water is four words and the longest observed backpressure is 489 SAFE24 cycles (20.375 us). Reserving 16 bytes leaves a 480-us no-service budget at the exercised 1-MHz PIXCLK. The original P9 runner, simulator and strict marker checker pass for each profile, with exit zero, exactly one SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny and no forbidden error marker. This closes the fresh full-system VGA/YUV422 Verilator gap for this candidate; it is finite behavioral evidence, not a qualified camera FPS or physical rate.

The generated invocation wrapper compared a parser tuple with the JSON list representation and recorded a false VGA collection failure. Supplemental vga-verification.json checks exact JSON-normalized equality, the original source/build/model/firmware identities, zero self-owned compiler warnings and the strict Tiny verdict. It preserves the original collection error and does not rerun simulation. An independent diagnostic-only P7_COLD_RESET_PASS requirement in that wrapper was not reached by the real P7 failures; it must not be used to convert their code-1 results into passes.

Both follow-up directories contain report.json with status=incomplete, executions_complete=true and phase_accepted=false, because P7 fails. All four simulator executions are complete, exactly once per selected case and PDK. The source and pre-launch binary identities remain unchanged. Full Icarus/complete regression stays deferred; the publication/Make-format failures below still need separate repair approval. Physical/PVT/board/sensor and qualified frequency claims remain final-product obligations. No phase, commit or push is advanced by this follow-up.

TINY-R2-P10 approved implementation campaign (2026-10-17)

The maintainer approved the P10 implementation plan from clean 5b81dea4fe0a68aabb51f42f01422068280192b2. The selected campaign completes the executable performance/application work while keeping complete P10 acceptance pending final regression. Full long Icarus firmware stays deferred to final Tiny qualification. This instruction does not rewrite prior P9 human-acceptance records, historical evidence or the frozen specification.

The P10 runbook defines the exact workload, ownership, measured endpoints, single-execution policy and evidence paths. Default ICS55/PLL-present and IHP130/no-PLL compatibility retain SAFE24. No production RTL, shared SDK ABI, dependency, warning baseline or metrics policy change is introduced. The approved implementation and selected performance/application/backend campaign are complete. Complete P10 acceptance remains pending final regression and human review; no subsequent phase is advanced by these results.

The first P10 focused campaign passes 19 new tests and 286 existing P1/P3/P4/P5/P6/P9 tests (592.46 seconds for the latter), plus C formatting, policy/host tests, Ruff, RTL format/style/readiness, Mini IHP130 firmware and explicit Tiny ICS55/IHP130 PR/nightly plus Mini IHP130 PR dry-runs. Evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-ff4b5cef6eb5/meta/tiny-r2-p10/validation/. The four pre-existing Make-format differences remain. Initial focused setup and observer compiler failures were corrected before measurement; their retained attempts do not replace the successful corrected test reports.

The matched stage passes one execution per retained image: ICS55 flat and banked under variant ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-a0ea4d0cd125, and IHP130 P1 under ihp130-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-bcf62053a831. Each records the original image separately from the current RTL source and verifies complete readback, guards and strict Tiny terminal verdicts. The observed cycle comparisons are:

Matched image / case	Reference cycles	P10 cycles
ICS55 P3 flat / CPU	73911	73911
ICS55 P3 flat / memory	102568	102568
ICS55 P3 flat / DMA16	16974	22829
ICS55 P3 banked / memory	86214	86214
ICS55 P3 banked / DMA16	15802	22805
IHP130 P1 / memory	754159	639438
IHP130 P1 / DMA16	71444	89513

The ICS55 reference is P5's execution of the identical P3 images; IHP130 uses the repaired P1 reference. This is whole-platform evolution, not attribution to an isolated CPU/fabric optimization. The cases include regressions and no predetermined speedup gate. The remaining selected stages are recorded below; the complete supported regression remains unclosed.

The one full Pytest execution completes in 5031.91 seconds with 1937 passed, 10 failed, 60 errors and 1 skipped. All failures/fixture errors are existing publication consumers of rtl/mini/dv/model/ESP_PSRAM64H.sv; the actual shared model remains at rtl/model/ESP_PSRAM64H.sv. Publication sources were not changed. This is not a global CI PASS. IHP130 ordinary acceptance plus P10 audio observations passes under ihp130-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-83113a53b401: both 256-frame audio formats and four WS frames pass, with longest WS wait 3219 PCLK cycles (budget 4800), FIFO peak 15 and complete expected recovery. The two windows observe 2479/7565 cycles of simultaneous issues to multiple SRAM groups; DMA R/W beat overlap in these windows is zero and remains zero in the report. Firmware text is 42764 bytes, BSS 10128 and flat-SRAM space above BSS is 78388 bytes; this is headroom, not a measured worst-case stack.

ICS55 ordinary acceptance plus audio observations also passes under ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-f3e42d54c18b, in 3730.267 seconds. Its WS maximum is 3220 PCLK cycles, FIFO peak 15, and the two measured bank-overlap windows are 2460/7520 cycles. Both PDKs retain 57 direct-background jobs in the 16-bit case and 39 finite-chain jobs in the 24-bit case; these finite service windows are not fixed-work architectural speedup comparisons.

IHP130's P10 backend completes under ihp130-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-8232fa11e7f3. Boot passes at 36069 cycles (641.742 seconds), compact DVP at 175649 cycles (3074.530 seconds). The structural audit reports 32 main, six Crypto and zero PLL macros. STA command execution succeeds but setup WNS/TNS remain -284.47/-11105854.00 ns and hold WNS/TNS -0.49/-141.45 ns. Standalone warnings retain exit 2; metrics remain observe-mode PASS. No timing closure or physical qualification follows.

The ICS55 software stage completes the other six P3 images once on the same compiled model as the matched stage, under ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-a0ea4d0cd125/meta/tiny-r2-p10/software/. All eight images retain their original HEX/ELF/compiler/layout identities. The following current-model cycles are software comparisons, separate from the same-image architectural comparisons above:

P3 image	CPU	CPU copy	DMA16	Contention
COMPAT Os flat	98586	135381	25301	401857
TINY_PERF O2 flat	73911	102568	22829	301181
TINY_PERF O2 LTO flat	73919	98504	21098	299414
TINY_PERF O3 flat	73911	102568	22550	300906
TINY_PERF O3 LTO flat	73919	98504	21098	299414
TINY_PERF Os flat	73979	110779	24056	302472
TINY_PERF Os LTO flat	73979	110776	21045	299773
TINY_PERF O2 banked	73914	86214	22805	300933

Compiler/profile defaults are not changed based on this table. Raw instruction, bank, wait, descriptor, stack and payload records remain in each stage record.

ICS55's backend also completes under ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-15-56-ff4b5cef6eb5: compact DVP passes at 177541 cycles in 8887.787 seconds. Synthesis reports 476025 cells and 2711070.264704 Liberty-based area. Setup WNS/TNS are -163.87/-6193132.50 ns and hold WNS/TNS -0.31/-45.71 ns; warnings retain exit 2 and metrics remain observational. This was the first execution of each selected long workload, not a repeat campaign. IHP130 reports 501378 cells and 14883898.734641 Liberty-based area.

After those frozen-source runs completed, the collector/test-only correction accounts separately for SDIO descriptor fetches and completion writebacks. Twenty-five focused checks pass, and both retained backend bundles revalidate with exactly those two permitted source differences. Original records and source snapshots are unchanged. The camera campaign uses fresh 2026-10-17-21-20 variants and passes once per PDK. ICS55 completes in 6966.317 seconds under ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-21-20-b6ad86f0a86e; IHP130 completes in 5002.673 seconds under ihp130-tiny-2026-10-17-21-20-1cb7ba9e3e49. Both command exits are zero, contain exactly one SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny at 34778540 cycles and contain no forbidden error marker. These are new P10 application results, separate from historical P9 capture and P6 SDIO evidence.

Both PDKs produce identical five-phase measurements at SAFE24:

Camera pipeline phase	Calls	Bytes	SYS cycles	Retired instructions
DVP-to-PSRAM capture	1	153600	7311485	1409737
CPU full comparison and histogram/checksum	1	153600	10060974	2140840
PSRAM-to-SRAM bounce copy	150	153600	4016550	388950
SDIO two-sector writes	150	153600	1686150	402150
SDIO readback and full comparison	150	153600	6824100	1667850

The 76800-pixel histogram and checksum 2323003269 match the independent oracle. All 300 sectors and buffer guards pass. Raw SDIO AXI totals are 158400 read bytes and 154800 write bytes: each direction carries 153600 pixel bytes, plus 4800 descriptor-read and 1200 status-writeback bytes respectively. The camera FIFO accepts and delivers 38400 words, peaks at one word and has zero observed backpressure. With the reserved 16-byte margin, the measured occupancy leaves a 492-us no-service budget at the exercised 1-MHz PIXCLK. This finite capture-then-save workflow does not establish continuous FPS.

The camera windows observe 200482 cycles with simultaneous issues to multiple SRAM groups, at most two active targets, zero DMA R/W beat-overlap cycles and zero bus response errors. Maximum completed read/write latencies are CPU 77/18 SYS cycles and SDIO 253/254; central DMA has no AXI reads in this stream capture and a maximum write latency of 126 cycles. Initial/final pending transactions remain in the raw observations; these are measured maxima, not universal service guarantees. GNU size reports text/data/BSS of 22264/136/2768 bytes and 106096 bytes above BSS for both camera images; that space is not a measured worst-case stack.

The final source-checked reports are:

• ICS55: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-21-20-ff4b5cef6eb5/meta/tiny-r2-p10/report/report.json.
• IHP130: build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-17-21-20-8232fa11e7f3/meta/tiny-r2-p10/report/report.json.

Both report selected_gates_complete, with phase_accepted=false. Old-stage execution digests are preserved with exactly the two collector/test changes listed as later validation differences; each camera's source delta is empty. Shared C/Python/style/Mini validation is indexed by the ICS55 report and the validation directory above, and is not repeated in the IHP130 profile report. Exact stage commands, tool/image/model/input digests and terminal logs remain in the referenced records. No source was changed during a long execution, and no selected long workload was automatically repeated.

Remaining acceptance obligations are unchanged: complete PR/nightly (including the deferred full Icarus firmware and P7 clock-transition matrix), fresh full-system VGA coverage, physical/PVT/board/sensor and higher-frequency qualification. The full Pytest publication failures above and existing Make format differences in Makefile, app/apps/ci_smoke/tiny.mk, rtl/mini/mk/verilator.mk and rtl/mk/software.mk remain explicit quality gaps. Negative STA and warning deltas remain observations under the unchanged policy. No new MISRA Required-rule deviation is introduced; the mechanical checks do not establish complete MISRA certification. Human review and the final regression closure are required before complete P10 acceptance.

TINY-R2-P7 human acceptance and P8 implementation authorization (2026-10-15)

The maintainer explicitly confirmed P7 human acceptance and authorized the previously approved TINY-R2-P8 implementation plan in the development session. The accepted checkpoint is 655c5871ea1789afea1c037c1b566a7be02b2bc6. All seven CI workflows for that commit completed successfully, including ICS55 run 38619690260, IHP130 run 38619690366 and quality run 38619690155. This acceptance retains the source-reset and response-conservation boundaries recorded below. Full long-running Icarus firmware remains deferred to final Tiny qualification; negative observational STA and physical/board/rate gaps are not waived or reclassified. Historical pending-human-review statements below describe their original checkpoints. P8 implementation is authorized; P8 acceptance and later phases are not implied.

TINY-R2-P8 implementation checkpoint (2026-10-15)

The approved P8 implementation adds optional XPI NSS1/GPIO29 PSRAM and keeps NOR/SRAM-only boot independent. The shared ESP_PSRAM64H.sv model is now owned at rtl/model and remains compatible with Mini's separate-controller tests. Shared XPI fixes cover byte-lane strobes, narrow-burst address progression, serial-boundary rejection, early core termination, held read responses, short sequences and final-command completion. The manual HAL validates ESP-PSRAM64H identity 0d/5d/26, 8 MiB geometry, bounded MEM24/48/96/120 timing and aligned four-beat DMA jobs.

The focused P8 campaign passed 28 tests across both simulators, including identity, mapped CPU/DMA paths, first/last addresses, byte/halfword/word lanes, canaries, 4 KiB/serial boundaries, timeout/held-response/late-error cases and forbidden-device behavior. The ICS55 full Verilator firmware passed with P8_RESULT code=0 profiles=3 and SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny; retained records are under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-05-00-28a7d10f3a7b/meta/tiny-r2-p8/. Observed windows report 1024-byte CPU/DMA transfers with four-beat bursts at SAFE24, PLL192 and PLL240. These are finite digital workload measurements, not worst-case bounds, camera budgets, physical rates or board qualification. The optional absent-device path is a separate bounded rejection case and does not advertise PSRAM capability.

The handoff-required full long-running Icarus Tiny firmware was started once but intentionally interrupted before a terminal verdict because that gate is deferred to final Tiny qualification. Icarus P8 pin-level focused coverage passed; the interrupted full-firmware record remains NOT_RUN/PARTIAL and is not relabeled. P8 now has explicit IHP130 compatibility replay, source snapshot/report generation, synthesis/netlist-function checks and observational STA for both profiles. Human phase acceptance remains open. P9 DVP, SPI, PIO-lite, PPALite and physical qualification remain unimplemented.

TINY-R2-P9 implementation checkpoint (in progress, source 39ae718)

The entries below preserve chronological development checkpoints. For the latest executed gates and outstanding work, see the row-size remediation. Earlier TIMEOUT/NOT_RUN statements retain their original attribution.

The approved P9 implementation connects the shared DVP V2 block to Tiny at 0x1000E000, IRQ15 and DMA2/request11. It adds the GPIO12-23 ALT1 camera profile, RCU target bit14, the pixel-clock CDC/lifecycle declaration, the Tiny product HAL binding, a bounded final DMA response drain and an odd-width PIO capture helper. The Tiny camera model and P9 evidence parser are source-owned verification inputs; Mini keeps its channel-3 DVP default.

The current source revision has passed topology generation, clock/reset-map validation, the standalone DVP test, Tiny/IHP130 and Tiny/ICS55 firmware builds, and the P9 host contract/evidence tests. A real P9 Verilator firmware attempt did not reach a terminal marker within the bounded 120-second probe and is retained as unrun/timeout evidence; it is not a pass. No P9 acceptance, continuous FPS claim, physical sensor/IO qualification, or final Tiny Icarus campaign is inferred from these checks.

P9 focused integration follow-up (2026-10-15, uncommitted worktree)

The follow-up uses base 39ae71887ca427c83d39ff663ec5f0d1aa19be1a plus the retained worktree inputs; it is not evidence for the committed P8 tree. tests/rtl/tiny_r2_p9_dma_tb.sv instantiates production DVP and DMA, extracting the DMA parameters from Tiny's actual top-level instance. Its controlled AXI sink represents the destination address 0x54000c00; it does not instantiate XPI, PSRAM pins, the Tiny fabric/RCU/pads or a CPU.

The fixture exposed and fixed two functional gaps:

• Tiny's old 0x31ff mask rejected request11 in both DMA and the SDK. The P9 mask is now 0x39ff, with topology, generated capability and validators agreeing. I2C1 requests remain unsupported; Mini's mask is unchanged.
• Shared DVP event toggles were decoded only on rising edges, losing every second notification. Both synchronized edges now generate an event. The fixture checks two frame-starts, two frame-completions and four line ends. The DVP register ABI, 512-byte payload FIFO and Mini channel binding remain unchanged.

The 4x2 RGB565 case verifies all 16 destination bytes, word sidebands, canaries, DMA2/request11 admission, exact bytes_done/remaining and lifecycle drain. Frame-done occurs while the last stream word is withheld; completion remains false through that hold and a separately delayed final B response (each held for at least 30 system cycles). A second execution reuses the binary and returns final SLVERR, checking that DONE and confirmed byte accounting cannot publish a successful frame. A subsequent 3x2 PIO snapshot checks 12 valid bytes, both partial line words, repeated interrupts and final FIFO empty without success-path abort/flush.

Verilator and Icarus focused executions pass command status, their explicit SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny P9 focused DVP DMA marker and forbidden-marker checks. This CPU-less test has no SYSCTRL TEST_STATUS; it cannot satisfy the full Tiny firmware gate, which still requires TEST_STATUS and the configured terminal marker. Sixteen DVP/P9/SDK tests and nine source/topology rejection tests pass. C format/policy/host tests, RTL format/style/readiness, Ruff and diff checks pass. Both selected P9 firmware profiles build without C warnings after replacing negative canary indexing with an explicitly bounded guard address. Make still reports approximately 38 seconds of filesystem clock skew; full compiler/link commands ran and their outputs are retained. No warning baseline or additional MISRA deviation was introduced.

Focused compile/simulation logs, failed diagnostic attempts, quality results and PR dry-runs reside under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-13-20-d336f87100e2/meta/tiny-r2-p9/. focused-final.json records the 16-test invocation; source-checks.json records the nine-test invocation. focused-source-final/ retains a snapshot and hashes of the focused inputs (not a physical/whole-product qualification manifest). Firmware logs/results are under meta/tiny-r2-p9/ in build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-15-25-9a44f7871af5/ and build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-15-15-25-064cd640790c/.

P9 remains in progress. The preceding session reported a 100k-cycle timeout before a P9 firmware stage marker, with CPU instruction fetch waiting in the slow/XPI response path. Its diagnose-progress-100k.log is empty on disk: this is session-reported diagnostic context, not retained, source-bound measurement evidence or proof of a permanent deadlock. Do not reconstruct that missing log or promote its inferred cause. Bounded failed probes remain TIMEOUT; full terminal acceptance remains NOT_RUN. The newly built firmware was not simulated in this follow-up. The current firmware still lacks full payload readback and measured FIFO/backpressure records (its printed zeros are placeholders, not measurements). Full QVGA/VGA, YUV422/crop/error/recovery/service-budget cases, actual DVP-to-XPI transport, current synthesis/mapping/netlist and observational STA remain open. Full repository Pytest and full PR/nightly executions were not run in this focused handoff; dry-runs still select P7 firmware, not the P9 image. Long Icarus firmware remains deferred to final qualification. Human P9 acceptance and P10 advancement are not implied.

P9 approved P1 remediation (2026-10-15, 16-22 campaign)

The approved remediation remains on dev, base 39ae718, with uncommitted P9 sources. The shared DVP now acknowledges error W1C through a clear epoch and coherent pixel-status mailbox, preserves simultaneous new source errors, and executes ABORT/FLUSH only at command acceptance. Configuration START is held behind an outstanding error clear; an applied configuration register prevents an unaccepted mailbox payload from changing an active frame. Snapshot completion stays stopped until a disabled configuration rearms it. The existing ABI and 512-byte payload FIFO are unchanged.

The real C HAL now decodes ACTIVE at bit1, initializes all DMA/CRC options, derives exact frame/crop length rather than treating capacity as length, rejects odd-width DMA/undersized buffers/address overflow, and checks new frame statistics, FIFO empty and final DMA responses. Failed DMA drain returns without source FIFO erasure. Abort and error clearing are bounded; a stopped pixel clock cannot be acknowledged as recovered. Mini's channel3/maximum burst default and Tiny's channel2/four-beat binding are tested separately.

The firmware compares every DMA payload word and odd-row PIO word, including padding and guards. The camera uses a deterministic frame-independent pattern and a default 1 MHz candidate PIXCLK; PIO crops 7x3 from the same input frame. FIFO/backpressure records come from verification-only handshake observers. The parser rejects malformed terminal markers, inconsistent dimensions/frame counts, missing readback/observations and stale or failed run identities. These changes do not themselves constitute full-firmware acceptance.

Retained validation:

• 28 focused tests pass after the configuration-barrier correction: shared DVP, P9 topology/ABI, both simulator backends and parser/provenance negative cases. The controlled backend checks delayed final stream/B, SLVERR, stopped-high/low PIXCLK, START ordering, simultaneous new error/W1C, repeated events and no unsolicited snapshot restart.
• The real XPI backend captures 16x8 / 256 bytes through production DVP/DMA2/XPI and the NSS1 PSRAM pin model, then reads every word and both canaries through mapped AXI/serial transactions. It also checks 7x3 PIO (42 valid bytes in 48 bytes of row-padded storage). No PSRAM backdoor supplies the expected result. Both Verilator and Icarus pass strict command/marker checks. These fixtures bypass CPU, product pads, fabric and RCU.
• Fourteen P8 pin-level compatibility scenarios passed in the earlier 42-test combined invocation; their production XPI/model sources were not changed by the subsequent DVP configuration-barrier fix.
• Real HAL host tests pass for Tiny and Mini, including initialized CRC fields, capacity rejection, odd-width PIO, no success before B, and no source abort when DMA cleanup remains busy. C format/policy, RTL format/style/ readiness, Ruff, dependency-lock validation and diff checks pass. No new MISRA deviation or warning-baseline edit is introduced.
• Both ICS55 and IHP130 P9 firmware builds pass without C warnings. The shared DVP register-shell formal prove/cover passes, including hardware events winning over simultaneous software clears. The final Tiny ASIC top elaborates in Verilator lint; this is not synthesis or CDC/RDC signoff.

Evidence root: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-16-22-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/remediation/. barrier-tests.json and barrier-pytest/ retain the final functional test invocation and per-simulator logs; focused.json retains the earlier combined 42-test run. current-quality.json and final-rtl.json record the quality checks. source/ captures the earlier inputs; source-final/ captures the configuration-barrier test inputs. A subsequent local unused-output lint annotation is recorded separately; it does not relabel an earlier binary's source digest. Formal evidence is under build/ihp130-2026-10-15-16-22-c30fb9412aa3/formal/dvp/. IHP130 firmware evidence is under build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-15-16-22-064cd640790c/meta/tiny-r2-p9/remediation/.

One 120-second startup diagnostic used the same campaign's pre-configuration- barrier binary, with its original source snapshot retained. It exited 124 and is TIMEOUT, not PASS. Unlike the earlier empty log, its streamed boot-before-config-barrier.log shows continuing fetch/XPI progress: at cycle 570000 the diagnostic counters are 5194/6195 and the last progress sample is 569975. Addresses 0x74..0x84 match the retained ELF's app_loader copy loop. These handshake counters are startup diagnostics, not retired instruction/performance measurements. The observation does not support a permanent XPI deadlock; it does not prove eventual boot or P9 capture success. No further long firmware run was started.

All four Tiny PR/nightly dry-runs pass but still select P7 firmware. Full PR/nightly/Pytest, final-source top-level firmware simulation, synthesis, mapping/netlist checks and observational STA remain unrun in this remediation. The final-source full-SoC binary was not rebuilt after the last configuration barrier; focused simulations and top lint cover that correction. Full Icarus firmware remains deferred. Full QVGA/VGA, VGA word-counter width, YUV422, sensor-rate/service-budget, product mode-transition and physical qualification remain P9/final-campaign gaps. Filesystem clock-skew warnings are retained. This closes the scoped remediation work for review, not human P9 acceptance; P10 is not authorized by these results.

P9 review fixes: rearm, admission and notifications (2026-10-15)

The next approved review-fix handoff addresses the four additional P1 findings on the same 39ae718 worktree. No new register, channel, clock domain, dependency revision or physical operating point is introduced.

• The HAL uses the existing STATUS.ENABLE bit to observe applied pixel-domain enable state, while CTRL remains requested control readback. Successful captures can rearm the same configuration through an acknowledged, non-flushing disable/enable sequence. Capture helpers use the supplied timeout for their new start waits. Tiny and Mini host tests model delayed application and execute consecutive DMA and PIO captures.
• PIO rejects busy/suspended DMA before touching stream mode, IRQ state or FIFO contents, and rejects active/nonempty source rearm. Startup failure after this helper starts DMA uses its own drain/abort cleanup; rejected configuration does not abort another owner.
• Configuration/command epochs keep lifecycle idle low until the source applies the configuration or drains the command. Armed capture waiting for VSYNC is busy. Local reset-ready requires a fresh native status packet. Global CPU boot already uses internal leaf/APB/AXI prerequisites rather than the local-reset readiness vector, and that production expression is unchanged. The fixture extracts both actual expressions and tests absent PIXCLK global-boot independence separately from local-reset acknowledgement.
• Error causes are retained in a pending mask and transferred by an acknowledged mailbox. Even pairs of errors cannot cancel as sampled toggle parity did. Tests cover paired errors, cleared IRQ not reasserting from an old sticky level, and notification of a new occurrence of the same cause.

The controlled fixture now includes the production Tiny peripheral controller: gate/reset requests time out without being applied while configuration or commands are pending; armed capture blocks gating, and fully drained capture permits it. The actual XPI/PSRAM and 16x8 DMA/7x3 PIO checks remain in both simulators. These are focused controller/HAL/RTL tests, not complete pad-level mode-transition or full firmware qualification.

Before the fixes, the retained C host command failed and the new Icarus cases reported pending configuration reported idle and paired faults lost their interrupt. Icarus returned zero for those fatal statements; the separate strict simulation checks correctly marked them failed. Those diagnostic logs are under the 17-15 variant below. Their temporary Pytest converted image was subsequently removed by Pytest cleanup and is not claimed as retained.

The 17-15 combined campaign passed 50 tests, including 14 P8 serial-PSRAM compatibility cases. Final 17-55 source replay passed 36 DVP/P9/evidence tests, with the unchanged P8 sources retaining their earlier compatibility evidence. Each compiled controlled fixture is reused for response error, clear recovery, pending control, paired errors, native reset and rearm cases. The formal register-shell prove/cover and both clock-domain inventories pass. The formal/DVP register sources are unchanged since the passing 17-15 proof. C format/policy/host tests, RTL format/style/readiness, Ruff and diff checks pass; no additional MISRA deviation or warning-baseline update was made.

Both final Tiny profiles build firmware without C warnings. The final ICS55 full-SoC Verilator executable was also compiled into a fresh variant. Its prepared-build.json was captured before outputs existed; the build identity binds unchanged 1808 input hashes to the resulting ELF, HEX and simulator. validate_run() verifies those artifact bytes, the matching build-source and configuration records, and the executable/firmware launch arguments. Negative tests reject existing outputs, changed inputs, stale artifacts and wrong launches. A build identity alone is not a passing simulation result.

Final evidence: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-17-55-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/review-fixes/. The final IHP130 build is build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-15-17-55-064cd640790c/meta/tiny-r2-p9/. Earlier combined tests and negative logs are under the corresponding ICS55 17-15 variant's meta/tiny-r2-p9/review-fixes/; formal reports are under build/ihp130-2026-10-15-17-15-c30fb9412aa3/formal/dvp/. The final source digest is 728ed683fcc027929c479d2302f24ffdd642912d51f752bc5ff2c8097d2e2404. Filesystem clock-skew and existing EDA warnings remain observations.

No new full-firmware simulation, broad PR/nightly/Pytest, synthesis, netlist, STA or physical flow was run in this handoff. Full QVGA/VGA/YUV422, VGA counter width, service-budget and complete product-transition coverage remain open; the long Icarus firmware gate stays deferred. The earlier 120-second startup diagnostic remains historical TIMEOUT evidence. Human P9 acceptance and P10 advancement are not implied by these scoped fixes.

P9 START/ABORT ordering correction (2026-10-15, uncommitted worktree)

The approved correction retains the 39ae718 source baseline and fixes the reviewed START/ABORT race in the shared DVP. An accepted ABORT retires older unsent register-side configuration requests. The command CDC now carries the last issued configuration epoch; a pixel-domain cancellation record prevents that configuration from rearming the core if it applies after ABORT. The normal config acknowledgement still completes. A subsequent different applied config epoch retires the record before epoch reuse, and commands do not wait for an active frame's blocked config. Later writes and the existing acknowledged disable/enable recovery remain usable. The external DVP V2 ABI, 512-byte FIFO, Mini transport binding and Tiny DMA2/request11/IRQ15/RCU14 are unchanged. No C implementation, dependency, warning baseline or metric policy was changed by this correction; no new MISRA deviation was introduced.

Two pre-fix Icarus attempts reproduced stale START resumed after ABORT: before.json covers an unsent START behind W1C and repeated ABORTs; before-single.json covers an already issued START and one ABORT. Each raw Icarus invocation returned zero with a Fatal marker; the Pytest verdict was correctly failed. Both source snapshots, converted images and logs are retained.

After correction, the focused command passed 36 tests. The existing controlled binary was reused for three new scenarios in each simulator: abort_order, abort_active, and abort_applied. They cover stopped-high/low PIXCLK, pending and in-flight START, repeated/coalesced commands, the delayed config application, active capture with a blocked config, and a later START queued after ABORT. Existing DMA tail/late-response, error notification, lifecycle, rearm and actual XPI/PSRAM cases also passed. These are behavioral fixtures, not complete Tiny firmware or physical evidence.

The first quality command stopped at fixture formatting. The final quality command passed RTL format/style/readiness and the Tiny/Mini C host tests; Ruff passed. Only whitespace in tiny_r2_p9_dma_tb.sv changed after the passing test run. format-equivalence.json binds the identical token sequence and verifies all other tested input hashes are unchanged; the old test source snapshot is retained instead of relabeling its binary. The shared register formal prove/cover passed, including cancellation of pending config under arbitrary config readiness. This is a register-shell proof, not complete CDC formal qualification. Both Tiny PDK PR/nightly dry-runs passed; they still select P7 firmware and cannot establish P9 acceptance.

The two Tiny firmware/Verilator builds use fresh variants and prepared input records; their completion and artifact hashes are recorded separately in each variant's build.json and build-identity.json. A compiled simulator is not a passing full firmware simulation. The retained executable hashes and versions identify the tools actually used. The strict R2-P1 cached-archive installation audit was unavailable because RETROSOC_DEVELOPMENT_CACHE is unset; that audit is not claimed, and no tool installation or version was changed.

Evidence roots:

• build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-19-15-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/abort-order/
• build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-15-19-15-064cd640790c/meta/tiny-r2-p9/abort-order/
• Register formal: build/ihp130-2026-10-15-19-15-c30fb9412aa3/formal/dvp/

The final build input map contains 1750 entries, digest 2bf849e9868ea0e7e24fbaedc7207db8bd6f5df13b3128b8ad797d37287921b1. It uses the existing P8 source collector for both PDKs; formal inputs and documentation are recorded separately. It is a new evidence set, not a replacement for the earlier 1808-entry collector or its historical claims. Full firmware simulation, broad Pytest/PR/nightly execution, synthesis/mapping, netlist, STA and physical flows remain unrun in this scoped correction. QVGA/VGA/YUV422, VGA counter width, service budgets and full product mode transitions remain open. Long full-firmware Icarus remains deferred to final Tiny qualification; neither P9 human acceptance nor P10 advancement is implied.

P9 retained-binary QVGA replay (2026-10-15, timed out)

The approved validation-only handoff reused the reviewed ICS55 SAFE24 build ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-19-15-9a44f7871af5 without recompilation or RTL/HAL/test changes. Its APP=ci_smoke TINY_P9_ACCEPTANCE=YES image requests one 320x240 RGB565 frame through DMA2/request11 into NSS1 PSRAM at 0x54010000, complete 153600-byte readback/guards, and a subsequent 7x3 odd-width PIO check. The retained HEX SHA-256 is 615f08b42cf9490b0574edddc8f9e15d4e171de8e9dd3694060ce7280e8c09a1. The build/source/runtime identities were checked before execution; the 1750-entry input map and 296 runtime inputs remained unchanged afterward.

Exactly one ICS55 attempt ran from 2026-10-15 19:44:56 to 21:44:56 CST (11:44:56..13:44:56 UTC). The command exited 124 at 7200.012 seconds; result-sim.json records a terminal failed result and child_cleanup_pending=false. acceptance.json classifies the attempt as timeout, with null measurements and phase_accepted=false. There was no automatic retry or extension. The independently prepared IHP130 image was NOT_RUN because ICS55 strict acceptance was the prerequisite. Both profile PR dry-runs passed; their P7 matrix is not P9 firmware acceptance.

The immutable launch command is in the attempt's result-sim.json. It uses timeout --foreground --kill-after=30s 7200s, stdbuf -oL -eL, the retained Verilator executable and HEX, +max_cycles=40000000, +tiny_p8_psram, +tiny_p9_camera, and +tiny_p9_half_ns=500. It does not enable +tiny_p9_progress, which also enables a second UART character observer. The 1 MHz camera input is a candidate digital model rate, not qualification.

The complete 164-byte simulation log contains model initialization, P9_STAGE CAMERA_PINS_START, and P9_STAGE CAMERA_PIN pin=15. Approximately 32-, 64-, and 94-minute external checks retained that same last stage. There is no CAMERA_PINS_DONE, PSRAM-init, frame/PIO/observation record or SIM_TEST_PASS/SIM_TEST_FAIL terminal marker. The strict checker rejected the missing success records and unsuccessful command; absence of a forbidden error string does not make a timed-out command pass. No frame size, throughput, FIFO high-water or hardware timing measurement is claimed from this attempt.

Read-only diagnosis confirms that the last marker is emitted inside rs_p9_camera_pins() after the GPIO15 call. rs_gpio_configure() performs ordinary register accesses without a software polling loop; the GPIO register shell's APB response is not qualified by PIXCLK, and the camera GPIO12-23 assignment does not replace UART0 GPIO8/9. These checks do not establish the root cause or the exact stopped instruction. Without current PC/bus/cycle samples, the final UART write response, later GPIO accesses, CPU/fabric state and simulation progress cannot be distinguished. A deterministic hardware deadlock or regression in the START/ABORT correction is not established by this one attempt. A separately approved focused progress diagnostic is needed; repeating the full two-hour acceptance run is not the next step.

Evidence: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-19-15-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/qvga-replay/attempt-01/. It retains launch/source/library identity, raw log, command and marker verdicts, before/after inputs, interval snapshots and the final diagnosis. IHP130's conditional NOT_RUN record is under the matching 19-15-064cd640790c variant's meta/tiny-r2-p9/qvga-replay/. Existing focused/formal evidence is unchanged. Strict tool-install archive audit, full QVGA success, VGA counter width, YUV422, service budgets, product transitions, synthesis/netlist, STA and physical qualification remain open. Full long Icarus remains deferred; no P9 acceptance or P10 advancement is authorized by this failed replay.

P9 passive GPIO/UART diagnostic preparation (2026-10-15, build blocked)

The approved diagnostic plan adds only an opt-in +tiny_p9_diag observer to rtl/tiny/dv/tiny_p9_observers.svh. It writes a separate trace without enabling the legacy duplicate UART character observer. It records native-domain CPU address/response counts, GPIO/UART APB requests and responses, clock/reset and CDC state, slow-path state and UART FIFO/drain signals. It observes the accepted UART line for GPIO15, then ends after 100000 REF cycles; the independent diagnostic cap is 5000000 cycles. These are diagnostic endpoints, not firmware acceptance markers. No RTL/HAL functionality, public ABI, profile, dependency, warning baseline or metrics policy was changed.

The fresh diagnostic variant is build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-22-04-9a44f7871af5/. Its prepared input identity differs from the retained 19-15 build only in that observer. The original ELF/HEX and generated filelists remain unchanged. RTL formatting, full owned style/readiness and the Tiny/ICS55 PR dry-run passed. Verilator translated the model and generated its C++ makefile, but the single build command exited 2 after 13.351 seconds during C++ precompiled-header compilation:

ccache: error: Failed to create temporary file for /run/user/417800035/ccache-tmp/tmp.cpp_stdout.sRJsDx: Read-only file system

The direct compile-command replay omitted CCACHE_DIR and CCACHE_TEMPDIR normally exported by rtl/tiny/Makefile; both were unset. This is the confirmed build-launch failure, not an established defect in the observed SoC. The generated C++ sources are retained, but there is no diagnostic executable or simulation attempt. In accordance with the approved stop-on-failure/no-retry instruction, the command was not retried and the 900-second diagnostic was NOT_RUN. IHP130, full QVGA acceptance and all broader gates remain unrun.

Evidence is under the new variant's meta/tiny-r2-p9/gpio-diagnostic/attempt-01/: prepared-model.json, source snapshot, quality/dry-run results, failed compile.json/compile.log, and build-diagnosis.json. The concrete recovery is to restore the repository's existing ccache environment and resume the generated C++ makefile in place; it does not require another Verilator translation or firmware build. That continuation needs explicit authorization under this handoff's stop condition. The original QVGA timeout root cause remains unknown. The new observer has not yet been exercised, and no P9 acceptance or P10 advancement is implied.

P9 UART initialization root-cause diagnostic (2026-10-15)

The maintainer authorized continuation after the ccache failure. Restoring the existing CCACHE_DIR and CCACHE_TEMPDIR values from rtl/tiny/Makefile allowed the generated C++ makefile to finish in 82.963 seconds with exit 0. cpp-resume.json retains that command and its environment identity separately from the original failed compile.json. Verilator translation and firmware compilation were not repeated. Prepared source, generated C++, retained ELF/HEX and runtime inputs matched before the continuation; the final simulator and runtime-library hashes are bound in model-identity.json.

Exactly one ICS55 SAFE24 diagnostic ran from 22:29:54 to 22:36:16 CST (14:29:54..14:36:16 UTC). It exited 0 after 382.716 seconds, ending at REF cycle 2085487, exactly 100000 cycles after the GPIO15 UART marker at 1985487. The wall limit was 900 seconds, the diagnostic cap 5000000 cycles and the outer guard 6000000 cycles. P9_DIAG_END reason=post_pin15 means the diagnostic window was collected; it is not SIM_TEST_PASS or P9 acceptance. There was no simulation retry, IHP130 run or full QVGA replay.

The trace localizes the original apparent GPIO stall to missing UART initialization in the P9 acceptance application:

• tiny_r2_p9.c:162 disables interrupts and calls rs_p9_camera_pins() without first initializing UART. That helper immediately calls printf. _premain_init() only initializes IRQ tables and enables counters; the retained ELF has no linked rs_uart_init/rs_uart_configure symbol.
• At REF cycle 2000000 the TX FIFO is full: 64 pushes, zero pops, count 64, TX enable 0, config-valid 0, baud integer/fraction 0 and TX busy 0. The same condition remains in all nine snapshots through cycle 2080000.
• CPU fetch completion addresses 0x30000e64 and 0x30000e74 map to the retained ELF's rs_uart_write() TX_FULL polling loop. There are 3097 completed SYS-side reads of UART STATUS 0x10001018 returning 0x1060 without an APB error. CPU, GPIO and UART clocks continue, resets are released, gates/disabled masks are zero and clock/peripheral blocking is clear.
• Both GPIO APB endpoints complete all 232 observed-count transactions. The last GPIO request is the successful write of 0x00080000 to OE_CLEAR 0x1001401c, completing GPIO19 configuration. GPIO16 is not the stalled transaction; the software is printing the next pin-group progress line.

The first two complete stage lines consume 54 bytes. The next ten bytes, P9_STAGE C, fill the 64-byte FIFO. The Verilator UART model prints accepted FIFO writes even while TX is disabled; those characters are not evidence of serial-wire transmission. In the original line-buffered timeout run the last complete line was therefore GPIO15. Normal diagnostic $finish flushes the partial next line, which appears before P9_DIAG_END in the console log. The HAL wait is bounded, not an infinite hardware deadlock: rs_uart_write() polls up to RS_TIMEOUT_DEFAULT, and putch() discards the timeout result, so each later printf character can incur another full polling budget.

The source-bound report is build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-15-22-04-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/gpio-diagnostic/attempt-01/diagnosis.json. It retains the trace, 208 complete snapshot groups, counter/clock consistency checks, run/build identities, ELF disassembly and source evidence. The minimum follow-up is a checked UART initialization before the first P9 printf, with UART-init failure reported directly through SYSCTRL TEST_STATUS without another printf. This is a P9 firmware acceptance-image defect; this diagnostic does not authorize or implement that fix, change shared HAL/RTL behavior, or implicate the START/ABORT correction.

This turn changed only this ledger and generated evidence/cache outputs. No public interface, dependency version, warning/metrics policy or MISRA deviation changed. The original two-hour timeout remains failed evidence; QVGA success, VGA/YUV422, service budgets, mode transitions, IHP130 replay, synthesis/netlist, STA and physical qualification remain open. Full long Icarus stays deferred. P9 human acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending.

P9 UART startup correction and focused replay (2026-10-16)

The approved application fix initializes UART before the first P9 diagnostic print. tiny_r2_p9.c reads the RCU snapshot and passes its pclk_hz to the existing rs_uart_init() at 921600 baud. A failed snapshot or UART setup writes SYSCTRL TEST_STATUS failure code 4 directly and enters the terminal loop, without calling printf. The internal p9_startup.h helper is tested with success, zero-clock, callback failure and null-input cases. Shared UART/DVP/RCU HALs and RTL were not changed; no MISRA deviation was added.

The ICS55 and IHP130 P9 firmware builds at build/*-tiny-2026-10-16-22-20-* both completed successfully. Software format/policy/Host tests, Ruff and the 36 P9 evidence tests passed. Existing filesystem clock-skew warnings remain observations.

One ICS55 focused diagnostic reused the previously compiled passive-observer model and loaded the new HEX. It ran for 410.539 seconds and ended after the approved 100000-cycle post-GPIO15 window. CAMERA_PINS_DONE was emitted; UART snapshots reported enable=1, config_valid=1, baud_int=26, baud_frac=11, cumulative push/pop counts above 64 and 215 zero-count FIFO samples. This confirms the UART startup correction and FIFO drain behavior.

The run then reached PSRAM_INIT_START and reported PSRAM_INIT_FAIL before frame capture. It is therefore not P9 acceptance and does not justify an IHP130 replay. The raw runner record conservatively marked the attempt failed because it expected one exact pushes=64 pops=64 count=0 sample; the retained assessment.json applies the approved cumulative drain criterion and records UART as passed while classifying the overall P9 workload as blocked at PSRAM initialization. No automatic retry or full QVGA replay was started.

Evidence: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-22-20-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/uart-startup/attempt-01/. The previous UART-root-cause diagnostic remains under the 22-04 variant and is preserved as historical evidence. The next issue is the existing PSRAM initialization path or its retained model interaction; it requires a separate review/diagnostic. VGA/YUV422, service budgets, IHP130 simulation, full Icarus, synthesis/netlist/STA and physical qualification remain open. P9 acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending.

P9 GPIO29 NSS1 correction and focused replay (2026-10-17)

The approved follow-up adds the missing PSRAM chip-select admission to the P9 acceptance image. Before camera setup and rs_xpi_psram_initialize(), the application now configures GPIO29 as ALT0 with no pull, no trigger and a high output default. The topology already binds GPIO29 ALT0 to xpi.nss_o[1] with output enable asserted; the helper and the source-order/static binding test keep the firmware admission aligned with that binding. A direct SYSCTRL failure code 2 is used if the configuration callback fails, without printing before the UART startup path is ready.

Both ICS55 and IHP130 P9 firmware builds completed successfully. The focused P9 evidence suite now has 37 passing tests, including the UART/GPIO startup host test and the GPIO29-before-PSRAM static binding check. Embedded-C format and policy checks, the host C suite, Ruff and git diff --check pass. No shared HAL/RTL, dependency, warning baseline or MISRA deviation changed in this correction.

One ICS55 diagnostic reused the retained passive-observer model and loaded the new firmware. It exited 0 because the diagnostic observer deliberately called $finish after the bounded post-GPIO15 window; this is not the Tiny simulation acceptance gate. The console reached CAMERA_PINS_DONE and PSRAM_INIT_START, with no PSRAM_INIT_DONE or PSRAM_INIT_FAIL before the observer ended. The trace records a successful GPIO29 OE_CLEAR write, released clocks/resets and a healthy UART (pushes=160, pops=160, count=0, enabled and configuration-valid). The last CPU slow-path sample was an XPI APB write at 0x1000900c, so the evidence proves entry into PSRAM initialization but does not establish its completion or a PSRAM/model failure. The post-pin15 window was insufficient to distinguish a long initialization sequence from a later XPI transfer issue.

Source-bound evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-00-10-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/gpio29-psram/attempt-01/. assessment.json binds the ICS55 manifest, firmware HEX, retained model, command, console, trace and result hashes. The previous UART replay remains historical under the 22-20 variant. IHP130 simulation, full QVGA acceptance, Icarus, synthesis/mapping/netlist, observational STA, physical qualification and broad regression remain unrun. P9 acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending; the next diagnostic needs an XPI APB/transfer observer or a separately approved longer bounded PSRAM-only window.

P9 XPI/APB diagnostic (2026-10-17, stall attribution corrected)

The approved diagnostic added passive XPI-domain observations to the existing P9 observer: APB request/response sequence, controller ownership, mapped and indirect busy state, core busy/done/error, FIFO counts and error address/code. The observer remains verification-only and leaves all design handshakes untouched. Verible RTL formatting and the changed-only RTL style check pass.

One ICS55 run used the independently compiled observer model and the same GPIO29-corrected firmware. It reached CAMERA_PINS_DONE and PSRAM_INIT_START. During PSRAM initialization, all 164 XPI APB requests and 164 responses completed with error=0. At the final samples the XPI controller was enabled and idle (mm_busy=0, indirect_busy=0, core_busy=0, owner none, TX/RX FIFOs empty, no error event). This rules out an APB response stall or an XPI core still being busy at the diagnostic end.

The CPU sample shows an in-flight instruction read at 0x30002a4c in the rs_xpi_psram_validate_dma() loop. The earlier interpretation that this request was stuck is withdrawn: completion counters continue to increase, and the longer-window replay below completes the validation. A single LocalWait sample does not establish a persistent stall. The final P9_DIAG_SLOW record still shows the preceding XPI APB address only because it is the retained slow-path request register; the XPI APB observer has no pending request. The run ended at the observer's normal post_pin15 $finish, so it is diagnostic evidence, not Tiny acceptance and not proof of a PSRAM device failure. No SRAM, XPI or application defect is established by this sample.

Evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-00-10-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/xpi-diagnostic/attempt-01/. assessment.json records the model/source hashes, command, result and trace. The simulation model was compiled before a subsequent mechanical Verible format-only rewrite of the observer; the rewrite passed formatting/style checks and did not change RTL behavior. IHP130, full QVGA, Icarus, synthesis, netlist, STA, physical qualification and broad regression remain unrun. P9 acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending.

P9 ICS55 local SRAM response diagnostic (2026-10-17)

The next scoped diagnostic added only passive signals for Tiny SRAM group 0: instruction client request/grant, arbitration issue, outstanding read owner and bank, bank-2 select/data, and the registered instruction response. The CPU state is sampled alongside these signals. No SRAM, CPU or macro RTL was modified.

One ICS55 run reached the same P9 boundary. The final sample at instruction address 0x30002a4c showed an in-flight local read (pending=1, owner 0, bank 2) at the observer sampling edge, but this is right-censored evidence: the preceding CPU samples continued to complete instruction fetches. These are bus completion counts, not architectural instruction-retirement counts. Between REF cycles 2190000 and 2220000, instruction requests/responses advanced by 3333, 3334 and 3333 respectively. The XPI controller remained idle with all 164 APB responses complete and no error.

The cause of the missing PSRAM_INIT_DONE marker is the bounded diagnostic window, not a proven SRAM deadlock. rs_xpi_psram_validate_dma() validates every four-beat burst in the 320x240 RGB565 frame. Each beat is four bytes, so its loop executes 153600 / 16 = 9600 iterations. The earlier 38400-iteration/1.5-million-cycle estimate confused beats with bytes and is withdrawn. The retained disassembly at 0x30002a34..0x30002a64 is the loop body and increments the cursor by the 16-byte burst size (a6 = a3 << 2, with a3=4 at the call site). The 100000-cycle post-pin15 observer window ends while this deterministic validation loop is still running. The SRAM sample must not be promoted to an SRAM RTL failure.

Evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-00-10-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/sram-diagnostic/attempt-01/. assessment.json binds the current observer source, independent model, firmware, command, console and trace. Verible RTL format/style checks pass. The run is diagnostic-only and ended at the normal observer $finish; it is not Tiny acceptance. IHP130, full QVGA, Icarus, synthesis, netlist, STA, physical qualification and broad regression remain unrun. The longer bounded ICS55 replay below retains the same firmware but recompiles the observer model to support a longer stop window. No SRAM RTL fix is justified.

P9 diagnostic-window root cause confirmed (2026-10-16 run timestamps)

The long-diagnostic/attempt-01 replay uses the same HEX SHA-256 232e7a7ca00df295b46c30388f62b165963d2832df071013cd36d8488109e369. Only verification observer stop configuration was extended with +tiny_p9_diag_long (2000000 post-pin15 REF cycles). Production CPU, SRAM, XPI, HAL and workload inputs were not changed during this diagnosis. The model was rebuilt, so this is matched-firmware evidence, not a claim that the earlier simulator executable was reused.

The trace records GPIO15 at REF 2129996, PSRAM_INIT_START at 2168195, PSRAM_INIT_DONE at 2564848, and DMA_CAPTURE_START at 2572839. The original window ended at 2229996, 334852 cycles before the observed completion marker. START to DONE spans 396653 cycles; this includes both PSRAM initialization and DMA admission validation (and marker printing), not a measurement of the validation function alone. The marker is after both calls in the application's short-circuit condition, so its absence previously obscured which operation was executing.

At the disputed SRAM sample, bank data 0x40ee8733 already matches the retained ELF instruction at 0x30002a4c; pending=1 describes a macro read already issued, while bank select need not remain asserted during response registration. The group's s_read_pending_q supplies the next registered response. Later fetch completions and the DONE marker disprove the prior claim that this sample establishes a missing SRAM response.

The run exited 0 after 769.997 wall seconds at REF 4129996 due to the diagnostic $finish. No SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny was observed; capture completion and full P9 acceptance remain open. This finding resolves the short-window startup diagnosis only, not the original pre-UART-fix timeout or downstream DMA/capture behavior. Raw logs and original run results remain unchanged; the earlier XPI/SRAM assessment interpretations are explicitly superseded. Evidence: the same variant's meta/tiny-r2-p9/long-diagnostic/attempt-01/, including assessment.json, trace.log, console.log and result-sim.json.

P9 observer isolation and single full-workload attempt (2026-10-16)

The approved correction separates generic NSS1 population (+tiny_psram) from the legacy P8 campaign (+tiny_p8_psram). P8's four-window, mapped-write and absent-device terminal checks remain intact. Both population flags retain the shared active-CS check. P9 documentation now uses the generic flag. No production CPU/SRAM/XPI/DVP/DMA RTL, HAL, register ABI, PDK input, dependency revision, warning baseline or MISRA deviation changed in this correction; the earlier P9 worktree remains uncommitted on base 39ae718.

The new tiny_p9_monitor.svh, included by the existing P9 observer, counts camera VSYNC, DVP frame events, DMA2 confirmed bytes and remaining work, XPI handshakes/errors and CPU bus completions. The report uses native-clock samples with REF timestamps. It never calls $finish and cannot be combined with the early-stop diagnostics or legacy UART progress observer. These observations do not establish atomic cross-domain snapshots or physical rates.

Validation before the single full-SoC launch:

• 26 observer behavior cases passed in Icarus and Verilator, compiling each fixture once and reusing it. They covered P8 missing windows/writes, absent-device writes, generic and legacy CS violations, conflicting monitor modes and continued execution beyond 5000000 cycles. A separate static assertion failed because Verible wrapped a plusargs call; the assertion was made whitespace-insensitive and its focused rerun passed. The initial failure summary and per-case raw logs are retained.
• 52 P8 pin-level compatibility/P8-P9 evidence tests passed. RTL format/style/ readiness, Ruff and dependency-lock validation passed. ICS55 PR/nightly dry-runs passed but still select P7 firmware, so they are not P9 execution.
• The new ICS55 firmware and Verilator model built successfully. The prepared build record binds 1426 unchanged input hashes to ELF/HEX/model artifacts, with a pre-build source archive. The HEX equals the earlier GPIO29-corrected HEX: 232e7a7ca00df295b46c30388f62b165963d2832df071013cd36d8488109e369. Existing EDA and filesystem clock-skew warnings remain in the logs.

Exactly one ICS55 SAFE24 full-workload attempt ran with a 40000000-cycle / 10800-second cap, generic PSRAM, 1 MHz camera and non-terminating monitor. It ended with exit 1 after 1397.023 seconds, not a timeout or diagnostic early stop. It reached PSRAM_INIT_DONE, then firmware reported READBACK_FAIL word=0, P9_RESULT code=3 and SIM_TEST_FAIL code=3.

The final REF-7400000 progress sample records one frame started/completed, 38400 accepted and delivered words, DMA bytes_done=153600, remaining=0, DMA/DVP errors=0, FIFO high-water=1 and backpressure=0. XPI counted 9602 AW/B transactions and 153608 written bytes, consistent with 9600 four-beat payload bursts and two guard writes. These counts do not prove payload contents. Reaching the readback loop implies the preceding capture/pixel-count and both guard checks passed. The later guards=0 field reflects aggregate failure, not an observed corrupted guard. Expected word0 is 0x02030001; the actual loaded word is not logged, so the mismatch's root cause is unresolved. No PIO completion or full-frame readback pass is claimed, and no automatic retry or speculative production fix was performed.

The run also exposed a monitor logging defect: stdout progress split a character-stream UART P9_FRAME line. The final source writes monitor records to a required +tiny_p9_monitor_log=<file> instead. Twelve focused monitor cases passed after this correction, proving separate output, missing-path rejection, conflicting-mode rejection and survival beyond the old cycle cap. Final full-TB Verilator lint, RTL quality and Ruff checks passed. The final observer suite then passed all 29 tests after restricting the test driver's monitor-log argument to monitor scenarios; $test$plusargs prefix matching otherwise activates the monitor in unrelated fixture cases. This post-run fix has its own source snapshot and has not been replayed in a full firmware simulation. It does not relabel or repair the failed raw log.

Evidence root: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-11-24-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/observer-isolation/. campaign.py retains the exact explicit profile/build/run commands; prepared-build.json, source/, build-identity.json and tool-identity.json record provenance. attempt-01/ retains launch, console, structured exit, bound result, assessment and readback diagnosis. observer-tests/, compatibility-tests/ and monitor-fix-tests/ retain the short runs. monitor-final-source.json identifies the separate-log correction's scope. final-observers.json and final-observer-source.json bind the final short suite and its source snapshot separately from the failed full-SoC executable.

The scoped observer correction is ready for review, but the P9 workload is failed and human phase acceptance remains open. IHP130 firmware replay, full long Icarus, full-repository Pytest/PR/nightly, current synthesis/netlist, STA and physical qualification remain unrun in this correction. P10 is not authorized. The next focused diagnosis must capture the first camera bytes, DVP stream word, DMA destination write and XPI/CPU read value before assigning the mismatch to a packing, sampling or storage boundary.

P9 external camera/audio pad isolation (2026-10-16)

The approved P1 correction changes only the external P6 board drivers on GPIO17 and GPIO15: they release to high impedance in +tiny_p9_camera mode. The former otherwise supplies the audio reference; the latter otherwise loops GPIO14 codec output back to GPIO15 input. P6's oscillator, delayed startup/CPU independence check and stop/recovery logic remain unchanged. The production GPIO mux cannot disconnect an external testbench driver, so ALT1 selection alone did not prevent the old collision. The frozen camera/ audio exclusion contract now applies to both sides of the pads.

tests/test_tiny_p9_pad_isolation.py extracts the actual P6 startup and driver statements, top-level camera assignments and generated pad/DVP routes into tiny_p9_pad_isolation_tb.sv. It uses the production ICS55 pad wrapper and DVP core. Icarus uses native ICS55 functional IO definitions; Verilator uses the existing compatible functional IO model. The fixture bypasses the GPIO register controller, CPU, full interconnect, DMA, XPI and PSRAM, so its result is not full-system memory acceptance or physical pad qualification.

Retained results:

• Eight initial cases passed across Icarus/Verilator: delayed audio startup and loopback, 512 byte/audio-level combinations, all 64 words of a 16x8 camera frame, and expected rejection of simultaneous legacy codec drivers. The positive first word is 0x02030001 in both simulators. The combined negative case reports expected byte 0x04 versus 0x0c in Verilator and 0x0X in Icarus, exposing D3 contamination by the codec loopback.
• Two additional audio-clock-only negative cases passed as tests by detecting the required failure. Reconnecting the legacy GPIO17 reference corrupts DVP word0 to 0x02230021 in Verilator and 0x02X300X1 in Icarus, versus 0x02030001. These are deliberate fixture failures, not passing product runs. They demonstrate first-word corruption at the DVP input boundary; they do not reconstruct the actual CPU value missing from the prior full-SoC log.
• Five existing ICS55 GPIO/P6 I2S/pin-contract checks passed. RTL format, changed-only style, readiness, Ruff and diff checks passed. No embedded-C, public ABI, production RTL, dependency, warning baseline or metrics policy was modified; no MISRA deviation was introduced.
• A fresh explicit ICS55 SAFE24 P9 firmware/model build passed with 1426 unchanged pre/post-build source hashes and archived inputs. The HEX equals the prior failed run's 232e7a7ca00df295b46c30388f62b165963d2832df071013cd36d8488109e369. Existing clock-skew and EDA warnings remain in the logs. Build success alone is not a functional verdict for the new full-SoC model.

Evidence: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-12-20-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/pad-isolation/. focused.json/focused-tests/ retain the eight initial cases; clock-negative.json/clock-negative-tests/ retain the two added negatives; compatibility.json retains the five existing checks. build-campaign.py records the exact profile/build commands, while prepared-build.json, source/, tool-identity.json, build-identity.json and completion.json retain build provenance. The fixture and model sources were not modified during the final full-model build.

As explicitly scoped, no full-SoC replay was launched. The previous observer-isolation/attempt-01 remains failed evidence; full QVGA payload readback and subsequent PIO completion remain unverified after this fix. IHP130 firmware replay, full Icarus, full-repository Pytest/PR/nightly, synthesis/netlist, STA and physical qualification were not run. P9 human acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending. If a later replay still fails, collect the first camera bytes, pad/DVP words, correlated DMA AW/W data and XPI/CPU read response in a separate bounded log before changing production logic or expected payload values.

P9 matched-firmware ICS55 replay after pad isolation (2026-10-16)

The maintainer authorized exactly one bounded validation-only replay of the reviewed 12-20 build. Before launch, all 1426 current inputs and the retained ELF/HEX/model hashes matched pad-isolation/build-identity.json; they remained unchanged after execution. No compilation, production-source change, or automatic retry occurred. The image is the same HEX used by the earlier failed run; the model includes the camera/audio pad isolation and the separate progress-log correction.

The explicit target is configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk, TINY/ICS55, SAFE24, APP=ci_smoke, TINY_P9_ACCEPTANCE=YES, full 320x240 RGB565 camera at a 500 ns pixel half-period. The retained pad-isolation/replay.py launches the existing sim/verilator/emu and sw/retrosoc_fw.hex through run_flow.py with timeout --foreground --kill-after=30s 10800s, +max_cycles=40000000, +tiny_psram +tiny_p9_camera +tiny_p9_half_ns=500 +tiny_p9_monitor, and an absolute +tiny_p9_monitor_log path. No diagnostic early-stop mode is enabled. replay-01/launch.json retains the exact argv and build/source binding.

The replay passed the specified workload with exit 0 after 3460.503 wall seconds, emitting SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny cycles=18570772. The normal Tiny testbench observes SYSCTRL TEST_STATUS before emitting this marker; P9_RESULT code=0 frames=1 bytes=153600 is present. check_simulation.py reports no missing marker or rejected error, and source-bound scripts/tiny_r2_p9.py::validate_run() passes.

• The QVGA DMA2/request11 frame confirms all 153600 bytes, complete payload readback and both guards. DMA_CAPTURE_DONE is present; the previously observed word0 mismatch does not recur in this matched image.
• The subsequent 7x3 PIO crop confirms 42 valid bytes in 48 storage bytes, complete readback, row padding and guards.
• The terminal observer records 38412 accepted/delivered words, FIFO high-water 3 words and maximum backpressure run 504 consumer-clock cycles, at the tested 1 MHz camera clock. These are session observations including PIO, not a worst-case service bound, sustained FPS, or a physical sensor/IO-rate qualification.

Evidence directory: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-12-20-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/pad-isolation/replay-01/. console.log retains intact UART verdict records, progress.log contains separate periodic observations, and result-sim.json, result-sim-check.json, bound-result.json, launch.json and assessment.json retain command, source/configuration and artifact provenance. The prior failed observer-isolation/attempt-01 and all short diagnostic attempts remain historical evidence with their original verdicts.

This closes the scoped ICS55 QVGA/PIO replay gate only. The broader P9 qualification matrix (including VGA/YUV422 and complete product-level error/mode/recovery coverage), IHP130 replay, full long Icarus, broad regression, synthesis/netlist, STA and physical qualification were not run in this replay. No MISRA deviation, public-interface, dependency, warning/metric-policy or operating-point change was made. Human P9 phase acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending.

P9 row-size and IO-constraint remediation (2026-10-17)

The maintainer approved the focused P9 remediation and selected reduced validation: one RECOVERY and QVGA execution per PDK, current-RTL full-size focused tests, and fresh synthesis/compact netlist checks with observational STA. Full-SoC VGA keeps its original historical identity. Source remains 39ae71887ca427c83d39ff663ec5f0d1aa19be1a plus the uncommitted worktree; the frozen Tiny specification and dependency lock remain unchanged.

Evidence starts at build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-09-35-ff4b5cef6eb5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/row-size-remediation/. before/ retains the pre-change inputs. counterexample-sources/ retains the new test with the unfixed core, and counterexample.json records two expected failures: both Icarus and Verilator report zero ERROR_STATUS for 4x2 configured geometry with 6+2 source pixels. The new RTL detects excess pixels before counter wrap and short rows at HREF fall, independently of crop selection, through the existing SIZE/error-event/cleanup contract. It changes no register, FIFO size, DMA allocation or SDK interface.

The host HAL rejection/recovery check and nine LibreLane scenario tests pass. The new default/camera IO profile keeps ordinary GPIO constraints separate from camera input delays and uses separate output roots. These tests are not physical-flow or board qualification. The original format attribution is corrected below: Tiny's final newline was introduced in P9, while the four other recorded differences predate P9. Only the scoped Tiny Makefiles are formatted; unrelated files and policy remain untouched.

Corrected focused RTL passes 14 tests: both simulators execute all twelve malformed-row/recovery cases, actual XPI integration, VGA statistics/readback and the new legal 65535-pixel row. C format/policy/host tests, RTL format/style/ readiness, Ruff and the three selected PR dry-runs pass. Mini IHP130 firmware also builds. The global Make formatter still reports the four pre-existing differences; the scoped Tiny Makefiles no longer appear in that failure list.

The single full Pytest run records 1915 passed, 13 failed, 60 errors and 1 skipped in 5016.09 seconds. Three failures expose P9 integration inventory drift: the commercial product Make policy still lists six clock domains, and its tests plus the older Tiny reset-inventory test expect the pre-DVP domain/leaf counts. The canonical inventory and Tcl product overlay already contain DVP. The remediation additionally synchronizes physical/commercial/config/products/tiny.mk, tests/test_commercial_flow.py and tests/test_tiny_r2_p2.py; it adds no new clock or timing exception and does not run commercial EDA. The original three failures remain retained; targeted post-correction results are recorded separately, not substituted into the original full-suite report. The complete commercial-flow/Tiny-P2 targeted replay passes 50 tests in 15.01 seconds after these inventory corrections.

The other ten failures and sixty fixture errors are publication-source validation failures for the obsolete rtl/mini/dv/model/ESP_PSRAM64H.sv path. 39ae718 already contains that reference in publications/datasheets/system-reference.json, while the model is tracked at rtl/model/ESP_PSRAM64H.sv. Publication files were not changed here. The single skipped publication test reports missing optional pypdf. These remain explicit repository/environment gaps, not passing global CI evidence.

The selected full-SoC and backend campaign has now completed. Every functional run passes command status, the strict Tiny TEST_STATUS/terminal marker and forbidden-error scanning, with unchanged frozen inputs through execution:

PDK / workload	Variant suffix after 2026-10-17-09-35-	Terminal cycles	Simulation seconds
ICS55 / RECOVERY	bf63475ab984	3058688	563.588
IHP130 / RECOVERY	7da598c5c377	3058688	393.120
ICS55 / QVGA_RGB565	9a44f7871af5	18601389	3362.665
IHP130 / QVGA_RGB565	064cd640790c	18601389	2294.190

Each workload was built and run once per PDK. RECOVERY retains seven cases, six validated frames/six IRQs, eight board controls and two audio sessions. QVGA checks every one of the 153600 bytes and both guards, then the 7x3 PIO crop. Both profiles report 38412 accepted/delivered words, high-water 4 and 308 PCLK cycles of longest backpressure. All four HEX files match their corresponding 2026-10-16-23-24 images exactly; the normal-workload cycle counts also match. Wall-time differences are simulator observations, not SoC speedup. The original full-SoC VGA result remains historical; current focused VGA checks do not relabel that old full-system run.

The new backend variants are ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-09-35-ff4b5cef6eb5 and ihp130-tiny-2026-10-17-09-35-8232fa11e7f3. Each retains its stage commands, results and immutable artifact identities in meta/tiny-r2-p9/row-size-remediation/backend/. Both syntheses and structural audits pass with 32 main SRAM and six private Crypto macros, plus one ICS55 PLL macro and no IHP130 PLL macro. The source remains SAFE24; these are not physical operating-point qualifications.

PDK	Synthesis seconds	Reported cells	Liberty-based top area	Netlist boot cycles	Netlist DVP cycles / simulation seconds
ICS55	2490.163	476025	2711078.944704	36449	177541 / 9433.690
IHP130	2233.433	501337	14883493.669841	36069	175649 / 3747.858

The compact DVP check verifies all 64 words using the unchanged assembly image. Each backend compiled its netlist simulator for boot once and reused that same hashed executable for DVP. No synthesis or long simulation was retried. Existing filesystem clock-skew warnings remain in the logs; all outputs were created in fresh variants and source/artifact checks passed.

OpenSTA executes successfully but reports negative slack. All values below are current post-synthesis observations in ns, not timing closure:

PDK	Setup WNS	Setup TNS	Hold WNS	Hold TNS
ICS55	-163.87	-6193132.50	-0.31	-45.71
IHP130	-284.47	-11105854.00	-0.49	-141.45

ICS55 smoke coverage lists 42 inputs without input delay, 52 outputs without output delay, 42 unclocked register/latch pins, five pins with multiple clocks and 146 unconstrained endpoints. IHP130 lists 42/51 missing input/output delays, five pins with multiple clocks and 89 unconstrained endpoints. These reports consume the existing smoke SDC, not the new LibreLane IO scenarios. Report limits and missing physical/board constraints remain explicit.

Standalone warning checks fail relative to the stored baselines: ICS55 has 523 RTL-lint and 20 Yosys new signatures; IHP130 has 471 RTL-lint, 13 Yosys and one Icarus signature. These are new-to-baseline counts, not attribution of every warning to this patch. OpenSTA warning checks pass. Both metric checks retain observe policy. No warning baseline, dependency version or quality policy was changed; no new MISRA deviation is introduced.

Exact long-run entrypoints and outcomes are retained in frames-*/ and each backend stage JSON. Both full-system workloads use scripts/tiny_r2_p9.py run with timestamp 2026-10-17-09-35, jobs 4, a 500 ns pixel half-period and the approved RECOVERY 20000000-cycle/7200-second or QVGA 40000000-cycle/10800-second limits. Backend synthesis uses SIMU=IVERILOG SYNTH=YOSYS, balanced mapping and a 10800-second synthesis allowance. RTL lint selects SIMU=VERILATOR SYNTH=NONE for its functional PDK models. Netlist consumers use SIMU=IVERILOG SYNTH=NONE; DVP uses the profile defaults of 10800 seconds (ICS55) and 7200 seconds (IHP130), with the unchanged 300000-cycle guard.

closure.json under the remediation evidence root independently validates the retained functional logs, binaries, source identities, netlists and matched previous HEX files, and indexes timing, warning and metric artifacts. format-scoped.json confirms all three Makefiles touched by the remediation pass the existing formatter. The original complete-Pytest report and the four remaining global format failures are not relabeled as passing CI. The verification-ledger completion text is a documentation-only update after the frozen-source executions. P9 human acceptance remains pending; there is no commit, push or automatic P10 advancement. Full long Icarus firmware, broad PR/nightly execution, and physical/PVT/board/sensor qualification remain unrun as described by the approved reduced campaign.

P9 remaining-acceptance functional campaign (2026-10-16/17)

After review of the XPI correction, the maintainer authorized resuming the remaining-acceptance plan. The source remains base 39ae718 plus the archived worktree. This follow-up changes validation firmware, verification monitors, focused tests and evidence checking; it does not redesign the reviewed XPI patch or alter product RTL/ABI, dependency versions, warning/metric policy or operating-point qualification. All full-system runs below use SAFE24 and a 500 ns camera pixel half-period.

The added service-budget case passes in Icarus and Verilator. It retains 480 input bytes without consumer service, checks all words after service and source clock resume, then deliberately exceeds FIFO capacity and verifies overflow/cleanup. The fixture reserves 16 bytes for source-word/packing and observation skew, giving a nominal empty-FIFO admission limit of 496 us at 1 MHz. A fixture correction was necessary: at external clock pause, only 119 words had entered the FIFO and the 120th was still held in the source output register. Reading it before another pixel edge returned the previous FIFO word. The corrected test checks FIFO empty and verifies that held word after resume; it does not weaken payload comparison or modify production logic. Initial failures and the diagnostic index=119/held-word record remain.

Two full ICS55 RECOVERY development attempts also failed and are retained:

• ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-22-51-bf63475ab984: firmware received four matching audio loopback words, but the old P6 wire observer required its unrelated 512-word incrementing pattern. An opt-in RECOVERY observer now verifies eight constant 16-bit wire samples per audio session; default P6 still checks all 512 incrementing samples. Extracted-observer tests verify both positive paths and deliberate corruption rejection in both simulators.
• ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-23-08-bf63475ab984: the first DMA frame completed correctly, but the draft firmware registered external IRQ id 15 instead of the generated DVP external id 13. SoC vector bit 15 maps through the CPU's [31:2] slice; external id 15 belongs to WS2812. The application now uses RS_SOC_EXT_IRQ_DVP, with a generated-map/wrapper binding regression. The actual interrupt requirement remains one handler invocation per frame.

Neither failure was a newly demonstrated product RTL defect. Each retry followed a concrete verification/application correction and used a fresh variant. No failure artifact was overwritten or promoted to PASS.

The final functional runs all pass command status, SYSCTRL TEST_STATUS, strict Tiny terminal marker, forbidden-marker scanning and source/build/run identity checks:

Profile / workload	Build variant	Terminal cycles	Wall seconds
ICS55 Tiny / RECOVERY	ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-23-24-bf63475ab984	3058688	569.889
IHP130 Tiny / RECOVERY	ihp130-tiny-2026-10-16-23-24-7da598c5c377	3058688	397.719
ICS55 Tiny / QVGA_RGB565	ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-23-24-9a44f7871af5	18601389	3463.139
IHP130 Tiny / QVGA_RGB565	ihp130-tiny-2026-10-16-23-24-064cd640790c	18601389	2331.387

Each variant retains its records under meta/tiny-r2-p9/full-frame/. RECOVERY reports seven successful cases, six validated captures and six DVP IRQs, two stopped-clock reset rejections (RS_ETIMEOUT, fault bit 1), eight board controls and two independently decoded audio wire sessions. Captures include repeated RGB565/YUV422 DMA, a nonzero-origin crop, PSRAM and small SRAM destinations, complete data/guard checks, and capture after each reset and audio/camera roundtrip. Audio verifies a finite loopback prefix, then explicitly disables/flushes the remaining queued tail before pin handoff; it is not a full P6 audio-workload replay.

RECOVERY intentionally aborts two source frames. Its old cumulative P9_OBSERVATION counters report 416 accepted versus 288 delivered words; the 128-word difference belongs to discarded sessions. The cumulative high-water value of 129 is not current FIFO occupancy across flush/reset and is not used as service-budget or successful-frame acceptance evidence. The dedicated RECOVERY parser instead requires all case/frame/IRQ/board and stopped-clock diagnostic records.

QVGA verifies all 153600 DMA bytes and both guards, 38400 words/76800 pixels, zero XPI error, then a 7x3 PIO crop with 42 valid/48 storage bytes. Each session reports 38412 accepted/delivered words, high-water 4 words and longest backpressure 308 PCLK cycles (12.833 us at 24 MHz). These are finite digital model observations; they do not qualify arbitrary contention or physical FPS. The same RECOVERY HEX is used across PDKs (6b7f36b7...36b536a7), as is the QVGA HEX (9557f6d2...8abb2a1c); full digests remain in each build identity.

Focused evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-22-40-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/acceptance/. The combined focused run initially had 84 passes and the two service-fixture failures; corrected controlled runs pass in both simulators. Audio observer and recovery parser checks pass 12 cases, and the generated IRQ binding case passes. C format/policy/host tests, RTL format/style/readiness, Ruff, diff checks and both Tiny PR dry-runs pass. No new MISRA deviation is introduced. The retained vga-reuse.json documents the original VGA evidence identities and the error-report-only/opt-in-control change impact; VGA was not rerun or relabeled as a new-source result.

Exact full-system commands use python3 scripts/tiny_r2_p9.py run, explicit --pdk ICS55 or --pdk IHP130, --timestamp 2026-10-16-23-24 --jobs 4 --pixel-half-ns 500, and --workload RECOVERY --max-cycles 20000000 --wall-timeout 7200 or --workload QVGA_RGB565 --max-cycles 40000000 --wall-timeout 10800. Each final selected workload runs once; the two QVGA profiles ran independently in parallel. Failed RECOVERY attempts retain their earlier timestamps and exact launch records.

Backend evidence uses ihp130-tiny-2026-10-17-00-31-8232fa11e7f3 and ics55-tiny-2026-10-17-01-01-ff4b5cef6eb5, both under build/. Each has meta/tiny-r2-p9/backend/ with the original source snapshot and synthesis command. Both balanced syntheses and structural macro/domain audits pass:

PDK	Synthesis wall seconds	Reported cells	Liberty-based top area	Main / Crypto / PLL macros
IHP130	2538.737	500331	14886954.637841	32 / 6 / 0
ICS55	2767.803	477040	2710554.224704	32 / 6 / 1

Area is the Yosys stat top-design value, not a placed die/core measurement. Both netlist boot checks also pass strict Tiny command/marker/error checks: IHP130 uses 36069 cycles and 669.884 simulation seconds; ICS55 uses 36449 cycles and 1847.863 simulation seconds. Several execution corrections remain explicitly attributed:

• The first IHP130 netlist elaboration failed because an opt-in legacy RTL progress block still referenced hierarchy removed by synthesis. The block now has a RETROSOC_SOC__TINY_NETLIST exclusion. The testbench is absent from both actual synthesis filelists, so neither synthesis was rerun.
• The first ICS55 netlist elaboration selected SRAM stubs and omitted the standard-cell/IO/PLL simulation models because this campaign's helper incorrectly carried SYNTH=YOSYS into netcomp. Using SYNTH=NONE for simulation selects the existing locked models. No PDK or product-source change was needed. The original missing-module errors remain retained.
• The original IHP130 compact DVP run hit its 1800-second host timeout (exit 124), without a terminal functional verdict. The same HEX passes in the retained IHP130 Verilator model in 177716 cycles, checking all 64 words. This is a diagnostic runtime measurement, not netlist acceptance. TINY_P9_NETLIST_WALL_TIMEOUT initially defaulted to 7200 seconds; the 300000-cycle guard and all payload checks are unchanged. ICS55 uses an explicit 10800 seconds because its measured boot model is slower. An early ICS55 7200-second attempt was deliberately terminated after this speed estimate became available; it is an interrupted attempt, not a DUT functional fail.

The broad source guards intentionally stopped helpers when the testbench or timeout-only Make rule changed. The resumes retain separate consumer input snapshots, immutable netlist/config/model/image hashes and the exact deltas; they do not relabel either original synthesis as a fresh execution. Completed continuations are meta/tiny-r2-p9/backend-dvp-resume/ for IHP130 and meta/tiny-r2-p9/backend-dvp-budget-10800/ for ICS55. Their durable assessment files retain the DVP, firmware, STA and warning/metric stage status and commands.

IHP130 has completed the continuation: compact DVP passes in 175649 cycles (3167.831 stage seconds), followed by a passing ordinary ci_smoke firmware build, STA execution and metric collection/check. The DVP log passes strict Tiny terminal/error scanning, and the replay retains the original compact image and compiled simulator hashes. OpenSTA reports setup WNS/TNS of -280.11/-11170202.00 ns and hold WNS/TNS of -0.48/-120.41 ns. This is a current post-synthesis observation, not timing closure. The smoke coverage report lists 42 inputs without input delay, 51 outputs without output delay, 6 register/latch pins with multiple clocks and 89 unconstrained endpoints. Its SYS/MEM/PCLK period is 41.67 ns; the DVP pixel constraint is 83.33 ns, separate from the 1 MHz behavioral stimulus. Reported paths are bounded by the existing report limits and are not an exhaustive violation census.

IHP130 check-warnings fails on 13 new-to-baseline Yosys signatures and one Icarus signature (68 instances of unsupported edge-sensitive ifnone). OpenSTA's warning check passes. These EDA deltas remain observations under the existing regression policy; no baseline was edited. The metric policy remains observe.

ICS55 also completes the continuation: compact DVP passes in 177541 cycles (9847.549 stage seconds), followed by a passing ordinary ci_smoke firmware build, STA execution and metric collection/check. Its setup WNS/TNS are -162.61/-5895612.00 ns; hold WNS/TNS are -0.34/-46.23 ns. The coverage report lists 42 inputs without input delay, 52 outputs without output delay, 42 unclocked register/latch pins, 5 register/latch pins with multiple clocks and 146 unconstrained endpoints. These remain explicit smoke-constraint and physical-qualification gaps, not timing closure. ICS55 check-warnings fails on 20 new-to-baseline Yosys signatures, including PLL supply-pin constant resolution and multi-output cell observations; Icarus and OpenSTA warning checks pass. No warning baseline or metric policy changed.

The compact HEX is identical across PDKs: 91abc81261ee978b86bca3b40de94f6d2f2dff38b0d46522f083ffe56b0b5d4e. After both continuations completed, the default host budget was aligned to the already executed explicit parameters: ICS55 10800, IHP130 7200. This changes only default selection in the new test target; the retained executions already used these exact budgets. Per-PDK Make dry-runs verify the final default commands, and a one-line source-delta check binds this final Makefile change to the run snapshots. No additional simulation is needed to validate that command-default correction.

acceptance/closure.json binds the functional results, synthesized netlists, compiled models, macro audits, timing/metric reports and warning deltas to their retained hashes. acceptance/final-defaults/assessment.json records the subsequent default-only source delta and dry-runs. Later changes relative to the passing RECOVERY/QVGA binaries are limited to the netlist-only TB diagnostic guard, netlist host-time budget and runbook; those original binary and source identities remain unchanged. The earlier VGA reuse rationale also remains historical, with these additional changes outside its active functional path. The scoped campaign is complete for review, not automatic P9 human acceptance.

The additional Make-format check failed on formatter differences in Makefile, app/apps/ci_smoke/tiny.mk, rtl/mk/software.mk, rtl/tiny/Makefile and the unmodified rtl/mini/mk/verilator.mk. Copies from before the timeout-rule change reproduce the differences; this comparison does not establish that all differences predate P9. Review against 39ae718 confirmed that Tiny's final newline was introduced in P9; the other four files already had final newlines at the phase base. The row-size remediation fixes the scoped Tiny difference and keeps unrelated debt separate. acceptance/format-attribution/ retains the original comparison. No unrelated file was reformatted. Ruff, RTL format/style/ readiness and git diff --check pass. Full long Icarus firmware, the full Pytest suite, broad repository regression and physical qualification remain separate unrun gates. P9 human acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending; no commit/push.

P9 shared XPI error-report alignment correction (2026-10-16)

The maintainer approved the narrowly scoped shared-XPI preflight. The patch changes xpi_mm.sv and xpi_indirect.sv only in their diagnostic metadata outputs/assignments: while the existing error/timeout event is asserted, all four fields bypass from the matching next-state bundle. Otherwise outputs retain the existing registered values. No event delay, AXI response/FSM, register offset/encoding, wrapper arbitration, first-error retention, W1C priority, reset, dependency or warning/metric policy is changed. Mapped pre-LUT/beat errors report PC zero; polling reports address zero and polling budget expiry reports PC zero. Core errors retain their actual fault PC.

The final 32-bit directed fixture was run against archived unfixed RTL: 11 cases fail on metadata and the existing W1C-priority case passes. This includes real mapped rejection, indirect and polling sequence errors, poll-transfer/poll-interval timeout and mapped core errors. Thus indirect and polling failures are now reproduced, not only inferred from source. Initial development attempts had incorrect polling offsets and a default 64-bit AXI test interface; those logs remain diagnostic history. The valid before/after comparison is baseline32.json versus final-source-tests.json.

On the final corrected source, 36 tests pass (12 cases each for Tiny Icarus, Tiny Verilator and Mini's Verilator wrapper with its native backend). They check code/address/slot/PC, enabled IRQ causes, sticky first-error hold across a second cause, W1C/rearm, exact simultaneous W1C/event priority, normal transfer/reset, malformed WLAST/WSTRB, held B response, and core sequence/timeout errors. The fixture drives real APB/AXI/LUT operations with deterministic external serial input and does not force DUT state.

The original P9 XPI-protection regression passes in both simulators: ERROR_STATE=0x80000003, address 0x54000c00, INFO 0x13 (slot 1, PC 0), AXI-error interrupt set, DMA error with zero confirmed bytes, unchanged PSRAM guards/payload, subsequent mapped readback and source PIO recovery. Another 16 existing tests pass for pin-level PSRAM boundaries/lanes/timeout/held reads/short reads/late errors, PHY pads and the fast-flash model. Those two regression groups ran before an identifier-only style correction; the final 36-case suite and builds cover the final name. Mini wrapper coverage uses the native branch; the fast-flash model is checked separately, not a full Mini fast-boot acceptance run.

Final RTL format/style/readiness, Ruff and diff checks pass. A local signal was renamed to s_err_report following the style gate; no baseline was edited. Tiny ICS55 and IHP130 APP=ci_smoke firmware builds and RTL lint pass, and Mini IHP130 firmware builds. Source inputs remain unchanged through each build; ELF/HEX/manifest hashes and source snapshots are retained. Existing EDA/clock-skew warnings remain, with no new C compiler warning observed. No embedded-C API or MISRA deviation changed.

Exact focused commands (run through the retained result/log wrapper):

python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_xpi_error_report.py
python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_tiny_r2_p9.py -k 'dvp_dma_drain and xpi'
python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_tiny_r2_p8.py tests/test_xpi_io.py tests/test_xpi_fast_flash.py
make rtl-format-check rtl-style-check rtl-readiness-check
ruff check .
git diff --check

Builds used BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-10-16-22-33 JOBS=4 APP=ci_smoke SIMU=VERILATOR, explicit SOC/PDK, and the following profiles/targets:

Profile	Targets	Build variant
configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk	firmware rtl-lint	ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-22-33-ff4b5cef6eb5
configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk	firmware rtl-lint	ihp130-tiny-2026-10-16-22-33-8232fa11e7f3
configs/ci/ihp130.mk	firmware	ihp130-2026-10-16-22-33-a2f660e37f72

Evidence root: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-22-21-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/xpi-error-alignment/. before-source/, baseline32/, final-source-tests/, p9-tests/ and compatibility-tests/ preserve the source/log distinctions. build-validation.py and each tiny-ics55/, tiny-ihp130/, mini-ihp130/ directory retain exact build commands/results and identities. This root groups focused host-driven tests; its name does not turn behavioral tests into ICS55 physical evidence.

The diagnosed XPI metadata blocker is corrected and ready for review. RECOVERY/QVGA/VGA full-system campaigns, full Mini simulation, full-repository Pytest/PR/nightly, synthesis/netlist, STA and physical qualification were not run in this scoped correction. Existing VGA PASS records remain bound to their original RTL and are not relabeled as runs of this shared-XPI patch. Draft recovery/netlist work is preserved; subsequent P9 gates require their own source-bound execution. P9 human acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending; no commit or push was performed.

P9 remaining-acceptance checkpoint: XPI diagnostic blocker (2026-10-16)

The approved remaining-acceptance plan was started on base 39ae718 plus the existing worktree. No production RTL or HAL was changed. The directed DVP fixture now drives actual overflow, missing-line size errors, odd-byte partial rows, overlapping HREF/VSYNC, invalid format, recovery payloads and repeated YUV crops at a nonzero origin. The first recovery test wrote CTRL before the asynchronous ABORT completed and correctly received an APB error; the fixture was corrected to wait for native abort completion and FIFO drain, matching the existing HAL. Both simulators then passed the controlled cases.

The combined focused suite passed 86 tests in 104.31 seconds before the new XPI-protection scenario was added. C format/policy/host tests, RTL format/style/readiness, Ruff and diff checks passed. Both Tiny PR definitions were dry-run. The compact app/asm/tiny_p9_netlist.S assembles successfully after adding the generated topology include directory to its build rule; that is assembly-build evidence only, not netlist simulation.

Draft validation additions include the explicit RECOVERY application, opt-in external board controls (UART-command observation changes only camera model clock and camera/audio population), strict seven-case result parsing, and the compact netsim-dvp target. RECOVERY intends to exercise real IRQ15, repeated DMA/crop, rejection, SRAM capture, stopped-high/low reset rejection and audio/camera roundtrip. Its firmware build and full-system behavior have not been validated. No completed recovery or netlist gate is claimed.

The next focused gate failed deterministically in both Verilator and Icarus: after initializing real NSS1 PSRAM, the test disables mapped writes through the public XPI slot configuration and sends production DVP/DMA2 traffic to 0x54000c00. DMA reports error without DONE and with zero confirmed bytes. The APB diagnostic reads ERROR_STATE=0x80000000 and the first-error address assertion fails. Icarus exits zero on its Fatal, but the forbidden-marker scan rejects it; Verilator exits nonzero. Neither run is a pass. The checks after the failing address assertion, including guard/recovery readback, remain unexecuted in this new scenario.

The root cause is an event/metadata cycle mismatch in shared production XPI: xpi_mm.sv raises combinational axi_error_event_o while assigning the new code/address/slot to _d. Its metadata outputs still expose _q. apb4_xpi.sv forwards the current event with those old fields, and xpi_reg.sv latches them as the sticky first-error record on that edge. The observed valid bit with code NONE matches this ordering. Error IRQ classification also uses the old code and is therefore at risk; that IRQ consequence has not yet been separately measured. The indirect/poll engine contains the same output/event pattern and needs review, not an inferred claim that every path was reproduced. This is a shared Tiny/Mini diagnostic defect, not a regression introduced by these verification additions.

Evidence root: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-22-00-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/acceptance/. fault-tests* retains the original fixture failure and corrected controlled run; focused.json/focused.log retain the earlier 86-test pass; xpi-protection.json/xpi-protection.log and xpi-protection-tests/ retain the two failures. checkpoint.json and post-failure-source.json retain this partial status and a post-failure source archive, explicitly not a pre-build provenance claim. The initial direct Pytest invocation lacked its basetemp parent and executed no tests; the recorded run_flow invocation created the evidence parent before running the actual tests.

Per the approved stop-on-failure boundary, RECOVERY/QVGA full-system runs, synthesis/mapping, netlist boot/DVP checks and STA were not started. The remaining service-budget/boundary coverage is also incomplete. Existing VGA and prior focused results retain their original identities; new verification controls are not retroactively included in them. A separately approved shared XPI fix and focused tests are required before resuming dependent gates. No dependency/warning/metrics policy, MISRA deviation, commit or phase acceptance change was made; P9 remains incomplete and P10 is not advanced.

P9 campaign existing-output protection correction (2026-10-16)

The scoped P2 review correction moves the campaign's existing ELF/HEX/model and evidence-directory checks before directory creation, evidence writes or generate_filelist manifest. Previously a built variant without a full-frame evidence directory could have its manifest/filelists rewritten before prepare_build() rejected its outputs. Rejection now returns nonzero without writing into that variant. Dangling output/evidence symlinks are also treated as occupied paths. The existing pre-compilation check remains in place.

The evidence/tooling suite passed 54 tests in 0.93 seconds. Twelve added runner-level cases cover both ICS55 and IHP130: each existing ELF, HEX or simulator, existing evidence, a dangling ELF symlink, and a fresh variant. Rejection tests retain exact file bytes, file/directory modification times and directory contents, and allow only the read-only configuration query. The positive orchestration test executes one mocked generation/build/run/check sequence. These are Python tests with fake external tools, not new firmware builds or simulator acceptance. The exact validation command was:

python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_tiny_r2_p9_evidence.py --basetemp=build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-21-34-7be4ff496b65/meta/tiny-r2-p9/runner-guard/pytest

The retained tests.log and tests.json are under that same runner-guard/ root. Ruff and git diff --check also pass. This follow-up changes only scripts/tiny_r2_p9.py, its evidence tests and this ledger; no profile, public interface, firmware, RTL, dependency, policy or MISRA deviation changed.

Both earlier 14-23 full-frame evidence directories remain unmodified: the build/log and ELF/HEX/model hashes still match their recorded identities. Their input maps differ from the current worktree only in the runner and its tests. Keep those PASS results bound to their archived source dictionaries; do not rewrite them as runs of the corrected runner. No long simulation, firmware build, full-repository Pytest, broad regression, synthesis/netlist, STA or physical flow was rerun for this scoped tooling correction. Existing P9 acceptance gaps and human phase acceptance remain unchanged.

P9 VGA/YUV422 full-frame campaign (2026-10-16)

The maintainer approved the scoped full-frame preflight and its implementation. This record covers base 39ae71887ca427c83d39ff663ec5f0d1aa19be1a plus the archived uncommitted inputs, not the committed P8 tree. The application adds TINY_P9_WORKLOAD=VGA_YUV422 with a distinct configuration digest; the default QVGA_RGB565 and quick paths retain their existing selection. A private frame helper supplies checked geometry and deterministic payload expectations. The evidence parser now binds format/dimensions/counts to that selection and rejects incompatible camera arguments, quick substitution, missing statistics, old artifacts or failed commands. The one-shot campaign entrypoint reuses the existing build, snapshot and durable run-result helpers. No production RTL, HAL ABI, CDC/reset, FIFO, DMA scheduling, dependency or warning/metric policy was changed in this follow-up. No new MISRA deviation was introduced.

Focused validation passed 53 tests in 77.43 seconds, including actual DVP/DMA/XPI focused simulations, workload configuration identity and negative evidence cases. C format/policy/host tests, Ruff and diff checks passed. Both Tiny PR definitions were dry-run, not executed. Commands and observed results are summarized in the ICS55 evidence root's prelaunch-checks.json; its raw interactive quality output remains in the development-session transcript.

Both fresh full-SoC Verilator executions passed, exactly once per PDK, at SAFE24 with a 500 ns pixel half-period. Each captures a 640x480 YUV422 frame through production DMA2/request11, XPI and NSS1 PSRAM at 0x54010000, verifies all 614400 bytes and both guards, then rearms for a 7x3 RGB565 PIO crop from the VGA sensor geometry (42 valid bytes, 48 storage bytes, full readback and guards). This proves the tested raw byte transport and format-change/rearm sequence, not sensor color calibration or the entire recovery matrix.

Target/profile	Exit and terminal verdict	Wall seconds	Source inputs
TINY / configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk / ICS55	0; SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny cycles=73938869	13703.038	1427
TINY / configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk / IHP130	0; SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny cycles=73938869	9291.077	1387

Both runs report P9_RESULT code=0 frames=1 bytes=614400, 153600 words, 307200 pixels and zero XPI error. The Tiny testbench emits its terminal marker from SYSCTRL TEST_STATUS; the command checker and workload/source validator both pass with no forbidden error marker. Input hashes remain unchanged before/after build and run, and the retained artifacts match their build identities. Both profiles use HEX SHA-256 52e806373c30c03c6c5022ef928bb23b0689176dafde123ec09448e160f1db79; ELF and simulator hashes remain separately recorded. Existing EDA/clock-skew warnings are retained; no new C compiler warning was observed.

Each session observes 153612 accepted/delivered FIFO words including PIO, high-water 4 words and longest backpressure 489 PCLK cycles (20.375 us at 24 MHz). These finite model observations are not worst-case service bounds, continuous FPS, physical timing or a qualified sensor/PSRAM operating rate.

Exact invocations, each with --jobs 4 --pixel-half-ns 500 --max-cycles 160000000 --wall-timeout 43200, were:

python3 scripts/tiny_r2_p9.py run --pdk ICS55 --workload VGA_YUV422 --timestamp 2026-10-16-14-23 --jobs 4 --pixel-half-ns 500 --max-cycles 160000000 --wall-timeout 43200
python3 scripts/tiny_r2_p9.py run --pdk IHP130 --workload VGA_YUV422 --timestamp 2026-10-16-14-23 --jobs 4 --pixel-half-ns 500 --max-cycles 160000000 --wall-timeout 43200

Evidence roots:

• build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-14-23-7be4ff496b65/meta/tiny-r2-p9/full-frame/
• build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-16-14-23-28a0c226bed5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/full-frame/

Each retains source archives, tool executable identities, prepared/build identities, exact launch arguments, console and separate progress logs, terminal command/check results, bound results and assessment.json. Tool executable hashes were checked; a new downloaded-tool archive audit was not performed. No retry or three-sample repetition occurred.

This closes the scoped VGA/YUV422 plus subsequent PIO workload for both profiles. Current-source QVGA full-system replay, the remaining product-level error/mode/recovery matrix, full-repository Pytest and broad regression, current synthesis/mapping/netlist-function checks, observational STA and physical qualification were not run in this campaign. Full long Icarus stays deferred to final Tiny qualification. Historical QVGA and earlier focused evidence retain their original identities. P9 human acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending.

P9 full-width word statistics correction (2026-10-16)

The approved correction expands the shared DVP pixel-domain word counter from 16 to 32 bits and the completed-frame statistics mailbox from 128 to 144 bits. The packet is {drop[31:0], words[31:0], pixels[31:0], lines[15:0], frames[31:0]}. Core output, both CDC-side vectors, the existing Common cdc_2phase instance and register unpacking now preserve all fields. The separate 128-bit configuration path, handshake/reset behavior, V2 software register map, 512-byte payload FIFO, Tiny/Mini DMA bindings and strict HAL completion comparisons remain unchanged. This fixes the previously documented 153600-to-22528 VGA word-count truncation.

Validation uses a new CPU-less dvp_stats_tb with real pixel traffic through the shared DVP wrapper, FIFO, statistics CDC and APB. No DUT counter is forced or preloaded. Each backend compiles once and reuses the binary for boundary cases. Both Icarus and Verilator pass all four cases:

Geometry	Expected words	Coverage
510x257	65535	Original 16-bit limit
512x256	65536	First high bit; stopped/resumed host clock
640x480	153600	VGA count and payload, YUV422 mode, host-clock pause
511x256	65536	Odd-row halfword/tkeep padding count path

All stream payload words and sidebands are checked against an independent scoreboard. APB verifies frame/line/pixel/word/drop/error statistics, retention of the preceding completed frame during active capture, and a subsequent 4x2 frame with count reset to four words. These 8 tests passed in 218.602 wall seconds in total; they do not instantiate the CPU, DMA, XPI or PSRAM. The VGA/YUV422 result is therefore a focused statistics/stream result, not the full external-framebuffer qualification.

The real Tiny and Mini HAL host tests accept a complete VGA count and reject the deliberately truncated count with RS_EIO, without weakening production HAL checks. The affected DVP/P9/pad regression passes 48 tests. Shared register-shell formal prove and cover pass, including arbitrary nonzero high statistics fields, coherent update/hold, zero-extended line count and the existing event/configuration properties. This is not whole-CDC/RDC formal signoff. C format/policy, RTL format/style/readiness, Ruff and diff checks pass. No dependency, warning/metric policy or MISRA deviation changed.

Fresh P9 firmware/Verilator models build successfully for both configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk and configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk, each with SOC=TINY APP=ci_smoke TINY_P9_ACCEPTANCE=YES SIMU=VERILATOR, SAFE24 and BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-10-16-13-50. The prepared-build records retain 1430 ICS55 and 1390 IHP130 unchanged input hashes respectively, archived sources and ELF/HEX/model hashes. Both builds retain existing EDA/clock-skew warnings. No full-SoC executable was launched, and the prior passing QVGA run is not relabeled as a pass for these new RTL inputs.

Evidence roots:

• build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-16-13-50-9a44f7871af5/meta/tiny-r2-p9/word-count/ retains stats.json, per-case logs in stats-tests/, host.json, regressions.json, quality.json, source/build identities and summary.json. build-campaign.py records exact build commands for both PDKs.
• build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-16-13-50-064cd640790c/meta/tiny-r2-p9/word-count/ retains the separate IHP130 source/build identity and results.
• build/ihp130-2026-10-16-13-50-c30fb9412aa3/formal/dvp/ retains the Mini-profile shared register-shell prove/cover reports; the exact formal-dvp command is also recorded in the ICS55 evidence root's formal.json. It is not a Mini full-product simulation.

Full VGA/YUV422 PSRAM capture/readback, current full-system replay and the remaining P9 product-level error/mode/recovery matrix are still open. Full long Icarus, broad repository regression, synthesis/netlist, STA and physical qualification were not run. The scoped counter/statistics fix is ready for review; human P9 acceptance and P10 advancement remain pending.

TINY-R2-P8 P1 correction follow-up (2026-10-15)

The review identified two evidence-blocking issues and both were corrected. rs_xpi_psram_validate_dma() now checks every emitted burst against the configured 1 KiB serial boundary, the 4 KiB DMA page boundary, capacity and alignment before a session starts. The P8 workload begins at 0x54000c00, an aligned legal boundary; aligned crossing and malformed cases remain rejected by host tests and the XPI directed tests. The MEM observer now maps AW/W/AR/B/R stall counters to the correct output fields and records the maximum observed CS duration.

After the correction, the P8 focused suite and C/RTL checks passed again. A fresh ICS55 Verilator replay passed SAFE24/PLL192/PLL240 with P8_RESULT code=0 profiles=3 and SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny; a fresh IHP130 SAFE24 replay passed with P8_RESULT code=0 profiles=1 and SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny. Evidence is retained below the corresponding build/*-08-00-*/meta/tiny-r2-p8 directories. These are behavioral/model results only. Full long Icarus remains deferred to final Tiny qualification. Both profiles also have current synthesis, netlist boot and observational STA records; source-bound promoted reports are retained under each profile's promoted evidence directory. Human P8 acceptance remains open.

TINY-R2-P7 source-reset integration contract (2026-10-14)

The follow-up review identified a missing source-side reset proof, not a reproduced product failure. The AXI bridge does not support arbitrarily resetting an active source while leaving its slave session alive. Flushing the FIFO cannot cancel a request already accepted by that slave. Production Tiny prevents that sequence: DMA local reset requires engine, admission and fabric drain before resetting the source; XPI's SYS source reset is a common system reset that also resets its MEM endpoint. Neither production bridge uses warm clear. These preconditions are part of the integration contract, not a claim of unrestricted unilateral-reset support by the standalone bridge.

tests/rtl/tiny_p7_source_reset_tb.sv uses the production DMA master, admission, CDC, lifecycle controller and reset tree. The test extracts the actual top-level instances, drain/block synchronizers and generated DMA/XPI reset bindings, so a hand-copied reset policy cannot silently replace them. An independent outstanding scoreboard survives local reset and rejects premature reset. The AXI target is a controllable behavioral slave; unrelated CPU/APB/SDIO work and the DMA completion mailbox are idle. This is a focused integration test, not a full-SoC firmware or formal CDC/RDC signoff result.

The scenarios cover stalled AR/AW, partial W, downstream W backpressure, delayed R/B, source-held R, drain timeout without reset, post-reset reads and writes, and common system reset during an outstanding read. The same binary is reused at SAFE24, XIN48, XIN96, PLL192 and PLL240 domain ratios. They test digital ordering only; the clock generators do not qualify a PLL or PDK rate. A negative run falsifies both idle observations and must trip P7_SOURCE_RESET_UNDRAINED; Icarus may return zero for sv2v's lowered fatal, so the forbidden marker and missing PASS still make that simulation invalid.

Evidence for this correction is retained under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-14-06-00-ff4b5cef6eb5/meta/tiny-r2-p7-source-reset/. The first focused attempt's test-driver failure is retained in focused-1.log; it is not a DUT failure or acceptance result. The final directed.log and result-directed.json record 54 passed in 191.71 seconds. This includes ten positive source-reset runs (five ratios in each simulator) and two expected-negative broken-drain runs inside the two new Pytest cases. RTL format/style, clock/reset inventory, Ruff, both Tiny PDK PR dry-runs and git diff --check pass. The verification-only source comparison is retained in verification-update.json: only the two test files differ; 1728 other technical inputs and tool identities match. The design, firmware, configuration, dependencies and physical inputs are unchanged from the 06-00 source snapshot; the new tests do not relabel earlier simulations as new executions. Full Icarus firmware remains deferred to final Tiny qualification. Human P7 acceptance is still required.

TINY-R2-P7 response conservation correction (2026-10-14)

The earlier review recommendation to give abort unconditional priority over source response retirement was incorrect. A cycle with an already exposed normal B/R handshake followed by an abort produced two completions for one request. Four read/write tests reproduced this in Verilator and Icarus. The failed candidate, diagnostics and source archive are retained below build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-14-04-00-ff4b5cef6eb5/meta/tiny-r2-p7-response/. The 04-00 synthesis/netlist/STA results belong to that rejected candidate; their successful boot does not close the protocol finding.

The corrected bridge holds presented responses in source-owned registers. Remote reset cannot revoke VALID or rewrite their payload under backpressure, and a completed source handshake is never followed by a second completion. Only missing read beats receive DECERR, with RLAST at the original burst end; a reset write consumes the remaining W beats before emitting B. Outstanding tracking is one transaction per direction, matching the existing Tiny paths. The payload reset uses the five-edge source link barrier. An unfinished warm clear quarantines the bridge until a real destination reset; a FIFO clear cannot by itself cancel remote slave state or authorize re-use of late replies. Production DMA/XPI clear inputs remain tied low; no new software reset API, autonomous AXI timeout, DMA owner, or later-phase capability is introduced.

The new tests distinguish completed/held responses from missing responses, cover simultaneous clear and response handshakes, remote reset with READY high, backpressure, partial bursts and late-response quarantine. That campaign's full directed selection passed 52 cases. Earlier 36-case and rejected- candidate passes did not cover these failures and are not proof of the repair. The failed same-cycle candidate and diagnostics remain in the response evidence directory. The final input snapshot is build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-14-06-00-ff4b5cef6eb5/meta/tiny-r2-p7-response/final/source-final.json. The 06-00 backend campaign is bound to the final source snapshot and all requested post-fix gates pass. Its variants are build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-14-06-00-ff4b5cef6eb5/ and build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-14-06-00-8232fa11e7f3/. ICS55 synthesis/netlist/STA durations are 2108.388/1655.980/43.594 s, with WNS max/min -152.03/-0.31 ns and TNS max/min -5622052.50/-44.14; IHP130 durations are 1934.515/578.869/47.109 s, with WNS max/min -253.43/-0.49 ns and TNS max/min -10035324.00/-153.37. Netlist boot emitted SIM_TEST_PASS Tiny netlist boot for both PDKs. These timing values remain observational and do not qualify closure or an operating point. Full Icarus firmware remains deferred by the maintainer to final Tiny qualification. It is not a current P7 gate; protocol correctness and human phase acceptance remain required.

TINY-R2-P7 final verification campaign (2026-10-13)

The P7 runbook records the current implementation, exact profile-specific commands, workload definitions and source snapshot. The integrated design now drives actual SYS/MEM/PCLK consumers, CPU-only WFI gating, local reset barriers, CLKOUT and the single ICS55 PLL backend. It keeps the 32 main SRAM macros at CPU SYS and six private Crypto macros at PCLK. Future target capabilities remain absent. No later phase is authorized here.

Development validation includes 68 passing Tiny P7/SYSCTRL/P5 directed tests and a later complete 52-case P7 directed pass, plus both simulators' real Hazard3 IRQ/debug wake, clock-pause and retained-debug warm-reset/aborted-command cases. RCU validation now rejects invalid or BUSY staging writes with PSLVERR, and the CLKOUT waveform test exposed and corrected enable/divisor ordering. HAL tests cover invalid, absent, busy, gated-reset and sticky-timeout/error boundaries. These short checks complement the final long flows; they do not replace full firmware or netlist acceptance.

Source evidence is retained at build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-13-17-05-f3e42d54c18b/meta/tiny-r2-p7/source.json. The final command matrix and its retained corrections are listed in the runbook. Default ICS55/IHP130 and external XIN48/96 P7 firmware pass in both simulators. Each profile's cycle count and WFI/DMA/reset observations match across simulators. Both watchdog-corrected full Verilator firmware runs pass the unchanged P6 peripheral/wire/AXI collector and JTAG. The two corresponding full Icarus replays were intentionally interrupted with exit 130 after the maintainer requested that this long-running gate move to the final Tiny phase; their partial logs and interrupted result records are retained, but they are not acceptance evidence. Both PDKs pass synthesis, structural macro binding and Tiny netlist boot. Current core STA remains observational and negative, with the coverage limits explicit in the runbook. These are historical campaign results; current phase acceptance requires the response correction above and human review. The full Icarus firmware gate belongs to final Tiny qualification. No high-rate physical operating point is qualified by these functional simulations or SAFE24 core STA.

Historical TINY-R2-P7 CDC/reset correction follow-up (2026-10-14)

This checkpoint predates the response-conservation correction and is superseded by the 06-00 campaign above. It is not current-source acceptance. The P7 review identified two source-bound gaps. The XPI fabric target and bridge source side release with the SYS reset endpoint, while the XPI/MEM side retains its MEM leaf reset. The Tiny AXI CDC bridge synchronizes destination reset loss, invalidates its protected request/response state and blocks new source admissions. Its original single-DECERR completion claim was insufficient for held responses and bursts; the later response-conservation correction supersedes that claim. The existing DMA/XPI instances retain their explicit bridge boundaries and the XPI bridge now uses the split SYS/MEM reset mapping.

The new tests/rtl/tiny_axi4_async_bridge_tb.sv passes under both Verilator and Icarus for normal read response, reset-aborted read/write, DECERR, no-replay and bridge recovery. The complete PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_tiny_r2_p7.py selection eventually passed 52 tests after the later corrections; that count does not belong to the 01-20 implementation. make --silent rtl-format-check rtl-style-check-all and git diff --check pass. An ICS55 default-profile Verilator comp also passes; its existing PDK and simulator warnings remain observations. The checkpoint's synthesis, netlist boot and observational STA gates passed for both PDKs. Its historical evidence is retained under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-14-01-20-ff4b5cef6eb5/ and build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-14-01-20-8232fa11e7f3/. ICS55 reports WNS max/min -144.40/-0.31 ns and TNS max/min -4859636.50/-45.04; IHP130 reports WNS max/min -257.81/-0.47 ns and TNS max/min -9807803.00/-100.68. These remain observational negative timing results, not closure or operating point qualification. The long-running full Icarus firmware gate remains intentionally deferred to the final Tiny phase; no physical flow was run.

Historical initial P7 checkpoint, superseded (2026-10-13)

The following incomplete checkpoint belongs to earlier development snapshots. Its unconnected/missing-path statements do not describe the final campaign.

This checkpoint starts from committed source 43a3c8d453b6d41df3536719ebc6d1f4521bc7cd, specification blob 7e19de49d49efaafacccfa85671e314d53dd15a4, Tiny/ICS55 profile configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk, and the locked PWM revision 38efaf5e20f084a00148920087c60cadab61839b. The dependency lock validator passes with digest 263402a34f2e315ca46ef4bf6366aab64935bd8de7abab3e469f513e988b0208.

The implementation adds the Tiny-owned RCU register bank and handwritten rcu.h/rcu_regs.h/rcu.c contract, reports SAFE24/domain-rate snapshots, connects committed PCLK/SYS rate reporting to the upgraded PWM and SDIO CLOCK_ACTUAL paths, and adds focused APB coverage for identity, capability, profile rejection/commit, status and write-only command behavior. Verilator and Icarus SYSCTRL focused tests pass; ICS55 Verilator and Icarus top-level compilation, Tiny firmware linking, C format/policy/host tests and the SDIO suite pass. Build logs are retained under the generated build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-13-09-00-f3e42d54c18b/ and build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-13-10-30-f3e42d54c18b/ roots.

A Tiny-owned tiny_clock_reset_subsystem backend is now source-bound and filelisted. Its SAFE24/no-PLL focused test passes in both simulators and covers five-stage SYS/MEM/PCLK reset release, external-profile handling and rejected PLL requests. A second focused test exercises the behavioral PLL lock-timeout path in both simulators; it does not claim successful macro lock or frequency qualification. The backend is intentionally not advertised or wired into the CPU/fabric yet; its SYSCTRL profile/apply handshake is now connected, while the backend instance is now present in the Tiny top and its SYS output clocks the CPU, fabric, SRAM, AXI interfaces and system reset tree. XPI now crosses from SYS to the backend MEM clock through the Tiny-owned warm-flush AXI bridge. The RCU command checks CPU/fabric/target idle observations and the XPI bridge before accepting a transition. PCLK outputs are still not connected to all peripheral consumers.

The focused command is PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_tiny_r2_p7.py; its four cases passed. Supporting gates were make --silent rtl-format-check rtl-style-check-all, make --silent sw-format-check sw-policy-check sw-host-test, PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_script_tools.py -k 'run_flow', ruff check scripts/run_flow.py tests/test_tiny_r2_p7.py, and python3 scripts/dependency_lock.py --lock dependencies/dependencies.lock.json. The current ICS55 top-level compile used source .cache/retrosoc/development/tiny-r2-p1/activate.sh && CCACHE_DISABLE=1 make --silent CONFIG=configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk APP=ci_smoke SIMU=VERILATOR HAVE_SVA=YES BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-10-13-16-30 comp and exited zero. These are source/compile/focused checks; none is a strict full firmware terminal verdict or physical qualification.

The long-run diagnostic also confirmed that the emulator itself exits normally with a Tiny timeout at a bounded cycle count and uses about 26 MiB RSS. The earlier status=running records lacked a verified terminal result. The initial diagnosis attributed this to sandbox cleanup without sufficient evidence; that conclusion is withdrawn. Separate tool invocations can have different PID namespaces, so process absence in one does not establish that another command died. run_flow.py now records parent_pid and child_pid in the running result and writes a failed terminal result for unexpected Python exceptions; long runs must remain attached to one polling session.

This is not phase acceptance. The current RTL now uses the backend SYS clock for the system/fabric path, but does not yet provide the required executable MEM/PCLK clock consumers, full CDC bridges, WFI leaf gating, PLL lock/loss recovery, or target-local five-cycle reset sequences. A full Tiny Verilator firmware run was started but did not produce a terminal TEST_STATUS/SIM_TEST_PASS verdict and was stopped; no physical, STA or netlist qualification is claimed. The remaining P7 clock/reset implementation and strict terminal regressions require a follow-up correction before human phase approval.

TINY-R2-P6 implementation complete, human review pending (2026-10-12)

The maintainer approved the P6 preflight on b3b30a72cd6ef5340c28e5044c96cd13258ec5a6, against unchanged specification blob 7e19de49d49efaafacccfa85671e314d53dd15a4. The P6 runbook records eight-channel/shared-IP integration, the explicitly retained historical ASIC wrapper and publication, and the separate source-bound validation scope. Development diagnostics are not final acceptance; no P7 or physical-frequency qualification is implied.

Initial integration exposed a shared I2S sample-LSB assembly defect and a Verilator packed-tri1 board-model limitation. The runbook records their narrow corrections. Directed SDIO integration additionally exposed command admission, transmit/receive pause and multi-burst descriptor-retirement defects, plus manual card-model gaps; their independent reproductions are recorded there. Both Tiny PDKs have complete Verilator and Icarus functional verdicts and netlist boots. Yosys synthesis and OpenSTA run for both PDKs with the exact 32-main plus 6-private-Crypto macro bindings. The final audit is build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-12-11-50-2eb98c0e1fae/meta/tiny-r2-p6/audit-result-v3.json; the source-bound evidence is evidence.json in the same directory. The functional report retains four simulator records, all workload/AXI/device observations and the Mini compatibility result.

Observed setup/hold slack remains negative: ICS55 WNSmax/WNSmin −84.93/−0.31 ns and IHP130 −165.41/−0.51 ns. Warning checks report new signatures from the existing policy's observation flows; no baseline or metrics policy was edited. The full Pytest attempt remains recorded as 1634 passed, one optional pypdf skip, five failures and 60 fixture errors; all 65 failed/error nodes pass in the explicit repair selection, and the affected consumer suite passes 512 with one optional skip. These overlapping counts are not a clean full-suite rerun. Final human review, complete-product timing closure, package/QFN64 binding and physical signoff remain pending. Earlier P5 results and failed P6 attempts retain their original attribution.

TINY-R2-P5 P1 protocol correction; validated, review pending (2026-10-12)

The maintainer requested correction of the reset write-drain/read-retention failures and publication-binding mismatch. The implementation starts from 4e6ab1a6fb445521703f0bfa412d3a1e8a38cd69; the specification remains blob 7e19de49d49efaafacccfa85671e314d53dd15a4. The P5 runbook describes preserved upstream spill responses, complete read/error bursts, write drain before B, latched downstream cancellation and first-error capture. Profiles remain Tiny/ICS55 SAFE24 with parked PLL and Tiny/IHP130 compatibility.

Current evidence is isolated under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-11-23-35-b4aa59f3e5d9/meta/tiny-r2-p5-p1/. The older 09-30 campaign failed overall: 1669 Pytest passes, one skip, two failures and ten errors (publication), plus independent R stability and W-before-B violations. Its passing ordinary regressions, PPA and replay are historical observations, not acceptance of the repair.

Final focused validation passes 101 tests. Full Pytest passes 1685 tests, with one optional pypdf skip and no failures; these counts overlap. Both Tiny PDK PR regressions pass, including six strict simulation verdicts, synthesis, netlist boot and the 32-macro/common-SYS binding check. Each simulator passes all 28 reset scenarios, including three production DMA drain cases; normal-target, arbitrary-target-reset and fault-collector induction/SAT checks pass. Complete terminal/fault publication bindings and three unsafe-completion mutation tests pass without changing the reviewed publication SHA. RTL format/style/readiness, Ruff and diff checks pass.

source.json and evidence.json bind 2011 technical inputs to digest f670789a2379a8d2e6c59f5ecd714ca0237bb6f1cfe749a2f29b0794d356b5f0, locked tools, exact command results and retained artifacts. No warning baseline, metric policy, shared DMA/SDK implementation or public ABI changed. The lint signatures/counts match the preceding 09-30 campaign; the existing baseline comparison remains a non-blocking observation. STA remains unclosed: max WNS is -70.04 ns ICS55 and -127.01 ns IHP130. The runbook records full area/timing observations and limitations. Matched-image replay, full-function C netlist qualification, PDF promotion and physical qualification were not repeated for this bounded correctness repair. P5 human review/acceptance and all P6+ work remain separate.

TINY-R2-P5 target-reset isolation repair; focused validation (2026-10-11)

Superseded attempt: later protocol checks rejected its response flushing and early B/RLAST behavior. The four focused passes below remain historically accurate but were insufficient to establish reset isolation.

Following the P5 review, the fabric now receives the explicit 23-entry target reset vector. A reset blocks new admission and downstream handshakes, flushes response spill state, and converts any accepted target session into a held DECERR terminal response. The existing owner credit is released only by the upstream RLAST/B handshake, preventing stale response replay or a permanently busy direction. No target map, public register, DMA capacity, clock profile or later phase was changed.

The focused command PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_tiny_r2_p5.py -k 'target_reset_isolation or concurrent_fabric' passed 4 tests: both Icarus and Verilator reset-isolation tests and both existing concurrent-fabric tests. make rtl-format-check rtl-style-check-all rtl-readiness-check-all also passed. This is a focused implementation check; the prior P5 campaign reports remain source-bound to their recorded snapshots and have not been rewritten or relabeled. The retained focused logs are under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-10-18-58-b4aa59f3e5d9/meta/tiny-r2-p5/reset-repair-tests/.

TINY-R2-P5 implementation; validated, review pending (2026-10-10)

The maintainer approved the single-phase P5 plan on clean commit 3131762b35e0ebfcd196395f955e7c1005bd18e7, specification blob 7e19de49d49efaafacccfa85671e314d53dd15a4. The P4 input hashes match this starting source, but earlier reports retain their original snapshot attribution. The P5 runbook records target-local ownership, sixteen APB branches, reserved inactive SDIO owner 2, concurrent-fault accounting and the unchanged public ABI/clock/memory boundaries.

The completed campaign is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-10-18-58-b4aa59f3e5d9/meta/tiny-r2-p5/; the earlier 18-25 root retains development attempts. Full Pytest reports 1679 passed and one optional pypdf skip. Both Tiny PDK PR regressions pass, including synthesis, netlist boot and clock/macro binding. The real CPU/DMA fixture records 13 overlapping DMA read/write beat cycles, 27 independent control completions, hart-reset isolation and abort drain on both simulators. Scoped target-control/fault proofs and retained P4 latency/streaming checks pass.

Initial image executions passed but aggregation correctly failed on an Icarus 13 temporary-expression population-count defect. The only subsequent source change is P5 opt-in testbench instrumentation. source.json retains the original snapshot for the unchanged DUT/full-suite/ordinary-regression/PPA results; monitor-source.json records the corrected monitor. Only affected image measurements and monitor checks were repeated. monitor-diagnosis.json retains the reproduction and original discrepancy; no comparison rule was relaxed.

Final report.json has identical banked observations across simulators. Against repaired P4, burst1 cycles change 91306→65527 flat and 89365→65502 banked; burst16 changes 17897→16974 and 17317→15802. CPU/copy cycles are unchanged; small contention/TCD/chunk256 increases remain explicit. The final combined input digest is 0f3ed21f6fd6e932ff2532aab8c9964e71cf4b972e4c27e2c8ca6ab1f22c1015. evidence.json rechecks 2010 inputs and binds both snapshot scopes, six ordinary simulations, final matched-image runs, 15 focused/formal artifacts and reused unchanged Mini compatibility evidence. Library area grows 5.56%/6.95%; max WNS is -64.75 ns ICS55 and -111.93 ns IHP130. Timing remains unclosed/observational. The runbook records exact commands, source attribution, warning observations, measurements and unrun qualifications. Human phase acceptance is pending. Shared DMA/Mini/SDK behavior, dependencies and warning/metrics policy remain unchanged. No P6 execution or physical-frequency qualification is authorized.

TINY-R2-P4 throughput repair; validated, review pending (2026-10-10)

Following the read-only P4 review, the maintainer approved the bounded-buffer repair plan for the P2 external-SRAM throughput regression. The changed Tiny group/frontend keep local I/D single-operation semantics, reserve external response capacity and overlap burst issuance/retirement; W is captured before macro arbitration and B follows complete commit-response drain. Common FIFO and register dependencies, ABI, clock/macro bindings and the pre-P5 external attachment remain unchanged. No shared Mini debug code is changed by this fix.

Fresh evidence belongs under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-10-15-15-b4aa59f3e5d9/meta/tiny-r2-p4/. The preceding P4 report below remains the pre-repair comparison, and does not qualify these new changes. The final audit rechecks 1972 technical inputs, six fresh regression simulations and three immutable-image executions. Full Pytest reports 1659 passed and one optional pypdf skip. Both Tiny PDK PR regressions pass, including synthesis, netlist boot and clock/macro bindings. Streaming/backpressure/error/reset checks and response conservation/fairness induction pass; all six SRAM fixtures retain three-cycle local completion and one-cycle steady read/write beat spacing. Initial style failures and focused development attempts remain separate from final qualifying results.

Matched burst16 DMA cycles fall from 36713 to 17897 (flat) and 36489 to 17317 (banked), reductions of 51.25% and 52.54%. All banked observations match across Verilator and Icarus. CPU/copy/burst1 cycles remain unchanged from pre-repair P4; burst1 overhead and 8.34%/4.81% burst16 overhead versus original P3 remain explicit. The combined input digest is 58daf68fbb9dee199b3085a73ef07d22eb3de6d00ba875c462e85b76b6091a0d. evidence.json binds the source, artifacts, comparison and reused unchanged Mini behavioral evidence. All long gates ran once; Tiny nightly matched PR and was not duplicated. Setup WNS remains negative (-36.88 ns ICS55, -97.37 ns IHP130), with warning/metrics observations and baselines preserved. The runbook records exact commands, measurements and unrun qualifications. Human review remains required; no P5 execution or physical-frequency qualification is implied.

TINY-R2-P4 implementation and validation; review pending (2026-10-10)

The maintainer approved P4 preflight and implementation on clean source 4db27524a6282ca40d76b935415b89f043d6ea83, specification blob 7e19de49d49efaafacccfa85671e314d53dd15a4. The P4 runbook records architecture, lifecycle, physical binding and matched-image boundaries. P3 results retain their original source attribution; no historical phase or physical qualification is automatically promoted.

Development evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-10-10-05-b4aa59f3e5d9/meta/tiny-r2-p4/. All planned functional gates completed: 1659 Pytest passes and one optional pypdf skip; Tiny ICS55/IHP130 PR and Mini ICS55 behavioral compatibility pass. Both Tiny netlists pass boot and the four-group/32-macro/common-SYS binding checks. Local uncontended latency is three cycles; group-control induction passes. Setup and hold timing remain negative and observational.

report.json retains single-execution matched-binary results; the banked image matches exactly across Verilator and Icarus. CPU-copy cycles improve about 19%/25% for flat/banked images, while isolated burst-16 DMA cycles increase about 2.2 times. This external-frontend throughput regression requires review; no blanket speedup or automatic phase acceptance is claimed. evidence.json rechecks 1972 source inputs and binds the gate, image, model, log and report artifacts. Exact commands, measurements and unrun qualifications are in the runbook.

External fabric stays serialized until P5, which is not authorized. Default Tiny stays ICS55 SAFE24 with PLL off; IHP130 is explicit compatibility.

TINY-R2-P3 implementation in progress (2026-10-08–10)

The retained source-bound compiler/layout matrix is complete for commit 3e46cc80e2d2243233d284b7cd9583714b0773bb, source digest a7fc5112cd6f20df956243c4d081a6a31ede6192cd270e3c13340557b0e58776. All eight configurations pass ordinary Tiny acceptance and three deterministic Verilator cold starts. compat-os-flat, perf-o2-lto-flat and perf-o2-plain-banked also pass three native Icarus cold starts, with exact cross-simulator sample identity. The structured measurement report is build/ics55-tiny-performance-2026-10-09-17-10-53cc6674d532/meta/tiny-r2-p3/report.json. It records software measurements only; it does not close phase acceptance, physical timing, hardware bank conflict or Mini integrated-DMA gates.

Quality evidence for that committed source is complete: full Pytest reports 1629 passed and one environment skip for missing pypdf; focused P3 tests and the embedded/RTL quality checks pass. Its Tiny PR regressions pass for ICS55 and IHP130, and Mini ICS55 behavioral-only compatibility passes. Negative STA margins and non-blocking lint observations remain recorded as observations.

Exact commands, measurements, current evidence roots and remaining qualification limits are in the final section of the P3 review-fix record. Human review and acceptance remain required before any R2-P4 work.

Subsequent P1 race-fix follow-up

The approved follow-up fixes WS2812 completion between register reads and legacy TCD publication across an ISR lease acquisition. Current source is 3e46cc8 plus the two HAL fixes and deterministic host tests; the matrix above remains evidence for the original commit. New evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-10-09-00-b4aa59f3e5d9/meta/tiny-r2-p3-races/. The two new tests fail before their respective fixes and pass afterward; C format/policy/host checks and 156 focused tests pass. Mini PIO compatibility also passes once with strict SIM_TEST_PASS and no forbidden markers. Tiny ICS55/IHP130 PR and Mini ICS55 behavioral regressions each pass once. Final evidence.json checks all 1287 source inputs, 487 Mini PIO compiled inputs and all eight ordinary regression simulations. Lint baseline differences and negative STA remain observations; no timing closure is claimed. See the final review-fix section for commands, hashes, exact paths and unrun gates.

Per the maintainer's follow-up instruction, long checks default to one execution; repeat only for a concrete failure/inconsistency or an explicit acceptance requirement. This follow-up does not repeat the three-cold-start compiler matrix. It does not waive any frozen qualification requirement or reattribute old runs.

Historical development snapshot

The 2026-10-09 execution snapshot in the P3 review-fix record records all eight ordinary Tiny/Verilator compiler experiments completed, with selected Icarus groups still running at that snapshot. The then-current full Pytest result was 1531 passed, 4 failed, 94 fixture errors and 1 skipped; configuration-declaration and publication source/fixture drift were still open. IHP130 Tiny PR completed with non-blocking lint observations and negative STA margin. These results do not replace the final results above or imply human phase acceptance.

The P3 review-fix record closes the retained banked O2 Icarus finding: all three runs completed successfully and match the three Verilator samples after artifact/log/command revalidation. The Mini WS2812 finding remains open: the current Mini memory-only DMA data plane has no route to WS2812 TXDATA, independently reproduced by the production crossbar fixture. Its failed integration run is not relabeled a pass. The user explicitly approved option A on 2026-10-08: retain this unsupported boundary, validate the shared DMA algorithm through host/standalone checks, and use the supported Mini PIO path for compatibility. No production fabric change is part of this follow-up; product-integrated DMA/IRQ service budgets remain pending an actual route.

Option A is implemented and its supported-path checks pass. Mini PIO evidence is bound at build/ics55-2026-10-08-22-57-d0c568d0142e/meta/tiny-r2-p3/option-a-evidence.json: 4/16/33/65-word frames, real DONE IRQ, exact serial waveform/reset-low, underflow/abort recovery, zero DMA starts and strict TEST_STATUS/SIM_TEST_PASS. Focused checks report 96 passed; C/RTL quality, Ruff and diff checks pass. The old Mini DMA failure remains failed/unsupported evidence, not a PIO pass. The full compiler/placement matrix and broader regressions were pending in this initial record; human phase acceptance remains pending. See the review-fix record for exact commands, artifacts, historical attribution and unrun gates.

The user explicitly approved the P3 preflight and implementation on source bab01352f8f7c80e39546b04e3ed37a3d927f475, with a clean worktree at entry. The specification blob is 7e19de49d49efaafacccfa85671e314d53dd15a4 and the preflight ledger blob is bb18d58598eb7e60a166c19fc9da60407ce4bd4c. This authorizes continuing from the implemented R2-P2 and ICS55-P1 SAFE24 foundation; it does not retroactively turn their recorded human-review or physical gaps into passes. Original phase IDs, historical evidence and qualification limits are retained.

The P3 runbook defines compiler/layout experiments, shared finite DMA/WS2812 service, ownership and exact commands. The initial entry recorded implementation and validation in progress; it did not claim phase completion or performance improvement. The existing GNU toolchain was used as requested; no dependency version has been changed.

Early development testing found a compressed-instruction acceptance bug: rs_mcu_unmapped_probe assembled its faulting load as 16-bit 4108, while the test trap handler advances MEPC by four bytes. The performance image therefore skipped its return, first surfacing as I/O code 10 and, with diagnostic layout, a subsequent store-access fault. Explicit .option norvc around the faulting load restores the intended fixed-width probe. The repaired performance banked normal image passes strict Tiny acceptance. This is an acceptance-fixture fix, not a CPU, register ABI or toolchain replacement.

Provisional development evidence is under build/ics55-tiny-performance-2026-10-08-16-14-b6fb322b1bce/; meta/tiny-r2-p3/ retains the first failure, separate diagnostic source/ELF and the Mini SBT sandbox failure. These are development attempts, not the final source-frozen compiler matrix. Mini SBT required the existing environment restriction on Unix socket creation to be lifted for the same approved command.

TINY-ICS55-P1 implementation (2026-10-07–08)

Implementation is based on committed source ecac3559b0ba67fa2630003ad718657969c78af4 plus the retained working-tree diff. The worktree was clean at entry. The preflight specification/ledger Git blobs were 713f3d5a0d04a7b2fc4c66838e9ceaf6c7551263 and 87bc267759d863d98f200e2740abcaa0dcba28a5. This record is separate from the earlier documentation/dependency refreeze and IHP130 R2 measurements. Implementation and validation are complete for review; human phase acceptance is still pending by this entry.

TINY-ICS55-P1 review fixes (2026-10-08)

The read-only review found two implementation issues and both are corrected in the current working tree:

• The quality workflow now restores the locked ICS55 PDK, SRAM views and PLL checkout before the mandatory Pytest step. A fresh checkout with no ICS55 cache restored all inputs through setup-pdk; lock revisions and archive hashes were unchanged.
• The SAFE24 audit now traces SYS backwards through the selected ICS55 P65_1233_PBMUX input receiver and BUFX0P7H7R clock buffer to extclk_i_pad, verifies constant CMOS input enables and rejects constant, unknown, wrong-source, inverter, mux and multiple-driver paths. It records the source trace in the structural report.

Focused review-fix tests pass (128 passed), including negative clock-source mutations and the quality-workflow cache-miss ordering assertion. Ruff, yamllint, actionlint, dependency-lock validation, regression dry-runs and git diff --check pass. A fresh source capture, Yosys synthesis and OpenSTA run at build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-08-10-05-42d5beccb726/ produce a current meta/tiny-ics55-p1/report.json; this remains SAFE24 synthesis/STA observation, not physical qualification. Human review and phase acceptance remain required.

The platform runbook defines ownership and commands. The default configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk selects TINY/ICS55, HAVE_PLL=YES, 128 KiB main SRAM and external 24 MHz SYS. The PLL is physically represented but disabled; standalone PLL192/240 tests do not enable those SoC rates. IHP130 remains an explicit no-PLL profile, and Mini defaults are unchanged.

Changes are limited to platform/profile selection, generated identity and filelists, technology adapters, the standalone PLL digital backend, native pad readback, JTAG smoke, netlist/STA evidence and matching publication-source parsing. Tiny explicitly selects 32 locked 1024x32 SRAM macros through a default-off shared parameter; this is not R2-P4 logical SRAM banking. Tiny's GPIO input remains enabled while driving, with the legacy Mini default intact. No register/API, address, IRQ, DMA channel/request, package assignment or private Crypto storage change is introduced. No new MISRA deviation applies. Dependency versions, warning signatures and metrics policy are unchanged.

Final validation uses BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-10-07-23-22:

• Primary CI/evidence variant: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-07-23-22-42d5beccb726/. Commands, logs and results are in meta/tiny-ics55-p1/validation/; the captured source/tools/views are selected by meta/tiny-ics55-p1/latest-inputs.json.
• Matched workload variant: build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-07-23-22-b4aa59f3e5d9/, APP=bringup. Each simulator runs three cold starts of the original retained P1 HEX, SHA-256 ba24c2dfd727a905f39b644df254e47262c39ab4960ff2614be44402020758b2. Its original image/source manifest remains under build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-05-12-30-fa1c4ce1e303/meta/tiny-r2-p1/binaries/image-ozwo38_b/. The seven fixed workloads are empty-window calibration, CPU, memory, DMA burst 1, DMA burst 16, CPU/DMA contention and descriptor-chain DMA. There is no recompilation or layout experiment in this comparison.

Gate	Current result / retained evidence
Focused checks after the JTAG correction	PASS; 178 platform/provenance/baseline/build tests; earlier memory/debug/clock and publication checks also passed
Final policy and formatting	PASS; validation/policy.json and rtl-format-retry.json; C format/policy/host tests, Ruff, locked dependency schema, RTL style/readiness and changed-file formatting
Regression definitions	PASS; validation/dry-runs.json; Tiny ICS55 PR/nightly are identical, plus IHP130 Tiny and ICS55 Mini PR expansion
Tiny ICS55 PR	PASS; validation/tiny-ics55-pr.json; firmware, Verilator SVA/JTAG, native Icarus/JTAG, Yosys, strict Tiny netlist boot and OpenSTA execution
Tiny IHP130 PR	PASS; validation/tiny-ihp130-pr.json; separate compatibility artifacts, not relabeled ICS55 evidence
Shared Mini compatibility	PASS for firmware, memory/pin/topology/clock-domain checks and Verilator SVA lint; validation/mini-compatibility.json, mini-rtl-lint-retry.json; full Mini PR not run
Source / macro audit	PASS; meta/tiny-ics55-p1/report.json, syn/yosys/tiny-ics55-netlist.json; 32 SRAM macros, 2177 CPU clocked cells on direct SYS, one PLL with constant EN=0
Matched Verilator workload	PASS, three identical samples, same original HEX; all seven workload samples also equal the historical IHP130 reference
Matched Icarus workload	PASS after timeout recovery; runs 1/2 at 13862.428/14242.835 s and recovered run 3 at 15379.18 s. All three samples match Verilator and historical IHP130; original exit-124 attempt is retained, with per-run budgets in matched-report.json
Full Pytest	PASS; 1568 passed / 1 skipped in 3769.75 s on final source; validation/pytest.json; the optional publication retrieval test lacks pypdf
Warning comparison	Non-blocking FAIL observations retained; no signatures regenerated or waived
Metrics	Collected on the actual APP=ci_smoke variants; validation/ics55-ci-metrics.json, ihp130-ci-metrics.json; policy remains observe

In this table validation/ is relative to the primary variant's meta/tiny-ics55-p1/. Verilator SVA CI variants use suffixes 2eb98c0e1fae (ICS55) and 39ea34c082ac (IHP130); IHP130's ordinary CI variant uses bff91e3529ba, all with the same fixed timestamp. Tiny netlist netsim-boot uses a retained 220-byte assembly image and TEST_STATUS/SIM_TEST_PASS; it is not the Mini UART-only boot target or full C netlist qualification.

The native source/input digest is 9566b3f2c06b21b3e06a4513d0163cc9ffcb63e6d68dd665a31f61be6c1e9def. The report rechecks consumed Verilog/JSON/configuration and audit-script hashes, source snapshots, locked tools and post-capture execution timestamps. The seven locked Tiny tools and PDK/model inputs retain their existing versions. Mini's first lint attempt failed at SBT's local Unix socket in the sandbox; the same source/configuration command passed with that environment restriction removed. The initial multi-file formatter invocation was unsupported; individual read-only verification passed without changing source.

The original Icarus attempt is retained as failed at meta/tiny-r2-p1/workloads/iverilog/attempt-_fqxpoam/attempt.json below the matched variant. Runs 1/2 each completed all seven cases and strict Tiny TEST_STATUS/SIM_TEST_PASS, with samples identical to Verilator. Run 3 printed part of its final TCD record before host timeout; the missing completion marker prevents acceptance. The generated recovery driver meta/tiny-ics55-p1/retry_icarus_run3.py below the primary variant checks original source/generated-input/model/tool/image hashes, preserves the two completed run records, and launches a new cold start for repetition 3 only. It retains the failed attempt and individual per-run timeout values. The recovered run 3 passed in 15379.18 seconds with the same seven samples and strict markers. HEX, simulator model, workload parameters and the 100000000-cycle limit are unchanged; this is an execution-budget recovery, not a compiler, layout or architecture experiment. The first recovery launch stopped during provenance validation before starting simulation: the stock runtime validator requires a common timeout for all runs. The generated recovery adapter now invokes that unchanged validator separately with each original command's declared budget. The final phase join uses collect_matched_report.py and writes meta/tiny-ics55-p1/matched-report.json below the primary variant, explicitly preserving per-run budgets and the failed attempt. It does not claim that the ordinary homogeneous-budget baseline report command accepts a mixed-budget record. Project implementation/validator sources and all original run records remain unchanged by this operational recovery.

Final SAFE24 core STA observations, in ns:

PDK	WNS max	TNS max	WNS min / TNS min	Verdict
ICS55	-41.14	-508669.53	0.00 / 0.00	Timing FAIL; observational in this phase
IHP130	-94.28	-1594880.00	0.00 / 0.00	Timing FAIL; compatibility observation

ICS55 sta/opensta/sys-setup.rpt starts at the XPI reset leaf, fanout 4707, and ends at RX FIFO storage; its SYS hold report's worst reported slack is +0.08 ns. coverage.rpt records 43 inputs without input delays, 52 outputs without output delays and 93 unconstrained endpoints. These are the retained core-only analysis boundary, not full-chip IO closure. The clock report has SYS 41.666666667 ns and JTAG 100 ns; no active PLL generated clock is claimed. The electrical/recovery/removal/pulse-width/minimum-period and SRAM input/return reports remain under the same sta/opensta/ directory.

Direct warning checks on the CI variants report 21 new Yosys signatures for ICS55, and 14 Yosys plus one Icarus signature for IHP130, relative to the stored baselines. Lint comparisons report 459/403 signatures respectively. Neither Tiny profile has a stored RTL-lint baseline, so every normalized lint signature is classified as new. The reports include unused parameters, empty ports, vendor model limitations and ABC's Liberty-cache fallback; they are not counts of defects introduced by this phase. The regression preserves their failed observation status while its functional commands pass.

The earlier development variant build/ics55-tiny-2026-10-07-21-00-42d5beccb726/ retains failed attempts: missing unused SRAM interface, wrong 16 KiB macro selection, GPIO readback failure and insufficient constant-disabled PLL proof. Corrected development Verilator/JTAG, mapped-netlist audit and SAFE24 STA subsequently ran, but those results are not substituted for the fresh final campaign. NFS clock-skew warnings are retained; final variants and forced workload compilation avoid reuse of those earlier simulator outputs.

The intermediate 2026-10-07-23-06 campaign exposed an IHP130 Icarus JTAG testbench reset-initialization failure. Four-state waveform inspection showed internal TRST remaining X until release because TCK started after reset. The opt-in test now clocks TCK during asserted external reset before its TAP/DMI sequence; no reset RTL changed. A bounded Icarus probe then completed halt/resume. Ongoing simulations in that campaign were explicitly interrupted before final source recapture; partial workload passes are not final evidence. The initial full Pytest was also interrupted and restarted on final source; its interrupted record stays in that earlier directory. After the correction, 178 focused platform, provenance, baseline and build tests passed.

The required acceptance remains command success, valid sticky TEST_STATUS, SIM_TEST_PASS and no forbidden error marker. UART alone is insufficient. Boot-only netlist checks are narrower than full C netlist acceptance. Timing violations remain failures under the observational pre-final policy; no behavioral result qualifies physical timing, analog PLL lock, PVT, power, package or silicon. The PLL has no LOCK output, no characterized timing arcs and an unresolved upstream license. Its ideal digital supply ties do not define physical rail integration. Full RCU/source switching remains R2-P7.

The next action is read-only feature review followed by explicit human phase acceptance. No commit, push, PR or next-phase advancement is authorized here.

ICS55 default and final timing policy refreeze (2026-10-07)

The 2026-10-07 normative policy selects TINY/ICS55 with HAVE_PLL=YES and SAFE24 startup as the default target. At refreeze, configs/ci/ics55-tiny.mk and TINY-ICS55-P1 platform implementation were pending; configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk was the executable compatibility baseline. The existing 614fa623 commit adds shared ICS55 SRAM inputs, not Tiny enablement.

All pre-final post-synthesis timing results are observations rather than phase completion gates. Keep applicable analysis attempts, macro mapping, netlist function, reset/protocol evidence and explicit FAIL/NOT_RUN attribution. Functional tests, accepted-work barriers, real-time deadlines and strict Tiny command/TEST_STATUS/SIM_TEST_PASS/forbidden-error checks remain mandatory. No warning baseline, metric policy or RTL maturity state is promoted.

The sole final timing campaign combines TINY-R2-P11, SPI-P5, PIOLITE-P5 and PPALITE-P5 after Tiny foundation, SPI, PIO-lite and PPALite functional work. Their checklists require the same complete-product source/config/PDK/netlist; none is an intermediate physical dependency of another feature's functionality. Phase titles containing IHP130 remain historical identifiers; ICS55 is the new default and IHP130 compatibility results must remain separately attributed.

PLL dependency: pdk_ics55_pll, revision 6ebb1a8f7f4ccbccdb7f587664fdfe63cd39e61b, upstream PLL_V02p1. Its managed checkout is .cache/retrosoc/sources/ics55_ecos_pll. Cell/pin-only Liberty, absence of a LOCK output and unresolved upstream license remain explicit integration/release gaps. Acquisition is not hardware evidence. Refreeze validation and downloaded-view hashes are recorded separately below.

The previous freeze and all executed R2-P0/P1/P2 and legacy records below retain their original dates, profiles, source identities, measurements and verdicts. They do not qualify ICS55 or satisfy the new platform-enablement phase.

This record accompanies the Tiny Gen1 contract. The active R2 verification plan below covers Target SoCs: TINY, feature tiny-soc, and the approved performance refreeze. R2 is a roadmap revision, not a new IP or register ABI version. The selected executable baseline remains configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk, IHP130, 24 MHz/no PLL; faster configurations and their physical acceptance do not exist merely because this plan names them.

The R2 freeze itself changed documentation only. Separately authorized R2-P1 implementation and validation are recorded below. Its functional and measurement baseline was accepted with the explicit R2-P2 implementation approval on 2026-10-06; the recorded physical gaps remain open. R2-P2 work is recorded separately below; later implementation and qualification remain pending. Historical TINY-P0 through TINY-P12 identifiers and evidence are preserved under their original scope; the mapping in the main contract transfers outstanding obligations without renaming old results or declaring them passed. Other PDK qualification, new SPI/PIO/BootROM IP and changes to QFN64 or the frozen IO/power-pad budget are outside the original performance-only R2 refreeze. PIO-lite is now a separately approved standard-product extension under piolite.md, with its own pending evidence matrix below; it does not renumber or retroactively expand the R2 phase results. SPI is also a separately approved standard-product extension under spi.md, with pending evidence below. The original performance-only exclusions remain in force for historical R2 work; the separate SPI approval does not turn older results into SPI acceptance. PPALite is the separately approved 2026-10-05 standard-product extension in ppalite.md. Its RAW-compatible inline processing and source qualification have independent pending gates; no earlier result covers them.

The executed historical sections describe the 2026-09-25 initial baseline, with two UARTs, two I2C controllers and the legacy pad mapping. The working tree was uncommitted when that evidence was collected and its readiness remains prototype. Those results do not validate the later package, shared-IP/clock/reset, DVP/framebuffer, R2 performance, PIO-lite, SPI or PPALite freezes.

PIO-lite planned extension evidence

Target SoCs: TINY; feature slug: piolite; approval date: 2026-10-04. The standard-product target adds two state machines sharing 32 x 16-bit program storage, 32-bit ISR/OSR, 16-bit X/Y counters and separate 8 x 32-bit TX/RX FIFOs per state machine. The engine, APB and host DMA endpoints use PCLK at the existing 24/48/60 MHz targets. This section records required future evidence only; no assembler/model, RTL, firmware, DMA, simulation, formal, synthesis, timing, physical or silicon acceptance has been executed for PIO-lite by the freeze. Four-state-machine expansion is not MVP support.

The committed configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk IHP130 24 MHz/no-PLL profile has no PIO-lite integration. New address/IRQ/request/RCU allocations remain planned until their complete executable paths and truthful capabilities exist. The authoritative phase titles and requirements remain in piolite.md. The detailed case matrix and documentation-check record are maintained in the PIO-lite verification ledger.

PIO-lite phase / area	Required evidence and completion boundary	Status
PIOLITE-P0 / contract	Approved ISA/ABI, resources, pin ownership and lifecycle; consistent linked product/GPIO/DMA allocations; preserved legacy/R2 phase IDs/titles and unchanged QFN64 terminals; documentation links and commands.	Documentation freeze only; no implementation result
PIOLITE-P1 / model and assembler	Deterministic encoding and model traces; valid/invalid opcodes, operands, labels, branches, wrap and program-size boundaries; shared 32-word allocation; software error handling and generated program metadata against the frozen ISA.	Pending
PIOLITE-P2 / core and registers	Both independent SMs, divider/delay/branch/shift/counter boundaries, TX/RX full/empty and stalled-instruction behavior; illegal accesses, W1C races, stop/abort/reset, stale-data isolation, program-write restrictions and configuration conflicts; directed/randomized model comparison and focused formal properties.	Pending
PIOLITE-P3 / Tiny integration and HAL	APB 0x1001C000..0x1001CFFF, IRQ24, RCU target15, requests PIOLITE_TX=14 / PIOLITE_RX=15, actual capability discovery, handwritten register parity, freestanding bounded HAL and actual R2-P6/P7 prerequisites; no fourth AXI master or ninth DMA channel.	Pending
PIOLITE-P3 / pad and lifecycle ownership	USER_SELECT reach to all GPIO0-31; unchanged ALT0/ALT1 and dedicated boot/debug/control pads; conflicts, high-impedance reset, existing GPIO synchronizer plus registered bypass/filter stage with FILTER_ENABLE=0, input latency and release; no new PIO synchronizer/raw-pad bypass; reject GPIO gate/reset while PIO owns any pad, including multi-target commands; clock-change and PIO gate/reset drain/restart barriers.	Pending
PIOLITE-P4 / DMA and protocol programs	Approved pin-level acceptance programs in Icarus and Verilator; independently checked data, edge/bit timing, first/last transfer, short frames, FIFO starvation/overflow, bounded recovery and strict Tiny terminal verdict; source-bound throughput and worst observed service gaps.	Pending
PIOLITE-P4 / system contention	TX channel3 only after bulk-owner release, RX channel2 only after complete camera release; no theft of Crypto4/5 or I2S6/7, correct abort/final-response drain and backpressure; CPU/control progress and real FIFO service budgets with actual permitted background traffic.	Pending
PIOLITE-P5 / physical product	PIO-inclusive netlist and source/profile/PDK/corner identity; area/reset load, PCLK STA, GPIO ownership paths, input synchronizers, pad setup/hold/turnaround, simultaneous switching, package/power and CDC/RDC evidence; declared engine rate distinguished from external interface rate.	Pending

PIOLITE-P3 depends on the applicable accepted R2-P6/R2-P7 platform behavior. PIOLITE-P5 may share a run with TINY-R2-P11 only when the same PIO-inclusive source revision, configuration and physical inputs satisfy both contracts. An earlier R2 netlist, standalone PIO test or another SoC's result cannot qualify the extended standard Tiny product. Preserve 128 KiB main SRAM on the same SYS source and rate as the CPU, three external AXI owners, eight central DMA channels and all QFN64/power assignments in every integration run.

Record exact commands and executed simulator/proof coverage when tests are introduced; a skipped/no-op RTL test or reserved request ID is not evidence. Firmware uses SYSCTRL TEST_STATUS and the strict SIM_TEST_PASS/result-file policy. Hardware, pad-speed and PPA claims remain pending until the specific source/profile/PDK evidence passes.

SPI planned extension evidence

Target SoCs: TINY; feature slug: spi; approval date: 2026-10-04. The future standard product adds SPI0: an 8/16-bit PCLK master with separate 8 x 32-bit TX/RX FIFOs, a bounded display transaction queue and DMA V2.2 paced fixed-MMIO requests. Slave operation and continuous double-buffer camera/display are deferred. The committed IHP130 24 MHz/no-PLL profile has no SPI implementation; every implementation, simulator, proof, firmware, workload, synthesis, timing, physical and silicon result below is pending. The detailed matrix and documentation checks belong to the SPI verification ledger.

SPI phase / area	Required evidence and completion boundary	Status
SPI-P0 - Contract and DMA Extension Freeze	Approved SPI/transaction ABI and DMA V2.2 contract; only the four reserved Gen1 ALT cells added; all 64 perimeter assignments, existing assigned alternates and legacy/R2/PIO phase IDs/titles preserved; linked address/IRQ/RCU/request values and documentation checks.	Documentation freeze only; no implementation result
SPI-P1 - SPI Core and Register Implementation	All CPOL/CPHA and 8/16-bit cases, first/last bits, TX/RX FIFO boundaries, partial words, timing changes, CS setup/hold/inactive and retained-CS behavior; invalid register access, W1C races, timeout/abort, stale-session isolation and handwritten register parity.	Pending
SPI-P2 - DMA V2.2 Paced FIFO Integration	Requests 16/17 and truthful capability support, stable grants, single-beat FIFO MMIO, memory-side bursts/boundaries, TX/RX tails, no FIFO double-pop/push, complete descriptor/accepted-response drain and no stale restart; regress existing PIO14/15 and other consumers.	Pending
SPI-P3 - Tiny GPIO RCU and SDK Integration	Accepted R2-P6 frozen Gen1/eight-channel routing and R2-P7 lifecycle prerequisites; APB 0x1001D000..0x1001DFFF, IRQ25, target16, native-ready/USER handoff, raw MISO capture, complete HAL queue/error/recovery behavior and truthful absent capabilities.	Pending
SPI-P3 / GPIO and lifecycle	Preserve sole PIO USER ownership and its synchronizer/filter path. Reject GPIO gate/reset while PIO USER_SELECT or latched SPI sessions remain, including prefill, CS-held and closing state and combined masks; no native-ready inference from zero USER_STATUS; guard loss closes admissions, invalidates work and requires explicit recovery. Gate/reset/PCLK changes need inactive CS and complete wire/DMA/MMIO/descriptor drain.	Pending
SPI-P4 - Display and Snapshot Application Qualification	Pin-level display command/data checks, D/C ordering and setup, source/pixel conversion, exact counts/guards/readback, zero early wire completion, deterministic error recovery and explicit board reset/backlight/TE solution. Camera/PSRAM cases require R2-P8/R2-P9 and execute capture, verify, display, then SD save.	Pending
SPI-P4 / shared ownership and throughput	TX3 only after bulk/PIO release and RX2 only after full DVP/PIO release; no theft of Crypto4/5 or I2S6/7. Measure actual wire rate, source conversion/staging, payload throughput and worst admitted service gaps; strict Tiny terminal verdict in Icarus and Verilator. Nominal PCLK/SCK or double-buffer assumptions are insufficient.	Pending
SPI-P5 - IHP130 Timing and Physical Qualification	Same SPI- and PIO-inclusive source/profile/PDK/corner/netlist as applicable final product gates; actual PCLK STA, SCK/MOSI/CS/D-C output and MISO round-trip setup/hold, GPIO guard/handoff, CDC/RDC, local reset, gate behavior, area/power/IO/package and board evidence.	Pending

SPI0 is allocated at 0x1001D000..0x1001DFFF, IRQ25 and RCU target16; SPI_TX=16 and SPI_RX=17 are DMA request IDs, not new channels. Keep those capabilities absent until complete implementation. Planned RCU support is the actual implemented target mask; 0x0001FFFF is valid only when every target0-16 path exists. GPIO gate/reset veto is based on actual PIO ownership OR the hardware-latched SPI session, not mutable claims or FIFO-empty alone.

The four changed Gen1 rows are GPIO27 ALT0 SCK, GPIO28 ALT1 MOSI, GPIO30 ALT1 MISO and GPIO31 ALT1 CS_N. GPIO30 ordinary D/C replaces MISO in the write-only display profile. R2-P6 first migrates the legacy executable PWM capture routes from GPIO30/31 ALT1 to the already frozen GPIO24/25 ALT0. The complete camera profile plus display consumes all 32 GPIO and preserves GPIO29 NSS1. Board control pins and external CS/reset bias need explicit evidence; changing the internal mux cannot prevent external contention.

SPI-P5 can share physical runs with PIOLITE-P5 and TINY-R2-P11 only when all applicable contracts are satisfied on the same SPI- and PIO-inclusive source revision, configuration, physical inputs and netlist. Earlier baseline/R2 or PIO-only evidence does not qualify the new product. PCLK24/48/60 and arithmetic SCK12/24/30 MHz are target cases, not measured payload rates or qualified pad operation. Preserve the existing 128 KiB CPU-rate main SRAM, eight DMA channels, three external AXI owners and fixed QFN64/power budget. Record documentation validation separately from these pending implementation gates.

PPALite planned extension evidence

Target SoCs: TINY; feature slug: ppalite; approval date: 2026-10-05. The processor contract and case ledger own formats, exact row layout and source/route/lifecycle acceptance. The current IHP130 24 MHz/no-PLL profile has no PPALite. No model/core, source repair, integration, firmware, simulator, proof, performance or physical result is supplied by this documentation freeze.

Phase	Required evidence	Status
PPALITE-P0 - Contract and Camera Route Freeze	Approved processing/RAW route, source correctness predicates, exact metadata/ABI, unchanged package/pinmux/phase IDs, linked resources and documentation checks	Documentation freeze only
PPALITE-P1 - Stream Pixel Core and Reference Model	Exact RGB/YUV ordering, Y-only grayscale, step1/2/4 and phases, odd dimensions/row padding, input markers and backpressure, counters, APB/parity and independent reference evidence	Pending
PPALITE-P2 - DVP Route and Source Qualification	RAW byte/sideband parity, coherent source controls/statistics/errors, full word counts, repeated snapshots, source stop/tail ordering, route barrier and isolated abort/flush; preserve DVP V2/FIFO/Mini	Pending
PPALITE-P3 - Tiny DMA RCU and SDK Integration	Applicable R2-P6/P7, APB 0x1001E000..0x1001EFFF, IRQ27/target17, exact direct DMA2/request11 admission, source guards, truthful capabilities, bounded HAL and no new DMA request/master	Pending
PPALITE-P4 - Camera Memory and Display Qualification	R2-P8/P9 and applicable SPI prerequisites; QVGA gray/decimated patterns, SRAM/PSRAM pixel/padding/canary checks, stride-aware SD/display, delayed responses/errors/recovery and both simulators	Pending
PPALITE-P5 - IHP130 Timing and Physical Qualification	Same complete PPALite/PIO/SPI-inclusive source/profile/PDK/netlist for all shared gates; actual clock, reset/CDC/RDC, storage, area/power, DVP/memory/Pad and physical evidence	Pending

PPALite adds no Pad or alternate-function assignment. RAW remains reset-default; processed direct DMA uses the existing DVP_RX11 endpoint and camera channel2, with padded row size rather than raw 2*W*H. The global all-DMA barrier applies to RAW/PROCESS route changes, not every capture in a fixed processing route. Retain existing SPI/PIO request meanings and other channel owners.

Source SYNC/SIZE/PARTIAL detection and current16-bit word statistics require explicit closure; PPA counts cannot validate bytes the source discarded. Test legal odd-pixel halfword tails separately from incomplete sensor pixels, source counts above65535 words, coherent repeated EOF/error epochs and no premature success-path flush. PIPE_DONE can precede source EOF or target B responses; final valid data needs every predicate. Missing PIXCLK/cleanup acknowledgement keeps the failed session closed and owned, not reset or buffer-reusable.

The upstream512 B FIFO still fills at raw byte rate. Processing reduces output volume but not sensor clock or the raw no-service budget. New buffering counts as extra slack only with proven occupancy/credit coverage. No measured FPS, physical rate or complete extended-product qualification is implied here.

R2 pending phase acceptance

The following is the active monotonically increasing sequence. Every phase uses the preceding accepted R2 contract and its declared prerequisites; the old P10 -> P7 execution order below is historical. Documentation approval is not implementation acceptance. Final physical qualification is R2-P11 work, not a prerequisite to the architectural improvements in R2-P3 through R2-P5.

Active phase	Required evidence and completion boundary	Status
TINY-R2-P0 - Performance Contract and Roadmap Freeze	Reviewable requirements, exact old/new phase mapping, invariant package/IO counts, same-frequency CPU/main-SRAM ownership, explicit performance budgets, links and commands. Record actual documentation checks separately.	Documentation freeze only; no hardware result
TINY-R2-P1 - Reproducible Baseline, Constraints and Measurements	Reviewed source/profile/lock/tool identity; current 24 MHz functional and workload baseline; clocks, reset endpoints, constraints and timing-exception audit; counters and comparison methodology. Historical WNS is a risk reference, not a refreshed measurement.	Functional/measurement baseline accepted by explicit P2 approval on 2026-10-06; timing, warning and physical gaps retained
TINY-R2-P2 - Reset Distribution and CPU/SRAM Clock Feasibility	Reset distribution and payload-reset semantics; locked IHP130 main-SRAM macro timing, candidate common CPU/SRAM periods and representative paths; early clock/reset feasibility with explicit gaps. No final routed/PVT pass is implied.	Implementation and evidence ready for review; all analyzed rates retain timing failures; phase acceptance pending human review
TINY-R2-P3 - Software and DMA Scheduling	Compiler and placement A/B results, finite DMA ownership, burst/chunk scheduling and available-path correctness; approved option A retains product DMA/IRQ budget qualification for the platform that supplies the route.	Matrix retained on 3e46cc8; subsequent two P1 HAL fixes and focused/compatibility checks complete in the worktree; human review/acceptance pending
TINY-R2-P4 - Dual-Port Hazard3 and Four-Bank Local SRAM	Actual separate I/D paths, four independent 32 KiB bank frontends, SYS-clocked physical main-SRAM macros, local latency/fairness, FENCE.I, debug/reset and early inventory/SDC/macro-binding updates.	Implementation and planned functional validation complete on 4db2752 plus retained worktree snapshot; matched-image DMA throughput regression and human phase acceptance pending review; timing remains observational
TINY-R2-P5 - Per-Target Concurrent Fabric	Cross-target concurrency, one combined transaction per target, central-DMA read/write overlap, AW/W binding, errors, simultaneous faults/counters and accepted-transfer drain.	Pending
TINY-R2-P6 - Shared IP and Eight-Channel DMA Integration	Legacy P7 obligations; shared PWM reporting, I2S slave and alternate-input-route prerequisites; common ABI/HAL parity; Crypto banks/lifecycle; truthful capabilities and affected Mini compatibility.	Pending
TINY-R2-P7 - Tiny RCU and Dual-Mode Clock/Reset Integration	Legacy P8 obligations with main SRAM in SYS and XPI in MEM; atomic rate changes, all actual CDC/reset barriers, clock failures, WFI leaf gating and reserved DVP controls.	Human accepted 2026-10-15 at 655c587; full long Icarus firmware and physical/timing gaps remain explicitly deferred
TINY-R2-P8 - XPI PSRAM Framebuffer Bring-up	Legacy P11 obligations: real pin-level NSS1 device transport, CPU/DMA mapped-write readback, boundaries/recovery, payload rate and worst backpressure.	ICS55/IHP130 Verilator, focused dual-simulator, synthesis, netlist boot, STA and promoted reports complete; full long Icarus deferred and human P8 acceptance pending
TINY-R2-P9 - DVP Camera Profile and Frame Capture Integration	Legacy P12 obligations: unchanged DVP ABI/FIFO, DMA2/request 11, exact frame length, final-tail drain, snapshots/crops, missing-clock recovery and camera/audio exclusion.	Pending
TINY-R2-P10 - System Performance and Regression Qualification	Complete current-profile functional regression and workload/contention A/B, measured real-time budgets, synthesis/macro mapping, netlist checks and explicit missing coverage.	Pending
TINY-R2-P11 - IHP130 Physical and Product Qualification	Final joint CPU/main-SRAM timing, CTS/reset distribution, extracted PVT/IO/package/power evidence, qualified clock/PLL inputs and device operating points; close remaining legacy P9 obligations.	Pending

R2 clock, reset and macro evidence

For new work apply the default ICS55 binding and timing policy above. The following matrix retains frequency and functional obligations for both explicitly selected PDKs; historical measurements remain IHP130-only. The main 128 KiB SRAM includes its actual physical macro clock pins. It MUST use the same SYS source and active frequency as the CPU, with no hidden main-SRAM divider, CPU/main-SRAM CDC or half-rate fallback. The old P6/P10 assignment of main SRAM to MEM is historical and is superseded for R2. Four logical 32 KiB banks do not mean four physical macros: verify the real selected-PDK mapping (32 OpenECOS 1024x32 macros for ICS55) and preserve the complete 128 KiB capacity. Crypto's six private banks remain additional storage in PCLK and retain their own lifecycle.

Target profile	CPU and actual main SRAM / SYS	XPI / MEM	Shared peripherals and Crypto / PCLK
Safe boot	24 MHz	24 MHz	24 MHz
No-PLL fast, XIN96	96 MHz	96 MHz	48 MHz
PLL I/O	192 MHz	96 MHz	48 MHz
PLL peak	240 MHz	120 MHz	60 MHz

Also test external XIN24 and XIN48 at the declared 24/24/24 and 48/48/48 MHz SYS/MEM/PCLK rates. These are target cases, not qualified operating points. At 192/240 MHz the actual main-SRAM clock periods are approximately 5.208/4.167 ns. R2-P2 must inspect the locked macro timing views, minimum period/pulse widths, setup/hold, clock-to-output and representative bank paths. Wait states or a registered response do not repair a violated macro minimum clock period. An unsupported target remains an explicit delivery gap; lowering the common CPU/SRAM rate requires a reviewed profile/contract change and must not silently restore CPU240/SRAM120. R2-P11 adds CTS, extracted parasitics, skew/uncertainty and actual macro/standard-cell PVT evidence before rate claims.

R2-P1 audits the existing clock/reset inventory. R2-P4 updates it, the local path constraints and physical macro instance bindings as soon as the new bank hierarchy exists; it must not postpone those updates until RCU integration. R2-P7 adds dynamic SYS lifecycle, XPI MEM division and the actual domain bridges. CPU/main-SRAM accesses remain within SYS; DMA PCLK-to-SYS and SYS-to-XPI MEM crossings retain complete request/response and reset barriers. Main-SRAM control access follows SYS ownership. Rate reporting must make SYS_HZ authoritative for CPU/main SRAM and MEM_HZ authoritative for XPI.

For clock transitions, acknowledge the RCU command before blocking new target admissions on both local CPU I/D and external AXI paths. Exercise continuing instruction fetch and data requests while draining all accepted bank operations, frontend responses and crossing state. Blocked-but-unaccepted requests must remain stable rather than refill the drain set; no accepted request may be lost, replayed or completed twice across the common SYS clock change.

The existing WFI exception gates only the idle CPU leaf after its accepted work drains. It does not divide SYS or gate the main SRAM, fabric or DMA service paths. Verify IRQ/debug wake and ongoing DMA access while the CPU leaf is stopped. Cold/warm/watchdog/hart/peripheral reset, asynchronous assertion, five valid local release edges and CPU-last release all require directed evidence. Missing AUDIO/PIXCLK or software Crypto READY must not block CPU startup. A reset-done indication is not Crypto READY or ZEROIZED.

For ordinary FIFOs, removing payload reset is permitted only after proving the existing observable empty/reset/flush behavior, no stale-word visibility, correct validity/pointer state and restart barriers. Main SRAM remains uncleared by reset. Crypto is not an ordinary payload-reset optimization: retain immediate invalidation, scalar clearing, full required SRAM write-zero/readback-zero sweeps and physical FIFO-payload erasure. Test late responses, stalled outputs, interrupted scrub and no early erasure success.

R2 functional and performance matrix

Every row is pending and must identify its requirement, R2 phase, exact implementation, profile and executed test. Keep functional correctness and cycle-level performance distinct from physical frequency qualification.

Area / phases	Required cases and objective evidence
Independent banks and I/D paths, R2-P4/P5	Exercise simultaneous I and D traffic to different banks plus DMA/SDIO traffic; prove each of the four 32 KiB banks has its own frontend and can serve independently. A bank decoder behind one serialized controller is insufficient. Cover every bank boundary, byte lane, first/last word and full-capacity/alias checks.
Local service and fairness, R2-P4/P5	Measure from accepted CPU AHB address phase to terminal data-phase completion, with clocks running, an uncontended bank, response capacity available and no lifecycle stall. The engineering budget is <=3 SYS cycles; report reads/writes and I/D separately. Report admission waiting separately so delayed acceptance cannot conceal latency. Same-frequency operation alone does not prove zero-wait service. Under contention, exercise beat-level bank grant fairness, maximum legal bursts and bounded service opportunities without violating AXI transaction ownership.
Per-target admission, R2-P5	Each target permits at most one combined read-or-write transaction until its B or RLAST response handshake. Independent targets may progress together. Cover all requester/target combinations, same-target serialization, backpressure and target/page/alignment errors; preserve VALID payload and response identity.
DMA read/write overlap and AW/W, R2-P5/P6	Central DMA may hold one outstanding read and one outstanding write; different targets overlap while same-target requests obey the combined target limit. Test W-before-AW, delayed W, stalled B/R, rejected writes and interleaved unrelated traffic. Bind every accepted W beat to the correct accepted AW owner/length; no reassignment or untagged write interleaving.
Faults and counters, R2-P1/P5/P10	Inject simultaneous faults and completions on different targets. Verify deterministic first-fault retention, correct requester/address/response, no lost independent fault events, correct aggregate count and source attribution. Backpressure must not recount a held event; concurrent events must not collapse into one boolean increment. Check clear/snapshot precedence and the frozen counter overflow semantics.
CPU ordering and lifecycle, R2-P4/P5/P7	Verify FENCE.I after data writes to executable SRAM, required store/response drain and instruction refetch. Exercise interrupts, debug halt/resume and hart reset with both I/D paths active; hart reset waits for accepted CPU work while unrelated DMA remains usable. Cold/system reset must discard the old session consistently, and graceful drains must retain all accepted responses.
Compiler and placement A/B, R2-P3/P4/P10	Use identical workloads, input/checksum, compiler identity, ISA/ABI and recorded flags. Separate compiler-only, bank-placement-only and combined comparisons; retain linker map, text/data/BSS/stack sizes and bank assignment. Compare cycles/instructions, I/D stalls, DMA throughput and latency against a reviewed baseline, not an unrelated historical build. Validate bank-aware code, data, stack and DMA-buffer placement and instruction synchronization.
WS2812 finite refill, R2-P3/P6/P10	Keep the existing register ABI and fixed-MMIO DMA path. With exclusive producer ownership, use watermark 8 and an observed FIFO level L to schedule at most min(remaining, 16-L) words. Exercise empty/full levels, short final chunks, stale observation with only consumer draining, timeout, abort and ownership release. Competing CPU/DMA producers must not invalidate the credit calculation; ownership and the submitted transfer remain finite.
Real-time service budgets, R2-P3/P8/P9/P10	Account for software/IRQ delay, arbitration, DMA, bridge/APB or serial service, maximum backpressure and margin. Prove the refill/service deadline against available FIFO slack under the declared competing traffic. Record WS2812 underrun/reset-gap behavior and DVP overflow invalidation; average throughput or bank count alone is not a worst-case guarantee. Unsupported traffic combinations must be explicit.
Gen1 shared integration, R2-P6/P7	Eight DMA channels and frozen channel/request bindings; RNG qualification rejection; CRC tails/FINISH; Crypto initialization/readback/lock, vectors and erasure; I2S/SDIO contention; dynamic PWM rate reporting, slave-audio and exclusive alternate-input prerequisites. Run affected Mini consumers without treating their results as Tiny evidence.
XPI/DVP retained acceptance, R2-P8/P9/P10	Execute the archived transport/frame cases below under the R2 phase mapping. Retain pin-level NSS1 PSRAM, measured write backpressure, exact frame length and guard/readback checks. DVP frame-done does not complete the final DMA word or AXI write response: never flush the undrained tail or publish a valid frame early. Preserve the DVP ABI/FIFO, DMA2/request 11 and capture-then-readback/save scope.
Clock/reset, package and ABI, R2-P4/P7/P11	Test the R2 domain ownership and lifecycle above, truthful staged capabilities, SRAM-only boot, fixed QFN64/32 GPIO/16 power-ground budget and unchanged frozen alternates. Maintain common addresses, IRQs, register/HAL parity and documented fault semantics; no new SPI/PIO/BootROM or extra IO is implied.

R2 evidence classes and required validation

Evidence class	Required record	Claim boundary
Functional	Actual Icarus and Verilator executions, strict terminal markers and result files, focused protocol/reset/error tests, and applicable formal/host tests separately identified	Does not establish performance or qualified clock rate
Performance	Reproducible workload/compiler/placement A/B, cycle and instruction counts, service latency, throughput, contention and worst observed backpressure with stated workload bounds	A simulated clock assumption is not physical frequency evidence; observed maxima alone are not a universal bound
Synthesis and netlist	Current selected-PDK mapping of every main-SRAM/Crypto bank, area/cells, reset fanout, critical paths, netlist boot and applicable full-function checks	Pre-final timing is observational; library area is not die area and compact netlist boot does not replace full firmware or routed timing
Physical	Final combined complete-product campaign: source/profile/tool/PDK/corner/SDC identity; macro checks, CTS/reset distribution, extracted setup/hold/recovery/removal, CDC/RDC, IO/package/power and device timing	Mandatory final closure; behavioral PLL and pre-layout STA do not qualify an operating point or constitute foundry signoff

Each result must preserve commands, full logs, source revision, configuration digest, build variant, dependency/tool identity, library corners, simulator mode, workload and firmware identity. Record failures, skipped/no-op tests and missing artifacts explicitly. The historical -455.18 ns WNS below belongs to the original 2026-09-25 run; it is not the current R2 WNS or proof that any new rate is achievable. Physical feasibility and final qualification require new evidence for the actual CPU/main-SRAM clocks and reset distribution.

Use the implementation validation entrypoints and baseline commands in the main contract, with directed R2 cases and any new committed profiles added through the normal flow. The current IHP130 Tiny profile remains the starting point. Register integrated cases in normal regression; tests/test_xpi_io.py, tests/test_dvp.py, fast-flash and host-only tests do not replace the complete required hardware route. Preserve strict SIM_TEST_PASS/result-file verdicts and run affected Mini compatibility for shared changes. Do not remove unsupported PLL/STA guards, alter dependencies, or change warning/metric policy to manufacture a pass. Metrics remain observe mode; synthesis, simulation and timing failures remain recorded failures.

No R2 test, benchmark or PPA result is claimed by this verification-plan edit. Actual documentation-only validation is recorded separately after execution.

2026-10-07 refreeze execution record

Scope: specification/ledger/guide changes and locked PLL acquisition only. The starting source was 614fa6237b6be5a14f51b39d1012a3ca79e1ad52; the existing ECC work was subsequently committed as 14a253a49aa477e82f71bdbeb752280fff99b535 without changing the protected working-file contents. No Tiny profile, RTL, firmware, SDC, warning baseline or metric policy was changed by this refreeze.

Validation artifacts are under build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-07-18-10-414a31ff29aa/meta/tiny-refreeze-ics55-pll/. The existing IHP130 profile supplies the artifact namespace only; these are dependency/document/tooling checks, not new IHP130 or ICS55 hardware evidence. The proposed ICS55 Tiny profile remains absent.

Check	Result / artifact
Dependency lock	PASS; lock.json, 31 sources and 22 archives; only the approved PLL source was added to the existing working lock
PLL restore and repetition	PASS; setup.json, setup-repeat.json; both logs record full SHA and all seven view hashes; checkout clean
Focused dependency tests	PASS; focused.json, 19 tests including missing/wrong views, wrong revision, dirty checkout, idempotence and component isolation
Ruff	PASS; ruff.json
Full Pytest	PASS; pytest.json, 1541 passed / 1 skipped in 3593.34 s; the optional PDF retrieval test lacks pypdf, not a Tiny hardware gate
Existing regression definitions	PASS; tiny-pr-dry.json, tiny-nightly-dry.json, mini-ics55-pr-dry.json; dry-runs only
Documentation/source audit	PASS; audit-delivery.json; unchanged original phase titles, package/pinmux/RCU tables, historical R2/legacy evidence and unrelated ECC contents; added local links and PLL interface checked

The first clone failed with an HTTP/2 transport error before checkout. The same SHA was fetched with a command-local HTTP/1.1 override, then both ordinary helper runs passed without a version change. An initial test fixture inherited host Git signing; the fixture now disables signing/hooks for its own temporary commits only. No repository commit or global Git setting was made by this task.

evidence.json indexes the successful gates and final source/input snapshot. The downloaded behavioral/blackbox views agree on 15 ports; min/typ/max Liberty contains no timing arcs. No LOCK output, characterized PLL timing or resolved upstream license was discovered. These remain pending integration/release gaps. SoC firmware/regression executions, full-SoC synthesis/netlist/STA, physical flows and generated publications are NOT_RUN by this documentation/dependency scope. Full Pytest's existing isolated fixtures are not product qualification. TINY-ICS55-P1 remains pending explicit preflight/implementation approval.

R2-P0 documentation checks (2026-10-04)

The working-tree documentation checks passed:

• Package, power and GPIO tables match the preceding contract; all 64 perimeter numbers remain unique and the 32 GPIO assignments are unchanged.
• All 13 legacy phase headings and planning bodies are preserved, while the 12 approved R2 headings are unique and sequential. Requirement identifiers TINY-001 through TINY-036 are unique and ordered.
• The four contiguous 32 KiB ranges total 128 KiB and retain 32 physical 4 KiB macros. SYS and XPI MEM table values match the same-frequency contract.
• The initial 24 MHz architecture block and the executed historical record from "Configuration and artifact roots" onward match the preceding revision.
• All 119 local Markdown links across the 13 changed documents resolve; referenced profile, CPU/device-model sources and test entrypoints exist.
• The local-admission clock-change rule and three-cycle latency measurement endpoints were cross-checked between the main contract and this matrix.

The selected executable profile remains configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk, IHP130, 24 MHz/no PLL. The following commands passed; Windows used the installed python entrypoint for the two command-list checks:

python scripts/regress.py --root . --suite pr --pdk IHP130 --soc TINY --dry-run
python scripts/regress.py --root . --suite nightly --soc TINY --dry-run
git diff --check

These are documentation and command-selection checks, not R2 hardware results. No RTL, firmware, configuration, dependency, warning-baseline or metrics-policy file is changed. No C/MISRA deviation is introduced. Firmware compilation, RTL/formal simulation, full quality/regression suites, synthesis, netlist, STA and physical qualification were not run in this documentation phase. Actual main-SRAM macro timing and joint high-frequency qualification remain pending; no SRAM or CPU maximum frequency is established here.

R2-P1 implementation evidence (2026-10-05)

Target SoCs: TINY; profile configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk; PDK IHP130, 24 MHz/no PLL. The approved source parent is bfdc3ffaf6cb0a134314272ac1b0f8b504d0b09c. These are uncommitted implementation runs, identified by retained source/input hashes and archives in addition to the Git parent. They must not be presented as clean-commit release evidence. The baseline runbook specifies workloads, observation endpoints, retained-image replay, commands and the clock/reset/constraint audit.

The implementation adds a separate finite measurement image, optional testbench observers and fail-closed evidence collection. Normal Tiny acceptance firmware, hardware, register/SDK ABI, profile, dependency versions, warning baselines and metrics policy are unchanged. The existing flat SRAM layout is retained; no compiler or banking experiment belongs to these results.

Environment restoration uses .cache/retrosoc/development/tiny-r2-p1/activate.sh. The original local Verilator/Icarus/OpenSTA archives did not match the lock. The new isolated installation verifies all seven selected tool archives against the unchanged lock; the original installations are preserved. A sandbox DNS failure and a Yosys download timeout are retained as failed attempts; the successful restore reused the checksum-matching local Yosys/GCC archives. Locked Python packages and both behavioral/full-flow doctor checks passed.

Initial development evidence is under build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-05-11-19-fa1c4ce1e303/meta/tiny-r2-p1/. The PR campaign uses BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-10-05-12-15; the final workload campaign uses BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-10-05-12-30. Each configuration retains its own variant. Workload attempts preserve the binary's original identity separately from the simulator source. Early failed instrumentation attempts are not acceptance: a comment interpreted as a tool pragma and an incorrectly formatted AXI observation record were corrected in the testbench without modifying production RTL. An intermediate Icarus measurement attempt was explicitly interrupted to strengthen artifact and repeat-consistency revalidation; its outer result records exit 130 and cannot qualify the baseline. Independent normal acceptance and PR runs were preserved.

Current completed checks:

Gate	Retained result and boundary
Lock and configuration	Dependency lock, Tiny address/pin/topology/clock-reset checks and selected tool doctors passed.
Focused tests	Initial 58-case Tiny/protocol/reset/SRAM/parity/collector set passed. The final collector's 41 unit tests also passed, including modified-image, mixed-repeat and mismatched-verdict rejection. Counts overlap and are not additive coverage.
Software and source policy	Software format/policy/host tests, Make/RTL format, owned RTL style, readiness and Ruff passed. SVA ASIC lint completed; warnings retain the unchanged observation policy.
Normal firmware, Verilator	Command and terminal checks passed at 3,744,261 cycles.
Normal firmware, Icarus	Command and terminal checks passed at the same 3,744,261 cycles; wall duration 1522.098 seconds. This is full SDK/IRQ/DMA/watchdog acceptance, not netlist or physical evidence.
Final workload, Verilator	Three independent cold-reset runs passed with identical records at 18,458,948 terminal cycles.
Final workload, Icarus	All three retry runs passed strict command/terminal/log acceptance at the same 18,458,948 cycles; wall durations 10878.451, 10851.610 and 10832.133 seconds. The earlier 10800-second attempts remain failed.
Cross-simulator baseline	Final report passed: all six cold-reset runs use the same retained HEX and agree on every parsed workload/observer record; source, model, firmware, log and verdict integrity checks passed. This is functional/measurement evidence, not physical qualification.
Regression selection	Explicit TINY/IHP130 PR and nightly dry-runs passed and select the same current Tiny matrix. Nightly adds no distinct Tiny execution.
Full Pytest	1476 passed, 1 skipped in 3574.13 seconds. The skipped PDF retrieval test requires pypdf. The suite began before final collector hardening; the 41-case collector suite was run after that hardening.
PR runner	Completed with exit zero, including SVA Verilator, full-firmware Icarus, synthesis, netlist boot and STA. Warning observations failed and timing did not close; runner completion is not a physical acceptance verdict.
Yosys, balanced	Completed in 311.874 seconds, 207697 cells, 9107224.664998 square micrometers of library area, 32 main-SRAM macros. These are current baseline values, not a like-for-like improvement over historical results.
Icarus netlist boot	Strict command/terminal/checker success at 29362 cycles, 151.389 seconds. Full C firmware netlist execution remains unrun.
OpenSTA	Command completed in 13.521 seconds. Setup WNS -455.18 ns and TNS -13049600 ns; hold WNS/TNS zero. Timing qualification failed.
Clock/reset netlist audit	32 direct flat main-SRAM A_CLK loads of u_clock_buffer/clk_o; 29605 structural reset-reachable endpoints using all arcs. This is not CDC/RDC or reset-tree timing closure.

The retained workload image is build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-05-12-30-fa1c4ce1e303/meta/tiny-r2-p1/binaries/image-ozwo38_b/. BIN SHA-256 is b98b981f397af5f3a1d9cc15157726e77a8d7f21c68c1691cdc9b1beecbf4293; HEX SHA-256 is ba24c2dfd727a905f39b644df254e47262c39ab4960ff2614be44402020758b2. Its .text is 9836 bytes, .bss is 76736 bytes, BIN is 10080 bytes and remaining SRAM above _ebss is 44480 bytes. The normal flat linker still reports its existing RWX LOAD-segment warning; it is not hidden by a linker or warning-policy change.

The final Verilator attempt workloads/verilator/attempt-vvytd6pz and Icarus retry workloads/iverilog/attempt-yu79tkc8 produced the following identical raw measurements in all six accepted runs. No partial or timed-out run contributes to this table. Cycles and instructions cover the specified workload envelope, including submission/polling overhead but excluding initialization, readback and UART. Empty-window overhead is reported without subtraction.

Case	Cycles	Retired instructions	Payload bytes	CPU kernel cycles	CPU / DMA admission-wait cycles
empty	137	12	0	0	0 / 0
cpu	98663	32830	0	98343	0 / 0
memory	754159	213076	65536	0	0 / 0
dma1	258772	32594	65536	0	114688 / 105056
dma16	71444	7601	65536	0	37888 / 6416
contention	1638244	530481	65536	1603696	37888 / 5520
tcd	1639540	530498	65536	1604848	39040 / 6208

The contention cases each execute 16 CPU kernels; the CPU-only case executes one. Each TCD case additionally reads 4096 descriptor bytes. Full per-owner latency, backpressure, outstanding-transaction and SRAM records are retained in the attempt JSON/logs. Payload-per-cycle is payload bytes divided by the whole workload envelope; contention-case values include the concurrent CPU work and must not be labeled isolated DMA bandwidth or physical throughput.

The synthesis/netlist/STA variant is build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-05-12-15-19f1e9c571ee/ (APP=ci_smoke). Its netlist SHA-256 is 69195dc4050725d5cdbb9fedc213f675cedc6470492c84b2704f8ba535b4a29f. The fresh STA command consumes that netlist and its generated core SDC at the slow corner; the netlist hash differs from the inspected October 2 run. The equal historical/current WNS values therefore remain separately attributed. The current worst path is u_soc.s_rst_n_reg/Q through the reset-dependent I2C0 FIFO data path to u_soc.u_i2c0/u_i2c_reg.u_rx_fifo.r_storage[4]_0__reg/D. No reset optimization or new timing exception was used to hide that result.

The final workload variant's meta/tiny-r2-p1/constraints/ contains source-audit.json, the generated reset-clock-audit.tcl and its command result, clock/reset endpoint reports, and synthesis-sta-evidence.json binding the consumed libraries, netlist, SDC, reports and compact boot binaries. The query reuses the completed netlist and unchanged SDC; it does not run PnR or alter constraints. Synthesis uses typical 1.20 V/25 C libraries, while STA uses the selected slow 1.08 V/125 C views and IO 3.0 V corner.

There is no committed quality/warnings/ihp130-tiny/ baseline. Consequently the ASIC lint observation reports 399 new signatures; the actual CI variant reports one Icarus and 14 Yosys signatures. Icarus reports unsupported edge-sensitive ifnone model paths. Yosys observations include asynchronous load-value warnings, combinational-network messages and the temporary SCL-cache rename/conversion fallback to Liberty. The standalone warning commands fail; the regression preserves its existing non-blocking observation behavior. No warning signature or metrics policy was edited. Explicit CI-variant metrics were collected because the runner's final default-APP observation targets do not select its CI synthesis variant.

The first final-source Icarus campaign (workloads/iverilog/attempt-cwvkmh4t) reached the 10800-second host timeout in all three runs (exit 124). Each log contains all 28 observer records and reaches the last UART case result. Since the firmware prints these records only after every case and complete memory readback succeeds, this establishes continued functional progress, but the missing final terminal marker still prevents acceptance. No RTL error or cycle-limit timeout was reported. validation/iverilog-timeout-diagnosis.json retains the failed results, logs and host-stdio tool hashes. The previously observed 22 complete observer rows matched Verilator in all three runs; partial output was never promoted to PASS.

The retry uses the identical retained image and production RTL with SOC_SIM_TIME=14400 and host line-buffered output. It does not change the 100000000-cycle bound or verdict rules. All three runs completed successfully between 18:46:45 and 18:47:31 Asia/Shanghai. The final cross-simulator aggregation also passed. Its result is build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-05-12-30-fa1c4ce1e303/meta/tiny-r2-p1/baseline-report.json; the exact aggregation command and exit-zero result are retained under the same root in validation/baseline-report.log and validation/baseline-report.json. Implementation and reproducible baseline evidence are ready for human review; this record does not automatically accept P1 or authorize another phase. P1 does not qualify 24 MHz timing, the QFN64 package, external Tiny JTAG, 96/192/240 MHz operation, or any later R2/PIO/SPI/PPALite phase. No additional MISRA deviation is introduced; the automated software gates remain partial checks rather than certification. Historical records below retain their original source, dates, stage IDs and qualification boundaries.

R2-P1 evidence-tool repair (2026-10-05 through 2026-10-06)

The read-only review of the seven-file implementation found two issues: the selected VVP executable was not bound to the recorded locked Icarus installation (P1), and image.json.compiler_command was overwritten by the last post-processing command (P2). The original image's hashed compile.json still contains the actual GCC invocation. Neither finding changes the previously recorded simulation results or establishes a hardware failure.

The separately approved repair changes only scripts/tiny_r2_baseline.py, its focused tests, this ledger and the baseline runbook. The runner validates the selected runtime before compilation, launches its verified absolute path, retains its version/binary/archive identity, and rechecks it with actual run commands at aggregation. The image producer preserves the compiler command separately from its post-processing commands. Historical artifacts are not rewritten to add provenance that they did not originally record.

Repair evidence uses build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-05-20-02-fa1c4ce1e303/meta/tiny-r2-p1/. The focused suite passed 55 cases, including rejection before compilation for external/missing runtimes and invalid installation markers, retained-runtime and launch-command checks, and compiler-command preservation. Full Pytest passed 1492 cases with one skipped PDF retrieval test (pypdf unavailable), in 3539.14 seconds. Ruff and explicit TINY/IHP130 PR/nightly dry-runs passed. These are local results; no new hosted CI or physical run is claimed.

The new metadata-validation image is binaries/image-watrhx9n/. Its retained compiler_command equals the actual GCC command in compile.json; the independent check is retained as validation/compiler-metadata.json and its log. This image does not replace the original matched binary. Verilator attempt workloads/verilator/attempt-86h7qnqw passed all three cold-reset repetitions using the explicit original image-ozwo38_b/tiny_baseline.hex. Icarus attempt workloads/iverilog/attempt-axv8qwr6 also passed all three repetitions at 18,458,948 cycles; wall durations were 10858.884, 10844.051 and 10923.896 seconds. All completed between 00:10:02 and 00:11:22 Asia/Shanghai on October 6. The recorded runtime is Icarus vvp 13.0 from the isolated locked installation, binary SHA-256 7b5521fbaf86c519603e824e189c767790424ea6914f3dadeda438136d5eaba7. Each retained flow command launches that absolute executable. Runtime binary, archive and launch-command checks passed after simulation and at aggregation.

The repair root's baseline-report.json passed all six runs, with original HEX SHA-256 ba24c2dfd727a905f39b644df254e47262c39ab4960ff2614be44402020758b2. validation/previous-baseline-comparison.json additionally checks that both simulators retain the original image manifest and identical measurements to the preceding campaign. Only the evidence collector changed among the archived executable inputs; the old image, old attempts and old report remain unmodified. Both review fixes now have focused and end-to-end evidence ready for human re-review, not automatic phase acceptance.

Production RTL, testbench, firmware, Make targets, selected profile, dependency versions, warning baselines and metrics policy are unchanged by this repair. The earlier failed timing qualification and all unrun physical/debug/PVT gates remain open. No phase acceptance or subsequent-phase authorization is implied.

R2-P2 implementation evidence (2026-10-06)

The approved starting revision is f06c039e790e38ccaf336ff21b68619010e7cc9e on dev, clean before work. Target TINY, profile configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk, PDK IHP130, 24 MHz/no PLL remain fixed. The reset/feasibility runbook owns the commands, reset-leaf mapping, measurement endpoints and qualification boundaries.

Before editing RTL, fresh firmware, Yosys and STA completed under build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-06-09-33-19f1e9c571ee/ (APP=ci_smoke). meta/tiny-r2-p2/baseline-inputs/identity.json retains the clean source/tools; baseline-artifacts.json additionally binds generated inputs, netlist/config, SDC and native flow results. The source input digest is 336aa85c3f213104d0d4b875ae18a427a403bb829c775904784311fd865cbfd0 and netlist SHA-256 is 7caefc1d53aeec3d506efea6d90a7dc3845dd8177a6bba262e9fbd3814d34631. Fresh setup WNS/TNS are -455.18/-13049600 ns, hold WNS/TNS zero. These new records do not change the attribution of the equal P1 timing values.

The implementation partitions reset across the existing 16 APB targets and one fabric leaf, with five-edge local releases and CPU-last startup. Shared debug wrappers retain default three-stage behavior and Tiny selects five. No FIFO/CDC managed source, Crypto erasure, memory capacity, clock operating point, register/HAL ABI, dependency version or quality policy changes.

Development checks passed both simulators' reset/FIFO fixtures, shared three/five-stage hart reset, Tiny protocol/generator checks, I2C recovery, clock metadata and 128 KiB SRAM protocol/reset readback. The first four-state fixtures lacked a post-elaboration reset edge; their startup failures were fixed in test initialization, not by changing the design. RTL format/style and readiness passed. Common's FIFO and warm-flush fixtures passed in both simulators with output redirected below the candidate build tree.

The initial candidate under build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-06-10-05-19f1e9c571ee/ completed synthesis/STA at aggregate max-delay WNS -94.28 ns and TNS -1594880 ns; min-delay WNS/TNS zero. These native metrics include recovery checks, rather than only data setup. Timing still fails. The worst path is the XPI leaf reset driver's recovery path. The first multi-point audit stopped because Yosys renamed a leaf wire to its APB interface alias. The audit was corrected to resolve actual mapped leaf registers and consumed nets; this partial campaign is not complete feasibility acceptance. A subsequent probe also rejected an invalid Tcl name-escaping expression. The final audit resolves the preserved leaf instances, their actual output-register pins and consumed interface nets without relying on source-level aliases or unsafe name escaping.

Final synthesis/analysis evidence uses build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-06-10-25-19f1e9c571ee/meta/tiny-r2-p2/. feasibility-rke9efn7/report.json completed all 24 source-bound points: two netlists, three corners, and four common SYS periods. Every point retains the exact libraries/SDC, commands, metrics, reset loads/endpoints, CPU/SRAM paths and constraint/coverage reports. No frequency point passed timing.

Corner	Baseline aggregate WNS at 24 MHz (ns)	Candidate aggregate WNS at 24 MHz (ns)	Candidate SYS data setup slack (ns)	Candidate SYS data hold slack (ns)
Slow	-455.18	-94.28	-87.78	0.22
Typical	-299.07	-51.46	-48.16	0.11
Fast	-185.71	-19.94	-19.18	0.02

Candidate corner	SYS96 aggregate WNS (ns)	SYS192 aggregate WNS (ns)	SYS240 aggregate WNS (ns)
Slow	-125.53	-130.74	-131.78
Typical	-82.71	-87.91	-88.96
Fast	-51.19	-56.39	-57.44

The baseline root reset directly drives 17211 loads; the candidate root drives 85 leaf-synchronizer reset pins. All 17 leaf instances and output-register drivers remain distinct. Largest leaf loads are XPI 4710, PWM 4193 and DMA 3212. These residual loads and their recovery/data-path violations remain explicit early feasibility limits, not a routed reset-tree pass. Both netlists retain exactly 32 main macros driven directly by SYS. The fast SRAM/standard-cell temperature mismatch, missing explicit macro minimum period, and ideal-clock, unextracted analysis limitations remain as documented in the runbook.

The fresh baseline reports 207695 cells and 9107192.081398 square micrometers of library area; the final candidate reports 208551 cells and 9109365.619198 square micrometers. These are native balanced-synthesis observations, including normal build-identity constants, not extracted die area or a power claim. Final metric collection retains the unchanged observe policy. Synthetic negative-test result JSONs were initially found by the generic collector below the full-Pytest scratch directory. After tests completed, that directory was moved to the separate ihp130-tiny-2026-10-06-12-38-19f1e9c571ee build variant, with its original path preserved as a symlink. test-fixture-relocation.json records the move and the original metric file; final native firmware, synthesis and timing values are unchanged, and synthetic test flows are excluded.

OpenOCD 0.12.0-1 and the SBT 2.0.5 launcher bundle are restored through the existing locked helper in .cache/retrosoc/development/tiny-r2-p2-debug; P1's environment is unchanged. The initial OpenOCD download's sandbox DNS failure and the initial Mini debug attempt's SBT local-socket permission failure are retained separately. These are environment failures, not hardware acceptance. The retry with locked tools and local-socket permission passed DEBUG_GDB_PASS in 47.323 seconds under build/ihp130-debug-2026-10-06-10-15-b4a322720e40/sim/verilator/debug/. The locked VexiiRiscv project selected sbt 1.10.0 on Ubuntu Java 17.0.18, as recorded in the generation log; its project tool selection was not changed. This validates shared-wrapper default compatibility, not Tiny external JTAG.

The final focused suite passed 45 cases; source format/style/readiness and Ruff passed. The Tiny PR campaign completed with exit zero in 2185.548 seconds under BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-10-06-10-26. Both ordinary RTL simulations passed at 3744281 cycles; Icarus took 1603.291 seconds. Netlist boot passed at 29373 cycles in 147.240 seconds. The PR synthesis and STA commands completed, while warning observations and timing failures retain their existing policy boundary. This is not a full-C netlist or physical pass.

The first full Pytest run recorded 1500 passed, 2 failed, 10 fixture errors and one skipped PDF test. Both root causes were static consumers of the approved reset parameter change: the Tiny publication collector required the old exact three-parameter CPU dictionary, and the debug-flow test required the old unparameterized instance spelling. The collector now explicitly requires ResetSyncStages=5 and includes the reset tree in source tracking; its negative tests reject a wrong stage count and preserve the reviewed-snapshot check. The debug test checks actual parameter forwarding and unchanged default three stages. These compatibility updates do not alter RTL or publication identity; no PDF or publication snapshot is refreshed. The focused consumer suite passed 31 tests. Final full Pytest passed 1517 tests with one skipped PDF retrieval test (pypdf unavailable) in 3624.06 seconds. The initial failed run remains recorded separately; focused and full-suite counts overlap.

consumer-inputs-rv35_5et/identity.json in the final analysis root retains the post-flow consumer/test increment and verifies that every archived RTL, generator, STA and workload source input is unchanged. Original timing inputs and reports are preserved, rather than relabeled with these later test changes.

P1-image Verilator replay passed all three runs under build/ihp130-tiny-2026-10-06-10-27-fa1c4ce1e303/meta/tiny-r2-p1/workloads/verilator/attempt-88f2f259/. All measured records match the original P1 image baseline; terminal cycles increase from 18458948 to 18458959, separately recording the intentional 11-cycle reset-startup change. Icarus attempt workloads/iverilog/attempt-e147iu49 under the same workload root passed all three runs at 18458959 cycles, in 11275.215, 11254.774 and 11341.696 wall seconds. All three logs satisfy command success, TEST_STATUS/SIM_TEST_PASS and forbidden-marker checks. The workload root's meta/tiny-r2-p1/baseline-report.json passed cross-simulator aggregation with the unchanged original HEX and identical measured records. This directory/record retains the P1 measurement protocol identity; its separate RTL-source snapshot identifies the P2 candidate.

Implementation and reproducible P2 evidence are ready for human review. Timing qualification still fails at all analyzed rates, including 24 MHz; the current executable branch is functionally validated, not physically qualified. Full C netlist execution, routed/PVT/IO/package/silicon qualification, exhaustive CDC/RDC and Tiny external-JTAG qualification remain unrun. No standalone formal qualification is claimed; this phase used directed reset/protocol checks and an independent FIFO scoreboard with unchanged Common implementations. No Required-rule MISRA deviation was added. Publication PDF rebuilding and snapshot advancement were not part of the consumer-compatibility repair. No P2 acceptance or later-phase authorization is claimed.

Archived P6/P10 planning and documentation evidence

The remainder of this section preserves the prior planning and P10 document checks under their original phase identifiers. Its P7/P8/P11/P12/P9 labels, three-master topology and main-SRAM-in-MEM clock assumptions are historical, not the active R2 architecture or order. R2-P6/P7/P8/P9 retain the applicable shared-IP, RCU, XPI and DVP acceptance obligations, while R2-P1/P2/P10/P11 carry the outstanding baseline and qualification work. Apply the R2 clock/fabric requirements above when executing those retained tests.

Archived P6/P10 pending Gen1 verification

P6 and P10 were documentation-only. Their recorded execution order was P10 -> P7 -> P8 -> P11 -> P12 -> P9, preserving all P0-P9 phase IDs/titles. The matrix below recorded required implementation and qualification coverage; it recorded no newly executed RTL, firmware, formal, synthesis or timing result. The existing committed IHP130 Tiny profile remained the 24 MHz baseline until implementation introduced reviewed configurations. Pending entries below are historical status, not new R2 results.

Area	Required cases / acceptance	Evidence status
Addresses and software	Match Mini bases for RNG/CRC/WS2812/Crypto/DVP and the SYSCTRL control entry; one RCU decode; unchanged DVP V2 ABI at 0x1000E000/IRQ15; handwritten parity and common drivers with product-selected clock/routing context.	Pending P7/P8/P12
Package and pinmux	Exactly 64 unique perimeter pins, 32 GPIO and 16 power/ground terminals; preserve the P6 perimeter/power table and all assigned alternates; add only GPIO12-23 ALT1 camera functions; 28 distinct GPIO with optional controls; GPIO26 alternate I2C exclusion, audio/camera exclusion, safe reset and default-interface concurrency.	Documentation scope P10; RTL/Pad evidence pending P8/P12/P9
DMA and fabric	Eight channels, Crypto 4/5 and I2S 6/7, serialized channel-3 clients, exclusive camera DMA2/request 11, three AXI32 masters, target/page/alignment errors, backpressure, abort drain and IRQ propagation. Absent DVP remains unsupported before P12; no private DVP master.	Pending P7/P12
Shared IP lifecycle	RNG unqualified/fault/duplicate handling, CRC tails and FINISH after DMA, WS2812 pulse/reset timing, Crypto six-bank init/readback/lock, AES/SHA/RSA vectors, reset/abort/zeroize and no early erasure acknowledgement.	Pending Tiny P7/P9; standalone results remain separately scoped
Clock profiles	Safe24, external XIN24/48/96, PLL192/240 model cases; SYS/MEM/PCLK rates; 1 MHz CLINT continuity; SDIO init at <=400 kHz and 48/48/40 MHz target rates.	Pending P8
Clock commands and failures	Invalid/unsupported profile, partial/unmapped access, busy rejection, drain/CDC timeout, lock timeout, PLL stopped high/low, no mixed profile commit and consistent safe fallback.	Pending P8
Reference loss	Stop XIN and observe loss of REF24/WDG progress; restore the external source and RESET_N before restart; no autonomous recovery claim.	Pending P8/board evidence
Reset and gating	Cold/warm/watchdog/hart/peripheral reset; five-edge local release, CPU-last ordering, WFI/IRQ/debug ungating, gated MMIO error and unilateral CDC reset. Missing AUDIO/PIXCLK and Crypto READY must not block CPU startup; DVP target bit 14 unsupported before actual integration.	Pending P8/P12
Timing-aware shared software	UART/I2C/WS2812 configuration at PCLK24/48/60; PWM CLOCK_HZ matches committed rate; shared-IP upgrade and Mini consumer compatibility; no managed-tree patch or Tiny HAL fork.	Pending shared upgrade/P8
Physical and security qualification	Characterized 96 MHz input receiver, oscillator/PLL/backend, SYS240/MEM120/PCLK60 timing, pixel/serial Pad timing, CDC/RDC, reset fanout, SRAM macros, PVT/post-layout, supply/package/IO integrity, sensor/PSRAM electrical compatibility and qualified entropy source.	Pending P9; no current qualified PLL profile

Each implementation result must identify its source revision, exact profile, PDK/library corner and build variant. Use both supported RTL simulators with the strict SIM_TEST_PASS/result-file policy, then the relevant netlist and physical gates. Run affected Mini regressions for shared changes without using those results as Tiny evidence. Do not remove PLL/STA guards or revise warning/metric baselines to relabel an unsupported or failing flow as passing.

DVP and XPI framebuffer acceptance matrix

All rows below are pending; the P10 freeze does not execute them. Scope each result to the committed IHP130 24 MHz baseline or the exact P8-introduced configuration. Neither an unimplemented profile nor a behavioral PLL result is a physically qualified operating point.

Requirement / phase	Required cases and objective evidence
TINY-022/026, P8/P12	GPIO12-19 data, GPIO20 raw PIXCLK, GPIO21 HREF, GPIO22 VSYNC, GPIO23 CAM_XCLK; preserve GPIO28 ALT0 as the same CLKOUT generator; off after reset, REF24/2=12 MHz, dual-route mirroring and disable-before-change. Verify camera/I2S/PWM conflicts and board inactive-driver isolation.
TINY-024, P11	NSS1/GPIO29, actual 8 MiB reference geometry at 0x54000000..0x547FFFFF within the 64 MiB aperture; device identity/init/reset, read/write LUT, SCK/CS/dummy settings, CPU and central-DMA full readback/CRC plus guard regions. Use the XPI pins, not a substituted RAM or separate controller.
TINY-024/025, P11	First/last device words, allocation end and overflow, 4 KiB and serial boundaries, chosen alignment and bursts up to 16 words, maximum CS duration, wrong/absent device, timeout/abort/reset/reinitialization. Failure must not alter NOR data, boot LUT or mapped-write disable.
TINY-027, P11	Per-profile mapped-write payload throughput and maximum observed backpressure, with recorded clock/LUT/burst/device settings and exercised contention. Use these measurements to define a tested input-rate budget; capacity alone is not a rate bound.
TINY-021/023, P12	Execute existing DVP V2 register/format/framing/IRQ tests; connect APB/IRQ15 and stream request 11 to DMA2; truthful capability before/after integration, no changed FIFO/ABI, no extra master. Mini retains its default channel-3 binding.
TINY-021/024/025, P12	End-to-end RGB565 and YUV422 snapshots/crops; repeated capture; full QVGA (153600-byte) and VGA (614400-byte) external frames at a safe measured rate; SRAM capture only with complete memory budget. Check every output byte, guard regions, DVP statistics and exact DMA byte count.
TINY-025, P12	Allocation larger than frame still programs exact frame length; even cropped width accepted; odd DMA width/insufficient capacity/invalid range rejected before start; odd-width PIO retained. Delay final stream word and AXI write response after DVP frame-done: no early flush, abort or valid-buffer publication.
TINY-025/026, P12	Backpressure/overflow, malformed sync/partial frame, DMA/XPI errors, lost/stopped-high/stopped-low PIXCLK, reset/abort/rearm and audio/camera mode changes. Invalid frames are discarded; accepted AXI work drains or the reset session is explicitly lost. CPU/APB stays usable without PIXCLK; no false reset-done with missing edges/barriers.
TINY-024/027, P12/P9	NOR boot with PSRAM present/absent/failing, SRAM-resident XPI reconfiguration including interrupt paths, capture-then-readback/SDIO-save ordering and explicit blocking-traffic exclusions. Archive tested PIXCLK and margins, not a general FPS guarantee.

The complete DVP -> DMA -> AXI -> XPI -> PSRAM route must execute with a pin-level PSRAM model in Icarus and Verilator and firmware terminal verdicts where applicable. The Verilator --fast-flash backend rejects writes, nonzero slots and modified LUTs; it cannot supply framebuffer evidence. tests/test_psram.py tests a different PSRAM controller, and tests/test_xpi_io.py is a shared PHY/LUT check, not this complete route. tests/test_dvp.py is standalone framing evidence and can return without executing RTL when tools are missing. Check actual simulator execution and pass markers; a collected/skipped/no-op host test is not hardware coverage.

P11/P12 must add integrated cases through the normal test/regression flow, record exact commands and retain full logs, source/profile/PDK identity, guards/readback checks and error snapshots. Reuse the existing PSRAM device model under shared/Tiny verification ownership without importing Mini product RTL or duplicating its controller. Keep hardware coverage separate from host-only length/range/HAL tests, physical device qualification and continuous video delivery. Shared HAL fixes require affected Mini compatibility runs.

P10 documentation checks (2026-10-01)

Local document checks passed: unchanged perimeter/power tables, 64 unique terminal numbers, 32 GPIO with exactly twelve new ALT1 routes, 28 distinct camera-profile GPIO including optional controls, unchanged P0-P9 headings, thirteen unique phase headings and correct frame-byte/KiB/DMA-word arithmetic. The DVP register/stream sections, Tiny 24 MHz baseline and historical executed results below were compared against the preceding revision and are unchanged. All 111 local Markdown links in the nine changed documents passed, and the two camera references were checked against their official sources.

Command selection was checked on Windows using the installed python entry point (python3 resolves to an unavailable Store launcher in this shell); both dry-runs succeeded:

python scripts/regress.py --root . --suite pr --pdk IHP130 --soc TINY --dry-run
python scripts/regress.py --root . --suite nightly --soc TINY --dry-run
git diff --check

The selected profile remains configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk, IHP130, 24 MHz/no PLL. git diff --check passed. P10 changes documentation only: firmware, RTL simulations/formal, synthesis/netlist/STA, full quality/regression suites and physical gates were not run. No C/MISRA deviation, configuration, dependency, warning baseline or metrics policy change is made or implied.

Configuration and artifact roots

The selected profile is configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk: IHP130, 128 KiB SRAM, 24 MHz, RV32IM firmware on an RV32IMC hart with A disabled. Runs below used BUILD_TIMESTAMP=2026-09-25-12-00:

• Default bringup: build/ihp130-tiny-2026-09-25-12-00-d6009644a134/.
• APP=ci_smoke: build/ihp130-tiny-2026-09-25-12-00-044d45791ef7/.
• APP=ci_smoke HAVE_SVA=YES: build/ihp130-tiny-2026-09-25-12-00-6874f2ffdf11/.

Configuration digests identify settings and the dependency lock, not a clean source revision. A release requires rerunning from its reviewed commit.

Functional and quality checks

Check	Evidence/boundary
Tiny maps and source isolation	Generated address, IRQ, pad and clock/reset inputs validate; source closure excludes Mini product RTL, RIB/RIBP and HP generation.
AXI fabric, both simulators	Directed tests cover competing CPU/DMA requests, W-before-AW, delayed W, response backpressure, ID/RLAST, 16-beat bursts, 4 KiB crossing, alignment, reserved regions and continued operation after errors.
Tiny SYSCTRL, both simulators	APB tests cover unsupported controls, partial terminal writes, sticky first status, counter snapshots, first-fault retention, W1C, RTC wake and reset.
Verilator full firmware	SIM_TEST_PASS; the CI composition also passes with SVA enabled. Pin-level NOR, compressed instructions, disabled atomics, load faults, SRAM discovery, memory/UART DMA, external timer IRQ, CLINT time, RTC, GPIO, UART1 loopback, I2C NACK and watchdog reboot are exercised.
Icarus full firmware	Final expanded CI firmware passes at 3,705,751 cycles, matching the SVA-enabled Verilator run.
Icarus synthesized boot	netsim-boot passes at 29,362 cycles using the compact assembly image. Covers pin-level NOR, SRAM first/last words, byte writes, UART and terminal status; does not establish full C-firmware gate-level coverage.
SDK gates	C formatting, embedded-C policy and host tests pass, including Tiny channel/endpoint rejection compiled from the real DMA validator. No new Required-rule MISRA deviation is recorded; these partial checks do not certify MISRA conformance.
Focused Python tests	112 tests passed across Tiny, address/pad generation and build/regression tooling. Shared debug-reset and SRAM/DMA register-parity checks also pass. After fixing parameterization/publication compatibility and preparing the existing MPW/device-model inputs, all 54 non-reference failures selected for rerun pass.
RTL policy	Changed RTL formatting, full owned RTL style audit and readiness metadata pass. Global formatting limitations are listed below.
Reproducibility	Dependency lock validation, Ruff, PR/nightly dry-runs and git diff --check pass. Tiny source packaging exports the Tiny top, actual filelist and its core timing SDC.

The full-firmware verdict is authoritative only when both the tool result and result-sim-check.json pass. UART text alone is not sufficient. Assembly netlist acceptance uses the same strict terminal marker policy.

Synthesis and timing

For the CI composition, Yosys completed with the IHP130 technology libraries and 32 tc_sram_1024x32 banks. The balanced report records 207,739 cells and 9,798,326.725198 square micrometers of library area. The area includes the instantiated memory/pad hierarchy and is not a placed die-area estimate.

OpenSTA completed with the selected slow library corner and the 41.666666667 ns system clock. Reported setup WNS is -455.18 ns, setup TNS is -13,049,600 ns, and hold WNS/TNS are zero. The worst path starts at the synchronized system-reset register and reaches peripheral FIFO storage through the high-fanout reset distribution. This is an open physical/timing issue; 24 MHz is a functional target, not a timing-qualified operating point.

Reports reside under the CI variant's syn/yosys/rpt/ and sta/opensta/. The metric collector understands the Tiny top and timestamp-prefixed Yosys JSON reports. Metrics remain in observe mode; no warning or metric baseline has been edited to accept this feature.

Commands and remaining coverage

The build/verification commands were run with the profile and timestamp above:

make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk doctor firmware sim
make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk APP=ci_smoke HAVE_SVA=YES firmware sim
make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk APP=ci_smoke SIMU=IVERILOG firmware sim
make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk APP=ci_smoke SYNTH=YOSYS synth
make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk APP=ci_smoke SIMU=IVERILOG netsim-boot
make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk APP=ci_smoke STA=OPENSTA sta
make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk metrics package
make sw-format-check sw-policy-check sw-host-test rtl-style-check-all rtl-readiness-check
python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_tiny.py tests/test_memory_map.py tests/test_pin_map.py tests/test_script_tools.py
python3 scripts/regress.py --root . --suite pr --pdk IHP130 --netsim-boot-only

The combined IHP130 regression stops in its Mini phase because the locked VexiiRiscv checkout is absent. Tiny can be selected independently with --soc TINY, or make CONFIG=configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk regress-pr. The initial full Pytest run completed with 1,234 passed, 26 failed, 19 skipped and 71 errors. Parameterization/format-sensitive expectations and the Mini publication's constant/cast parsing were corrected; the affected cases were rerun successfully. MPW/device-model inputs and a writable test ccache resolved additional environment failures. The remaining 16 cases require the absent locked FLAC corpus, MLPerf Tiny models or TensorFlow oracle sources. These are not Tiny setup dependencies. The full suite was not rerun after the focused corrections; it is not reported as a clean full-suite pass.

The initial run, focused results, combined-regression failure and remaining reference-input case list are retained under the CI variant's meta/validation/. Global RTL/Make formatting checks encounter existing APU/accelerator files outside this change. Changed-file formatting is checked independently.

Remaining qualification includes reset-tree/timing closure, placement/routing, PVT/MMMC, CDC/RDC signoff, silicon and power measurements, full C netlist acceptance, a Tiny-specific external OpenOCD session, positive external I2C slave transactions and comprehensive pad-level PWM/RTC coverage. Wireless, retention, secure boot and other PDKs remain explicit deferred features.

Shared-path migration follow-up

Mini now references the canonical shared RTL, scripts/rtl helpers and rtl/mk/software.mk directly. The 21 Mini compatibility links and seven Tiny helper links have been removed. Filelists, simulator/formal/synthesis rules, Python imports, tests, publication tooling and ownership documents use the new paths. No Git file-type changes remain. Historical warning baselines are unchanged.

The resolved Mini commonip.fl, ip.fl and top.fl retain the same 299 unique sources in the same order. netlist_support.fl retains its two sources; inc.fl adds rtl/ip/core. All relocated shared RTL content hashes match the pre-migration snapshot. This follow-up changes paths, not RTL behavior or the public hardware/software interface.

Validation after removing the links:

• 245 focused tests passed: 144 build/generator/topology/style/Tiny tests, 96 publication/LibreLane tests and five debug-reset/SRAM simulations. Full-suite collection succeeds with 1,356 tests; the full suite was not rerun because of the reference-input gaps documented above.
• Mini configs/ci/ihp130.mk address/pad/topology/clock-reset checks and firmware build pass. Its Verilator compile reaches HP generation and stops because the locked VexiiRiscv checkout is missing; full Mini simulation and the combined regression remain unverified.
• Tiny configs/ci/ihp130-tiny.mk, APP=ci_smoke HAVE_SVA=YES, firmware and Verilator simulation pass again at 3,705,751 cycles. Full Icarus, synthesis and STA were not repeated for this path-only follow-up.
• Eleven Python CLI entrypoints work outside the repository directory. Mini SRAM formal filelist generation, sv2v conversion, filelist combination and dependency generation pass using the canonical shared paths, including the relocated SRAM header. Formal proofs were not rerun.
• Ruff, owned RTL style, readiness metadata, 251 local Markdown links and git diff --check pass. The Make formatter still reports existing EOF and formal-command indentation differences in APU/GA2D/formal fragments; those unrelated differences were preserved.

Run logs, exact commands and path snapshots are retained under build/ihp130-2026-09-25-12-00-9903b3d112b7/meta/validation/shared-path-migration/. No C register/API change or additional MISRA deviation belongs to this follow-up; the SDK gates from the implementation record above were not rerun.

Next review

Use $retrosoc-feature-review in review mode for feature tiny-soc with Target SoCs: TINY. Review the current worktree diff against docs/ip/tiny-soc.md and docs/ip/tiny-soc-verification.md. Verify Tiny isolation, default Mini compatibility, AXI/APB/error/reset behavior and the SDK ABI. Treat the observed reset-fanout timing deficit and missing APU/NPU/VexiiRiscv inputs as explicit qualification gaps; do not claim timing closure or alter warning/metric baselines.